Sunday, April 12, 2009

Dead Cat Bounce - and other animals

I’ve never actually seen a dead cat bounce, so I don’t know if its trajectory resembles that of the stock market in a brief rebound such as last week’s. But the financial world is very fond of these rather brutal animal metaphors. “Bull markets” are so called because when bulls attack they toss their victims up in the air. Bears, on the other hand, beat down with their paws, hence “bear market”. Leaves you with the image of a cat being tossed about by bulls and bears as they beat it to death. Which is pretty much how you feel if you have your pension invested in the stock market.

“Stags” are aggessive speculators who “flip” or buy and sell undervalued shares before anyone notices. And the slump has added more exotic creatures to the financial bestiary, like “vulture funds” - which pick over the carrion left lying around by the bears. And my special favourite, “bottom feeders”, City slang for investors who discretely buy shares at the bottom of a bear market. Yum.

Bottom feeders are no doubt hoping that “quantitiative easing” will get the market moving. QE, is a vaguely medical metaphor designed to divert attention from what the Bank of England is actually doing, which is printing money to encourage inflation. The Bank would rather you thought of gentle laxatives clearing the blockage. Another diversionary image is “tax haven” designed to make you think of poor harassed capitalists seeking asylum from the big bad taxman. In fact tax havens run tax avoidance schemes where “shadow banks” “speculate” on “derivatives” dreamed up by “rocket scientists”.

Actually, many rocket scientists - physicists and mathematicians - really were attracted to work in the financial world in the 80s and 90s by the big rewards to for devising ever more complex ways of making money. Like the infamous “Black-Scholes option-pricing model”, which was supposed to guarantee profits in any market, but, er, didn’t. It's now called the "black holes" model.

"Hedge funds" - as in hedging bets - created “short sellers” who borrow shares in a company they think is about to collapse and then sell them back at a lower price making a profit on the difference. “Naked short sellers” don’t even borrow the shares in the first place. Then there are wonderfully opaque concepts like “backwardation”, a market in which futures prices are higher in the early delivery months, not to be confused with “contango” where prices are higher in the later delivery months. Wake up at the back there! You’ll be tested on this.

There is “balloon maturity”, and “boning” which is charging a lot more than an asset is worth. “Bootstrapping” and the “barbell strategy” are more or less what they sound like. Which brings us to the most important financial term of all, which applies to all of the above, namely: “b@llocks”.

Margaret Thatcher. My Part In Her Downfall

As with the assassination of John F. Kennedy, everyone of a certain age remembers where they were the morning after Margaret Thatcher was elected prime minister thirty years ago. I was a university research student on loan to the BBC and scheduled to join an occupation of the site of the proposed Torness nuclear power plant in East Lothian - an appropriately lost cause for the day that marked the Left’s greatest post war defeat.

Demonstrators and journalists swapped gallows humour - “Chile this morning, isn’t it” - sensing that, with the election of the right-wing housewife superstar, things really had changed. None of us realised quite how much. Margaret Thatcher was far more of a revolutionary than any of the anti-capitalists at Torness. She changed Britain, and the world, and altered the way we think about politics and society. Love her or loathe her, we are all Thatcher’s children.

There was an inevitability about the Tory victory in 1979. Nothing was working. The country had just emerged from the Winter of Discontent, as the tabloids dubbed the great public sector strikes when “the dead lay unburied and rubbish uncollected in the streeets” - allegedly. What was certainly true was that the Labour prime minister, James Callaghan had made a disastrous decision in delaying a general election which he would probably have won in autumn 1978. By April 1979 Labour was forced to fight a campaign in the teeth of rising unemployment and industrial strife largely caused by Callaghan’s own public sector cuts. Curiously, Gordon Brown seems to have opted for much the same electoral strategy today.

The Tories deployed the most succesful advertising campaign in election history: “Labour Isn’t Working”. The dole queue in the Saatchi and Saatchi poster was in fact a photoshopped line of Hendon Young Conservatives - not many people know that. Nor did people know that under Margaret Thatcher, unemployment was about to rise to levels not seen in Britain since the 1930s, as Britain plunged into the deepest manufacturing recession since the war. Unemployment rose over three million and devastated Scotland's industrial communities. “Bathgate no more, Linwood no more...” sang The Proclaimers, as Scotland experienced the kind of social chaos that was to hit Russia in the 1990s. We’re still living with the legacy today in the high rates of heart disease, depression and alcoholism in West Central Scotland.

But Scotland was never high on Margaret Thatcher’s priority list. Her horizons were and as wide as the world as deep as history. She wanted to “abolish socialism” at home and defeat communism abroad. Incredibly, she arguably did both, and at the same time gave her name to a new “ism”: Thatcherism - a political phiosophy founded on deregulated financial markets, privatisation of state assets, sales of council homes and dismantling of the welfare state. Thatcherism wasn’t just an economic policy, however, it was a social psychology based on possessive individualism. It was about getting as much as possible for yourself and your family and then letting the rest of the world go hang. “There's no such thing as society” she said in her most magisterial soundbite, and while she insists that she didn’t mean it literally, actually she did. And she largely succeeded, too, in destroying collectivism, a form of social solidarity that had endured in large parts of Britain since the Second World War.

Thatcher sensed intuitively that the key to breaking communitarian ties was home ownership. Before 1979, the sale of council houses had been regarded as a fantasy of the looney right. But she went right ahead and did it, and by ushering in the age of mass home ownership - “the property owning democracy” - she turned Britain into a nation of property speculators. Homes, once just places to live, became assets to be traded, used as a private fortress of personal wealth - and ultimately served as vehicles of speculation by the banks. In 1979, when Thatcher came to power, fewer people in Scotland owned their own homes than in Communist Poland. Now, nearly seventy percent of us are owner-occupiers. Ask long serving trades unionists why workers are so reluctant to go on strike these days and they will often say: mortgages.

Thatcher realised that to destroy socialism she had to destroy the political power of the industrial working class. She was more of a Marxist than most people on the far Left, which had fragmented into a litter of splinter groups arguing about obscure points of dogma. Few people in the media believed that Thatcher could possibly succeed with her scorched earth policy of destroying the unions through high interest rates, industrial closures and mass unemployment. “She’ll end up like Heath”, we snorted, “doing a U-turn and resorting to incomes policy, states subsidies and inflation”. But “the lady wasn’t for turning” and she broke the unions, and Labour, on the wheel of joblessness, and paid the bills using Scottish oil revenues. She wisely left the miners to last, confronting them on her own terms in 1984.

Everyone underestimated Thatcher’s resolve to deregulate and break the power of the state. Like council house sales, privatisation had been a preserve of right wing think tanks like the Adam Smith Institute. Most economists beleived that a modern economy required significant state ownership to regulate the free market. Not Thatcher. Starting with BT and British Gas, she launched a firesale of nationalised industries, getting the British public to buy companies they already owned. “Tell Sid” said the advert alerting the nation to the new opportunities of “popular capitalism”. Businessmen like Richard Branson became celebrities.

She also ignited the “Big Bang” in the City of London - a wave of deregulation which opened the way to the ‘anything goes’ era of financial buccaneering. The great misselling scandals - endowment mortgages, personal pensions, ';with profits' insurance bonds - all had their origins in the 1980s. Commission-driven “independent” financial advisers developed ever-more ingenious “financial products”. One of Thatcher’s earliest acts was to break the link between the state pension and average earnings. In future they would rise with inflation. This apparently technical move ensured that the value of the state pension would wither to next to nothing, forcing people to seek security in private pension provision.

Her ultimate objective was to privatise health and education, but she never managed to achieve that, leaving it to her successor. When Lady Thatcher was asked recently what her greatest legacy was, she said: Tony Bliar. Apocryphal it may be, but it is a compliment he is willing to reciprocate. New Labour was built on the foundations laid by Thatcherism. Blair promoted wealth as a virtue and subjected public services to market disciplines. Local authority bureaucrats started awarding themselves mega salaries; Chancellor Gordon Brown endlessly praised the City of London; MPs turned their political offices into a source of personal enrichment.

While Thatcher destroyed socialism at home by making Tony Blair inevitable, abroad she stiffened the resolve of Ronald Reagan - the hawkish US Republican President - to confront communism by placing a new generation of nuclear weapons in Europe. Cruise and Pershing 11 missiles ensured that any tank-led invasion by the Warsaw Pact would lead immediately to nuclear war. It was an extraordinary escalation of the arms race, and led to a revival of the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament in Britain. It is hard for people under he age of 45 to appreciate quite what life was like under the Cold War. Nuclear annihilation was a very real threat in hte 80's which coloured many peoples’ lives and inspired the savage humour of cartoonists like Steve Bell.

In the end, of course, it wasn’t missiles but consumerism and that killed communism. It was the visible economic success of the West in the 80’s, and its libertarian youth culture. that rotted the authoritarian regimes of Eastern Europe and led their citizens to tear down Berlin Wall. However, it is an inconvenient truth for the Left that many anti-communist radicals were genuinely inspired by Margaret Thatcher. From the Gdansk shipyard worker Lech Walensa in Poland to the Czech president/playwrite, Vaclav Havel - who presented the “Iron Lady” with an award for her role in bringing down the Iron Curtain - Margaret Thatcher was a beacon of freedom.

Perhaps it is only now, at the twilight of Thatcherism that we can begin to understand her true historical significance. There's an epic quality to everything about the Thatcher story. She was the last British prime minister to launch a shooting war against a foreign power - 8,000 miles away in the South Atlantic over the Falklands Islands. Who dares wins, and she did - though it was close. She woudl have declared war too on the European Union if her party had let her.

And there is a Wagnerian quality, now to the collapse of Thatcherism and the fall of its Gods. The origins of the greatest economic depression in a hundred years lay in May 1979 when she became prime minister. The economic engine she created, based on the unrestrained accumulation of wealth and deregulated financial markets, turned into an uncontrollable global juggernaut which has just careered over a cliff. Almost everything that has gone wrong with the neoliberal model - the housing bubble, the bonus culture, fraudulent derivatives, tax havens, financial speculation, the collapse of manufacturing - all had their origins in the Thatcher revolution thirty years ago. When Cameron Tories today talk of the “broken society” what they are really talking about is the society of rampant individualism and moral anarchy created by their own former leader.

Sir Fred Goodwin is the ultimate Thatherite - a sociophathic individualist who values personal enrichment even above self-respect; who is so dedicated to financial gain that he is willing to be cast as a pariah, loathed for his destructive greed. But then the truth is that we all became just a little infected with Thatcherism during the “me generation”. We privately gloried in the apparently ever-rising value of our homes; got vicarious enjoyment from the fantasy capitalism of “The Apprentice”; laughed at the antics of anti-social petrolheads like Jeremy Clarkson. The devil had all the best tunes during the Thatcher era - but unfortunately he was still the devil. And now that we face an era of social and economic chaos, against a background of runaway climate change, we will all have time to repent at leisure for our flirtation with Grantham’s most famous daughter.

Tuesday, April 07, 2009

G20 Or Whatever...

What a pantomime. Black Range Rovers, fancy frocks, the Queen dwarfed by the Obamas, the obligatory gaffe from the Duke of Edinburgh, Sarko being unfashionably late. The official engagements at the G20 were much weirder than the anarchist street parties outside, which have developed a kind of formality of their own. The massed ranks of Metropolitan Police performing the traditional truncheon display after the ceremonial trashing of RBS windows. They should put it on the social calendar.

But what were we all supposed to make of these shiny happy world leaders at their dinners and receptions? I was reminded of the film, Titanic. The unsinkable ship was a kind of metaphor for Edwardian society before the First World War. In the state lounges and dining halls, the great and the good carried on with their elaborate social rituals unaware that they were heading for an iceberg. They continued to go through the motions even as the ship went down.

The G20 managed to rearrange rather more than the deck chairs, but did nothing to solve the fundamental design flaws. It was an exercise in collective morale boosting, keeping spirits up, a group hug. But as they tucked into Jamie Oliver’s Scottish Salmon, world trade was sinking beneath them faster than at any time since the second world war. The IMF last week doubled its forecast of losses from the US banking crisis to $2.2 trillion. Three thousand jobs losses were announced in Britain alone on the day of the official G20 communiqué - and the UK recession has hardly begun.

Of course, we shouldn’t wallow in negativity. One trillion dollars from the richest nations will help. Though it is mostly going to the IMF to provide loans to countries in Eastern Europe that are falling like skittles - and perhaps to Britain which is wobbling alarmingly. Tax havens will become more transparent, and there is help for exporters. But this was no comprehensive solution to the global slump and to be fair none of the participants pretended its was. The only really significant intellectual contribution came from the Chinese who proposed a new international reserve currency to replace the dollar. In terms of Geopolitics, the G20 did mark a watershed with the Asians looking beyond the era of American economic and military hegemony.

As an event, the G20 was a presentational coup for Gordon Brown, perhaps even the CV for his next job. He is surely up for a plum role in international banking after this display, and it may not be long before he’s on the job market. Expectations were carefully lowered in advance of the summit so that almost any agreement could be hailed as a triumph. The threatened ‘walk out’ by the French if Anglo-Saxon capitalism wasn’t curbed was pure theatre badly acted.

The truth is that no one really knows how to curb Anglo Saxon globalisation, because regulation takes place within national jurisdictions. There is as yet no international body capable of reining in the trillions of dollars that flow uncontrolled around the world financial markets. Similarly, a “whatever it takes” fiscal stimulus was being proposed by the countries least able to afford one: Britain and America. The idea of massively increasing debt in order to solve a crisis caused by debt is simply untenable. Obama and Brown must know this, so they were probably quite glad to have their ‘hands tied’ by the Europeans.

The smiley world leaders returned home to industrial closures, mass redundancies and mounting public and private debt. The banks aren’t lending, and the G20 will do nothing to change that. National governments have handed hundreds of billions of public funds to irresponsible and unreformed financial institutions through various schemes to buy their toxic assets. And the state-funded banks already up to their old tricks - incredibly using public money to buy up their own toxic assets; still paying dividends and bonuses; ignoring the environment. RBS, which is 80% state owned, has used £10 billion of the £30 billion it received from the UK taxpayer to invest in fossil fuel projects.

Somehow the world has to create an international financial governance with the power to regulate the international banks and curb speculation. A reformed International Monetary Fund could have the responsibility of overseeing the creation of a true international currency unit, against which all others will be measured. This is a big ask, but by no means impossible. . If Europe could introduce the Euro, then the world can introduce Bancor - which was what Keynes proposed to call the international currency in 1946. A common global currency is the only way to address the problem of currency chaos and financial anarchy.

The £250bn in Special Drawing Rights agreed at the G20 are a move in the right direction. An international currency would not only bring stability and permit international regulation, it could also be used to generate loans to the African continent and other parts of the non-developed world. This is a matter, not of charity, but of self-interest for the West because the development of Africa will create new markets and new wealth to replac what is being lost in the global depression. After spending trillions rescuing insolvent banks, America and Britain can never again say that the money isn’t there for this global stimulus.

The other international priority is of course climate change which hardly got a mention at the G20. Again, this is in our global interest- we don’t want to fry - and also in our economic interest, since it could be the biggest engine of job creation in history. The development of renewables, the scrubbing and storage of carbon, the rebuilding of the housing stock, extending public transport and researching nuclear fusion could create new markets and investment opportunities.

Capitalism both destroys and creates. It has created greater material prosperity than ever in human history, but it has entered a destructive phase of the cycle as the excesses of the debt boom are swept away. It is also destroying the environment because the impact on the planet is not costed. However, capitalism goes where it is allowed to go. International regulation and specific climate goals could provide the foundation for another global economic boom, based on creative entrepreneurialism and sound finance.

This is not visionary or futuristic. Most people who have looked at the problem, from Sir Nicholas Stern to George Soros, have come to the same conclusion. The problem is simply getting from here to there. A small step was taken along the road in London this week. We can only hope, as Mao said, that the journey of a thousand miles begins with one step.

Monday, April 06, 2009

toile humour

Embra's annual culture fest was renamed the "Nedinburgh Festival" last week, thanks to the work of Glasgow graphic designers, Timorous Beasties. Their low life toile, used for the EIF bags and brochures, depicted drunks and ne’erdooweels instead of tartan and pipers. The shock!

'Toile' as i’m sure you know is the smudgy 18th Century French style of interior design, “toile du Jouy”. Only the Glasgow boys replaced the charming rustic scenes with episodes from everyday Edinburgh life, like gadgies urinating over Greyfriars Bobby's fountain and dossers lying beneath a statue of David Hume wearing a traffic cone on his head. Also featured were tower blocks and road works.

Actually they missed out on quite a few images from contemporary Edinburgh , such as scumbag bankers being stoned by angry citizens as they make off with their bonuses. Or estate agents beaten-up by bankrupt homeowners who can't sell. Or knickerless matrons in Range Rovers running over pedestrians as they pick up offspring from their expensive schools. Maybe next time.

The toile was of course a publicity-seeking exercise by the promoters of the Edinburgh Festvial, and it worked a treat. Not since they wheeled a nude across the organ gallery of the McEwan Hall in 1963 have we heard such moral outrage from the city fathers and mothers. The Tory MSP David McLetchie suggested it was all a Glasgow plot to do down Edinburgh. Presumably no one told him that the Beastie boys had already soiled the Second City's image with a Glasgow toile depicting drug addicts shooting up and prostitutes plying their trade.

The wallpaper is currently selling for £250 a roll and reportedly walking out the shop, which just goes to show what people will put on their walls these days. The toile style is most associated with the transvestite potter, Grayson Perry who used it on ceramics to depict rape, child abuse and homosexual congress. His work now sells for phenomenal sums and Perry is regarded as a significant artistic figure.

So how about a little recognition for the subjects of the Timorous Beastie toile? Pishing over monuments is clearly a new and exciting performance art and the vagrants and drunks should apply for an arts council grant. The traffic cone on David Hume’s head is probably worth a couple of million already and should be guarded by a special detachment from the National Gallery. The notorious roadworks in Princes Street should be renamed “Stasis Tramwerk” and billed Europe’s biggest modern art installation. People would flock to see it. Well, I’ve seen a lot worse in the Turbine hall of the Tate Modern

Monday, March 30, 2009

Dunfermline disaster - many dead

Another one bites the dust. Scotland's largest building society the Dunfermline, has collapsed amid the usual cries of betrayal, London perfidy and financial obfuscation. I have a scintilla of sympathy for the combative Chairman, Jim Faulds, who genuinely seems to believe in the mutual principle – but why then did the Dunfermline abandon it in favour of speculation? He and his executives will be reaching for their golden parachutes this morning and filling their pension pots, so save your concern for the 500 employees. And for the taxpayer - the bank of you and me – which gets handed the bill for Dunfermline's toxic assets.

And from a supposedly boring building society, for heaven's sake! I seem to recall Dunfermline boasting that it was so prudent in its lending that it just didn't “do” mortgage repossessions. Now we learn that it has been heavily involved in a variety of sub prime investments, and was lending 100% mortgages even as the Scottish housing market slumped. We had been told repeatedly that this conservative institution was well-capitalised and solvent until, er, it wasn't. A reported loss of £26m became £50m, then £100m, then think-of-a-number-and-double-it.

It was the same story with HBOS and RBS – everyone insists until the very last moment that there is nothing to worry about, perfectly safe, sound business, riddle diddle - and then, bang, the institution crashes into oblivion taking billions of public money with it. Misinforming investors about the financial health of a company should surely be against the law. Perhaps Gordon Brown, who has the privilege of having Dunfermline in his constituency backyard, could suggest this to the G20 this week as one of his new regulatory reforms.

And while we're at it, what on earth was a mutual society, which is supposed to finance mortgage loans from retail deposits, doing buying dodgy mortgages from the American bank GMAC – notorious for the unreliability of its sub-prime assets? A building society is supposed to be owned by its depositors. Did they know about the &##163;650m in commercial property deals? Or its exposure to ambitious IT investments? Or that Dunfermline was in bed with Lehman Brothers, one of the most hard-nosed and aggressive Wall St. investment banks? And don't give me the line that: “Oh we didna ken; we're just wee folk fae Fife”. Well they ken noo.

I agree that the HBOS and RBS bail outs were an even greater reward for failure and should never have happened - but three wrongs don't make a right. Nationalisation or administration were the only realistic options. The Treasury has blown so much money bailing out the dysfunctional banks, there's no way it was going to establish a precedent by bank-rolling dud building societies as well.

That this is a further nail in the coffin of the Scottish financial services 'industry' hardly needs to be said. The coffin has been nailed so hard there's barely any wood left. What happened to prudence? And how did a nation renowned for thrift and financial caution come to be cursed by such a disreputable and incompetent financial elite? Two of the most toxic banks on the planet have our names on them: Royal Bank of Scotland and Halifax Bank of Scotland. Sir Fred Goodwin has become an international icon of stupidity, recklessness and greed. Nor do I subscribe to the view that it is my patriotic duty defend bosses of Dunfermline Building Society just because they happen to be Scottish.

We thought Alex Salmond had learned to sup with a longer spoon in his dealings with bankers, but here he goes again, pleading for a rescue, defending the indefensible, blaming London. As Dunfermline is broken up, you can be sure that the FSA and the Treasury will make clear just how reckless was the behaviour of its executives. The briefings have already begun. So why expend political capital on trying to save them? Yes, I know that there are jobs at stake and there is a risk that another head office will go south. But these jobs have been destroyed, not by the Treasury, but by the Dunfermline Building Society which believed its own propaganda about Scotland being immune to the property crash.

Being an apologist for busted financial institutions undermines the authority of the First Minister's office The same happened with HBOS when the FM leapt to accuse the “spivs and speculators” for its share collapse, until we discovered that the worst spivs and speculators we're in HBOS itself. Then Alex Salmond doggedly supported Fred Goodwin's Royal Bank of Scotland, which he assured us was a robust, well-capitalised and highly profitable business – until it needed the biggest rights issue in corporate history, and then the biggest government bail-out in history. We keep hearing about how Gordon Brown should be apologising for failing to realise how bad our bad banks really were, but I haven't heard much contrition from the First Minister.

Of course political leaders can't go around talking down the economy and RBS and HBOS were two of Scotland's biggest employers. But nor can they allow themselves to appear to be captured by one sectional interest. FForget Sandi Thom's expenses, the real scandal is how Scotland is now forever branded as home of the world's worst bankers - Scottish government approved.

These motley fools have largely destroyed Scotland's economy and now our biggest building society. The Dunfermline executives do not deserve to be bailed out and rewarded for this failure. Every one of them should have had the decency to have resigned by now. They deluded themselves into thinking that if they played the FSA long enough, and enlisted the political support of the Scottish government, that they would be bailed out like the big retail banks. But that was never going to happen. Dunfermline Building Society is not 'too big to fail' and they should have realised that before entering the speculative poker game.

No one regrets the loss of yet another mutual society more than I do., but they should have kept their noses clean - in the interests of their members if nothing else. They, not the executives, have been betrayed. Dunfermline is a dead parrot, it has gone to meet its maker, if it hadn't been concealing its losses it would be pushing up the daisies. It is a late building society. The end.

Sunday, March 22, 2009

Farewell Darling Jade

And so farewell then, Jade Goody, the brave and brilliant mum who did it all for her family and for victims of cancer, Her story is a parable for our modern times. A death to give us all hope. Read all about it on pages 2,3,4,5,6,7, including Jade’s last words and Jack’s hospital romps with dying star. Ok, I’m making that up - but only just. Every detail of Jade’s final days will no doubt be revealed under the various contracts negotiated by her agents. Her own memorial edition of OK magazine, "Jade Goody, 1981 - 2009, Official Tribute, was published with her consent even before she died. You couldn’t make that up.

The celebrity death watch on this unfortunate young woman was certainly a sign of the times. A defining moment in the history of celebrity culture, a tabloid Passion. After a benediction from the red-top Pope, Max Clifford, plastic surgeons and perfume manufacturers will carry her coffin to lie in state in the diary room, as the paparazzi fire off a 24 bulb salute. Her partner, Jack, will stand in state, accompanied by his probation officers. The Sun has opened a condolence book and is offering cash prizes to the sauciest entries. A statue of Jade Goody will be erected in the Big Brother garden.

I know we shouldn’t speak ill of the dead, and I don’t intend to, even though someone who sold their own terminal illness to the popular press can’t expect to be treated lightly by posterity. But in her departure, Jade Goody, did achieve some kind of grace and a certain nobility. The government has promised to review the minimum age for cervical cancer screening, so in a real sense her death may allow others to live. She donated some of the proceeds of her celebrity wedding to charity, so the slumdog millionairess has the moral edge on the scumbag bankers like ‘Sir’ Fred Goodwin.

But the beatification of Jade Goody is something else - it is a dubious celebration of the crass culture of the early 21st Century. The coverage of her decline was as undignified as it was tasteless - death as reality television. The attempts now to elevate her to a kind of underclass sainthood are deeply unattractive, even if they are well intentioned. Jade Goody can only ever be the patron saint of stupid; a product of a media that celebrates ignorance; a reflection of a society devoid of moral purpose. Her place in history is assured as one of the defining characters of the money-for-nothing bubble years when we lost any sense of real worth.

Jade Goody’s life was stranger than any fiction. A former dental nurse who rose to national prominence for thinking East Anglia was abroad and that Rio de Janeiro was a footballer became the ultimate celebrity - famous for being famous. The commercial endorsements followed her appearance on Big Brother in 2002 - where she succeeded in coming fourth - as did the boob jobs and beatings; the therapy and the dysfunctional relationships. After a few years the tabloids began to lose interest in the woman they had taken to calling the “fat pig”. Though she made many millions before her disastrous comeback appearance in 2007.

From being famous for being famous Jade Goody became infamous for being infamous. Her racist taunts of one of the Big Brother contestants, Shilpa Shetty, became a national issue, debated in parliament no less, and led to her being vilified by the media that had invented her. Worse, for a product of the L’Oreal age, she was dropped by the cosmetics industry because she really wasn’t worth it. She tried to rehabilitate herself by appearing on Bollywood Big Brother in India, but here it was that she met her fate, with the discovery that she had cervical cancer.

In a savage irony, this turned out to be Jade Goody’s best career move. As her battle with cancer progressed her earning power recovered. Soon she was Brave Jade, a mother doing all and selling all for her children. But only through death could she achieve tabloid redemption, and as the end drew nigh a macabre auction ensued as various populist organs bid for pieces of her final story. I suppose by the get-rich standards of modern times, her decision to exploit her illness was curiously admirable. If moral worth is to be measured by how much money you make, then what could be more worthy than getting it while you still can?

The scary thing, though, is that an entire generation of young women may now start seeing the late Jade Goody as a role model, as an inspiration. We already know that far too many young people, when asked what they want to be when they grow up, say: “famous”, as if celebrity is a career option. They want to be Paris Hilton or Jordan or any number of attention-seeking surgical freaks. Will young girls now model their careers on Jade Goody? If so, how do you emulate this modern paragon? Presumably by learning nothing, earning anything, making an exhibition of yourself and turning your death into a media circus.

Of course, this is not the time to attack Jade Goody just for being what she was. But it is a time to think very seriously about the society that made her. She was always excused her excesses on the grounds that Jade was ‘just being herself’. Her authenticity was her justification, even though almost everything about her was contrived - even her weight loss was based on lipo-suction rather than the exercise and diet regime she sold in her videos. She may have been dumb, but at public relations she was a genius.

But it all had to end. And as the 21 car funeral cortege winds its way through Bermondsey to the “ultimate party” planned to celebrate her life, comparisons will inevitably be drawn with the funeral of Diana Princess of Wales in 1997. It will be a morbid satire on the entire celebrity industry. Diana was the Peoples Princess, Jade was the Empress of the Estates. May they both rest in peace.

Friday, March 20, 2009

something fishy in holyrood

MSPs often complain that they’re living in a goldfish bowl, so it's good to see them standing up for their fellow fish. The Holyrood petitions committee has asked the Scottish government to look into the welfare of Siamese fighting fish in Scotland’s pet shops. Apparently, these exotic creatures, which hail from Thailand, are suffering from obesity and lack of social interaction. Pretty much like the rest of the population in fact.

The petitions committee was responding to public representations on aquarium living arrangements. But the fishy tale hooked the sourer sections of the Scottish press, who’re always on the lookout for loony legislation - like not boiling lobsters or banning foie gras. When the economy is collapsing, cried the Fourth Estate, how dare Holyrood waste time on the fate of overweight fish with psychological disorders!

Actually, the question is really one for the press itself to answer: why did we devote so much time, editorials, comment and column inches to such a trivial tale? Aren’t there better things to write about? Scottish children are suffering worse obesity even than Siamese fighting fish, so why not more editorials about that? The answer of course is that row over betta splendens, as the fish are properly called, was a welcome relief from the economic gloom, and allowed punning subs to run pictures of exotic fish under “storm in a goldfish bowl” headlines. Commentators took a populist pop at Holyrood, for being a waste of space.

It also gave the many sane and well-balanced folk who post comments on newspaper websites a chance to vent their spleens - and boy do they have spleens to vent. Only in the Scottish blogosphere could the fate of gold fish be turned into a constitutional issue, with Labour and SNP trolls biffing each other over what the affair tells us about the legitimacy of the Scottish government. Many comments had to be removed because they were offensive.

Mind you, some of the less poisonous posts were really rather funny. The apparent antisocial behaviour of the fighting fish is down to the availability of cheap drink, said one poster, and the Justice Minister should be looking into the problem. Another suggested that feeding the fat fish to the fat cats could solve two problems at once. But that’s quite enough wit from the web - we don’t want to put ourselves out of a job

I know it's boring but the welfare of animals is actually a responsibility of the parliament under numerous statutes like the Animal Health and Welfare Act. The petitions committee was only doing its job. A democratic parliament has a duty to take seriously issues that are presented to it by voters if there is evidence the law is not being upheld. But then I suppose that’s another kettle of fish.

Sunday, March 15, 2009

Terrible Tavish

The Liberal Democrats never do things by halves. They prefer to do them by quarters and fifths. As on alcohol pricing which seems to be wrong in Scotland but right in England. And on the constitution, where the Scottish Liberal Democrat leader, Tavish Scott has called for radical constitutional change to save the Scottish economy. But not TERRIBLY radical change. The Libdems want taxation and borrowing powers for Holyrood to allow the Scottish government to finance a bold green job creation programme to counter the recession. But this is not to be confused with the SNP’s call for tax and borrowing powers and its counter-recessionary Green Deal. Oh no - that would be secession.

And don’t think there should be any kind of referendum on the Calman Commission on the Constitution, when it finally delivers the constitutional blueprint. The Liberal Democrats are utterly and completely opposed to referendums - except, er, in England and on Europe. The party is committed to a referendum on constitutional reform in Westminster, including reducing Scottish representation, in the first year of any Liberal Democrat administration. They also called recently for a referendum on withdrawal from the European Union. No, I don’t understand it either.

The Scottish Liberal Democrat antipathy toward a referendum in Scotland has never made much democratic sense, so perhaps we should welcome the fact that Tavish Scott is no longer ruling one out “for all time”. Though he isn’t ruling it in either. The idea appears to be to prevent the issue from denying the Liberal Democrats the option of forming a coalition with the SNP after the next Scottish election. The Libdems have finally realised what everyone else has known for years, that the Nationalists are actually intensely relaxed about delaying the referendum on independence. This may not be unconnected with the fact that they would almost certainly lose it, as the latest YouGov poll confirmed at the weekend. The whole point of the referendum policy was to liberate the SNP from the independence commitment - to put it into the long grass - while Alex Salmond got on with the business of governing in the Scottish parliament.

But in May 2007, Tavish Scott refused even to talk about a coalition unless the SNP abandoned its policy of a referendum on the constitution - which Salmond clearly could not do. It was an emotional spasm which now seems to have passed. Though I’m not entirely sure what has changed to clear the way for this historic compromise. Tavish and co could have remained in government; instead they opted for the wilderness. And the wilderness is a cold and lonely place.

Just consider a typical senior Liberal Democrat who is not getting any younger and yet feels he has much to contribute. He was an able minister for eight years in the Liberal-Labour coalition, and was rarely off the airwaves. Now he is, if not forgotten, then largely gone from public view. It is immensely frustrating to be a politician and not have any power. The Liberal Democrats knew what they were for back then: free personal care, tuition fees, reform of local government. Now they just don’t matter; they are the lost tribe of Scottish politics.

So, the Libdems have got to make themselves matter again, and the only way to do that is to get some kind of foothold on power through an alliance. But could it be that they are opening the way for the SNP just at the moment when the door is closing on Scottish nationalism? The latest YouGov opinion poll places Labour back in the lead in voters’ preferences for Holyrood for the first time in two years. The Nationalist minority government is becalmed, discarding manifesto promises like a sinking ship dumping cargo to keep afloat. Following the credit crisis, the whole idea of small nations with big banks trying to go it alone is discredited. Perhaps the Liberal Democrats should be making up with Labour again and looking to re-establish the partnership that delivered their greatest hits?

Well, certainly, the SNP is discovering that it is not immune to what they call “mid term blues” in Westminster - the slough that governments fall into half way through a term of office as the novelty wears off and they lose popularity. But Labour isn’t in a position to open the champagne quite yet, and the Libdems are wise to be circumspect. The financial crisis is only now transforming itself into an economic one, and Scotland is still behind the curve, as they say in the city. In places like Edinburgh people are still buying expensive cars and paying ludicrous prices for houses, like Wile E. Coyote who has run off the cliff but hasn’t succumbed to the force of gravity yet.

As the Liberal Democrat finance spokesman Vince Cable has warned, there is a 10% to 20% cut in public spending on the way, as the government tries to salvage the ruined public finances. This is going to be devastating to an economy like Scotland’s which is dominated by the public sector. The SNP Finance Secretary, John Swinney, is equally gloomy and has reportedly called on ministers to draw up a “doomsday budget” involving cuts of £2.3bn in spending on schools, hospitals and other services. The key question in Scottish politics for the medium term, therefore, is who gets blamed for the economy: Westminster, as the SNP wish, or the Scottish government. The Glenrothes by-election, and some opinion polls suggest that voters are disinclined to blame Gordon Brown. On the other hand, Alex Salmond remains by far the most popular leader in Scotland.

The battle of the cuts is unresolved. However, after this weekend I think one thing perhaps is resolved: the constitutional question. All the Scottish parties accept now that the Scottish parliament needs more powers to tax and to borrow - the difference is only one of degree. It’s devolution max all round. Independence is lying in the long grass, in a field far away, as the SNP increasingly confine their demands to “more powers” to deal with the economy. Tavish Scott yesterday called for “a true home rule parliament”. And, in time, it looks as if that is precisely what we are going to get. Though I’m not entirely sure that Gordon is on board.

Monday, March 02, 2009

The Pension Crunch

The revelation that Fred the Shred’s pension is actually going to cost £30m, and not the £16 million quoted by RBS, has underlined a salient fact about pensions: everyone underestimates the cost of them. This is partly because the pension providers tend not to take inflation into account when calculating the lifetime cost of pensions, and make optimistic assumptions about investment returns. They know that if people are told the truth about how much they really need to save they run and hide.

You want numbers? A sixty year old retiring today and seeking a £30,000 a year pension, inflation linked, requires a pension ‘pot’ of over £1,000,000, according to fairinvestment.co.uk. The average pension ‘pot’ of a worker retiring today is actually £35,000. Do the math. Only bankers, politicians and employees of public corporations like the BBC get pensions that actually deliver. That’s because they don’t pay the cost of them - we do. One fifth of your council tax goes to pay the pensions of the people collecting it.

But central government is at it as well. The government claims that the current public sector pension bill is around £600bn when everyone in the industry knows that it will be well over £1 trillion. One of the untold scandals of the Brown years is the way that this colossal expense has been kept off the public books. It is “unfunded’ in the jargon, which means the government pretends it isn’t there. But of course it is there and someone has to pay for it: around £40,000 for every household in Britain over the next 20 years. The alert among you will notice that this is actually more than those people are saving for their own pensions - which is of course madness.

Now, I have no animosity toward public sector workers, who deserve what they get - which often isn’t a lot. However, we are creating a kind of pensions apartheid here. Nine out of ten public sector workers still have copper-bottomed final salary pensions against only one in ten private sector workers. The public sector pension used to be a compensation for lower pay in the public sphere, but that’s all changed. State employees now have higher pay than private sector employees and also work fewer hours. And the disparity is growing very fast in the current recession as a pay freeze is imposed across the entire private sector while public sector pay continues to increase. Moreover, the private pension savers have just seen the value of their pensions collapse in the stock-market crash by 40% or more.

Everyone knows that this cannot go on, but the government is in denial - just as it was about the housing market 2 years ago. The pension deficit could split society and destroy services like the NHS - it really is as serious as that. The root cause is the failure of successive governments to realistically cost public pensions and to regulate the private pensions industry, which has performed disgracefully over the last two decades. The average personal pension fund at retirement, according to Prudential, produces just £2,000 a year. And most of this is wiped out by the means test on the state pension credit - another disgraceful fiddle of which the government should be ashamed. And remember that forty percent of workers don’t contribute to any kind of pension at all and will be left wholly reliant on the basic state pension or £124 a week.

Many people have been relying on the value of their homes to generate an income in retirement. Well, the writing really is on the wall here because UK house prices have fallen 20% since August 2007, placing two million in negative equity, and prices are expected to fall by another 10-15%. No future government is going to allow another house price boom after the present disaster. So anyone who believes their house will look after them in retirement is living in a fool’s paradise.

I know this is alarming and complicated, and that pensions are about as interesting as programming a video recorder, but we ignore these numbers at our peril. I have been tracking my own personal pension for many years and been appalled at the poor returns - largely a result of high commissions taken by financial “advisers” and because pension savers are more or less compelled to place their money in equities to generate income for the pension providers. Every ten or twenty years shares crash and the pension funds rarely regain the lost value. Honest financial advisers - there are some - are deeply embarrassed about the poor returns from pensions industry and admit that most of the tax relief on pensions is diverted into salaries and bonuses for the pensions industry.

The terrifying reality is that, as Britain’s population ages, the means to sustain any kind of wellbeing in retirement is simply not there. Public sector pensions are unsustainable and private ones are risible. Our collective denial about pensions is similar to our refusal to face up to the debt problem during the credit boom. That too was clearly unsustainable, but the government and the financial services sector observed a conspiracy of silence about it - until it turned into a suicide pact. Voters are also implicated, of course, for thinking that houses would always rise in value, which is like believing money grows on trees.

Actually, the government is still hoping that trees can be persuaded to produce fivers instead of leaves. Last week the Bank of England began quantitative easing, printing money, which it hopes will generate inflation and erode the value of the public pension debt as well as the debts of the banks. What this really means is a transfer of wealth from people who have saved, to people who haven’t. It is a desperate and dishonourable way out of the pensions hole - and it won’t work. Inflation may erode the value of the public sector pension bill, but only at the cost of increasing entitlement, because it will throw more public and private pensioners into poverty and into the arms of the state.

From Weimar Germany to Mugabe’s Zimbabwe, the lesson of history is that inflation only makes large debts disappear at immense economic cost. There’s no free lunch. Future historians will be astonished that the government actually penalised savers at the moment when the country desperately needs to pay down debt and save for the future. But our children, as they pay for our mistakes, will look back on the noughties with a mixture of scorn and disbelief. We are generation dumb, and getting dumber.

Sunday, February 15, 2009

White hell

Britain ground to a halt last week as the country was gripped by white hell. Well, what they really meant was that there was some snow in London. The London transport system promptly ground to a halt, schools closed, factories shut and newspapers suffered superlative fatigue. There were the heart-warming stories about meals on wheels on ice, and about the human cost in ruined lives. Climate change deniers insisted that global warming is a myth. Health and safety officials ordered people not to build snowmen or use sledges without airbags and full body armour.

It’s strange, but somehow when it snows in Scotland, it just isn’t news, at least not network news - it's just weather. Of course, snow in Hide Park is news, because it doesn’t happen very often, as are all the snowmen and sledges and bumped cars. But it is LOCAL news. The perennial problem with the media in this country is that local news in London is assumed to be news everywhere else. Last week was confirmation that the metropolitan media is the most parochial in the country. Its news values are worse than the most local of local rags, precisely because it can’t see beyond its own doorstep.

When snow fall in Scotland there are all the stories we have seen in the past week, and more. We have mountain rescues, islands cut off, remote farmers isolated. The schools don’t generally close and public transport remains active but with our mountain landscape it’s a lot more interesting to look at. However, what you will never see is the BBC’s national news bulletin devoting half its slot to covering snow chaos in Scotland. It is only when weather happens in London that it is thought to be of national significance. The rest of the country is assumed to be fascinated with buses not moving in Regent Street and Boris Johnson trundling his bike in the slush.

I’m not making a Scottish whinge here - well, perhaps I am a bit- but it is a legitimate whinge. Metrocentrism was supposed to have been stamped out after the BBC’s Impartiality Review last year. But hiring a few newsreaders with Scottish accents doesn’t disguise the reality that the network bulletins are still utterly preoccupied with whatever is happening the in the South East.

I don’t know why we take this from our ‘national’ broadcaster, I really don’t. The King report two years ago for the BBC Trust was scathing of the southern bias of BBC network news and current affairs. We were promised that things would change. But they haven’t. Look at the coverage on the network bulletins of the Scottish budget crisis. They’re much more interested in beavers. Maybe we should all grow beards and build dams.

Sexual Offensive Bill

The First Minister, Alex Salmond, continued his daring manifesto striptease last week. First it was student debts, first time buyer grants and new police that dropped to the floor. Now the bigger items of clothing are being removed, like Local Income Tax. But fear not, because the SNP’s moral guardian, Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill, has come to the rescue with an armful of daft legislation to cover up the FM’s wobbly bits.

Judge Kenny has already tried to stop under twenty-ones from buying drink in an off-license, even though they may be married soldiers back from Afghanistan. He’s now topped that by calling for teenage girls to be prosecuted for having sex under the age of 16. The Sexual Offences Bill now before Holyrood would make it illegal for girls as well as boys to have consensual sex with each other if they are underage.

Does the government realise just how many teenagers it is going to criminalise as a result of this extraordinary exercise in sexual hygiene? Like hundreds of thousands of people, I had consensual intercourse with my girlfriend before I was sixteen, which means I’m technically a rapist. But she was also underage, which means she could be prosecuted too under the new law. I’d better shop her right away.

How is the justice system going to cope with the flood of tweeny sex-criminals? A BBC survey two years ago revealed that at least a third of teenagers have sex below the age of consent, and that is widely thought to be an under-estimate. . And just how is Kenny going to know when they are all having illegal nooky? Perhaps all those speech-activated security cameras that are being put up around Glasgow will do the job. Whenever one of them picks up heavy breathing the sex police will be onto the couple in a shot. Come on now you two, get your kit on, you’re nicked.

Perhaps Kenny could take a leaf out of the Ysgol Dyffryin Teifi school in Ceredigion Wales (crazy name, crazy school) which has placed CCTV cameras in secondary school toilets. It’s not quite clear who is going to monitor this footage since the teachers would presumably place themselves on the sex offenders register if they looked at it. But a rumour that I have just invented suggests that the Justice Secretary, may be minded to introduce toilet tv cameras into every home in Scotland so that he can know what everyone is really up to.

I’ve heard of the nanny state, but this is ridiculous. The only way the Scottish government is going to stop young people having sex is to bring back chastity belts and bromide. But I’d better stop right there in case I give the sex police any more bright ideas.

The banality of bankers

Hannah Arendt used to talk about the “banality of evil”; last week we saw the banality of bankers. There they sat, the Sir this and Lord thats, uttering po-faced clichés and over-rehearsed apologies to ratty MPs in Westminster. The Sun called them “scumbag millionaires” but they were really a bit of an anticlimax, and far to dull to make proper villains. Goodwin and co were revealed to be just like the countless interchangeable suits who sit around thousands of corporate boards and shuffle paper around a million offices every day; uninspiring bureaucrats whose vision extends no further than the latest management fad.

They’re the people you remember from school - the ones who got their homework in on time but lacked any kind of inspiration or independence of thought. The ones who joined the right societies at university, studied subjects of mind-numbing tedium, and then polished up their CVs for the graduate milk round. They were supposed to be the safe pairs of hands these accountants and actuaries, with their mousy wives living in their characterless suburban houses. Secure and boring. But somehow they grey men managed to blow up the world.

How did it happen? When did it happen? Without a shot being fired, these people not only took over the commanding heights of the economy, they infiltrated the heart of government, sitting on countless quangos and inquiries, advising ministers and civil servants, creating a society in their own image. How did we let them do it? And where did these boring bean-counters and shiny-bottoms get the wherewithal to engineer the greatest financial crisis in history?

Well, it all goes back to the 1980s when the ruminant number crunchers became infected with the virus of greed and turned into voracious financial predators. It was the great financial boom ignited by Margaret Thatcher’s privatisation policies that transformed plodding corporate clones into to reckless gamblers and risk-takers. With deregulated financial markets, the suits discovered that they suddenly had access to the ‘dumb’ wealth of society which had been sitting passively in pension funds, insurance funds, government departments. Deregulation encouraged financial ‘innovation’ and the creation of ‘products’ like dodgy endowment mortgages or “personal” pensions that delivered little apart from commissions.

But it was the sale of public utilities that offered the suits their opportunity to cash in on a grand scale. The sale of state assets in rail, airports, communications gas and electricity yielded billions in commissions and fees that flooded into the offices of the grey men turning them into privatisation tycoons. Look at how well they’d done, selling the country back its own property and calling it popular capitalism. They set up remuneration committees staffed by their friends which awarded higher and higher salaries to themselves under the guise of incentive schemes. The bonus culture was born.

The lords of financial misrule weren’t actually making anything - building companies or creating new markets - but they began to regard themselves as financial engineers, masters of the universe, able to create wealth apparently out of nothing. Ten they started on the property market - a massive pyramid scheme, so huge and complex that it took over twenty years to construct and will take almost as long for society to pay off.

A pyramid scheme, like Bernie Madoff’s Ponzi scheme, is a way of inflating asset prices by creating an artificial scarcity fuelled by buying mania. Like the South Sea Bubble, inflated asset prices only last for as long as ever larger numbers of people can be persuaded to invest in them. The global real estate boom was the greatest asset bubble in history, as house prices in countries like Britain tripled with in a decade. This created trillions worth of paper wealth which was managed and manipulated by the bloated financial services industry which had now begun to crowd out other productive forms of economic activity.

It’s an open secret that the bankers realised that the boom couldn’t last forever, but they did everything they could to prolong it. Banks like Northern Rock and HBOS started selling 125% mortgages and the infamous sub-prime loans to people who could never repay. Then there was ‘securitization’. Instead of just holding on to mortgages for the duration of the loan, the banks started selling packages of mortgage in bonds to other investors and used the proceeds to lend ever more mortgages. They invented sophisticated derivatives like collateralised debt obligations and credit default swaps which used complexity to disguise risk.They started lending on every greater ratios of their core capital, “leveraging” loans by thirty or forty to one. Their command of the language of the balance sheet prevented the rest of us from fully understanding what they were doing. Just take a look at an RBS balance sheet - they’re openly available on the web - and try to work out whether or not it is solvent.

Most of the dodgy mortgage-backed bonds were bought by savers in Asian countries, who are now feeling extremely sore. Back home in Britain people stopped saving altogether as the suits found ever more ingenious ways of ensnaring them in debt - like credit cards, with 25% interest rates. Then there were student loans: an entire generation of graduates landed with £20,000 debts. Governments were persuaded to take out PFI schemes - which are a bit like endowment mortgages for public projects like hospitals and schools. Our children will be paying the cost of these and other financial innovations for decades.

As I say, the bankers knew perfectly well that a real estate asset bubble couldn’t last forever. But they believed that if they got big enough, fast enough, they would be too big to fail when the music stopped. This was why the former HBOS executive, Sir James Crosby, launched his dash for growth, which even the Financial Services Authority realised was reckless insanity. When Lloyds ‘rescued’ HBOS by taking it over last year, they too hoped that the resulting bank behemoth would be too big to fail - that the bigger the losses the more likely the government would always step in with public money.

This was why the Lloyds boss, Sir Eric Daniels, largely dispensed with due diligence before the HBOS take-over- he didn’t want to know how bad the HBOS books really were. And in a sense, he was right; they were all right. As we saw last week, the government has had no choice but to step in to save the bankers from the consequences of their own irresponsibility. After the privatisation of gains comes the socialisation of the losses. It’s been the crime of the century, perhaps of the millennium, and the colourless culprits are getting clean away.

Rector Reflections

The most difficult thing was explaining why I wanted to do it. As the 50th Rector of Edinburgh University, following my election last week by students and staff, I will now be chairing the University Court, the governing body of one of Scotland’s great cultural institutions. It’s clearly an immense honour and a privilege, and - I hope - a lot of fun since being Rector involves associating with some of the brightest and liveliest minds in the country and speaking on the great moral issues of the day.

But as I was trundling around lecture theatres and dinner halls canvassing support, I kept being assailed by the question why? Why did I want the hassle? It became increasingly difficult to give the same pat answer without sounding just a little false. The subtext of the question was clearly that there must be some kind of ulterior motive. People don’t just take on these roles for nothing these days - puh-leese - there must be something in it for me. The students didn’t want to condemn me for it; they just wanted to know what it was.

The more I answered the question the more I started questioning my own motives. I’m not a daytime TV celebrity or a full time politician, so there is no real PR benefit. The job involves no salary or comfy expense account and, so far as I know, there are no lobbying companies seeking rectors-for-hire. Apart from a lifetime membership of a unique club which includes Gladstone, Churchill, and Lloyd George, it’s not clear what the material rewards really are of being Rector of Edinburgh University. Perhaps I should have just said: ‘because it’s there’.

So, why did I stand. Well, the first reason of course, was that I was asked to - and sometimes that is incentive enough. Call it vanity, but it is very hard not to respond when you’re called out of the blue by a group of bright undergraduates from a wide range of political backgrounds, who seem to think that you stand for what they stand for. After thirty years in the tawdry trade of journalism, it’s nice to be told that you actually stand for anything at all- even if you’re not quite sure what it is. When you realise that the students are mainly interested in you because you are not one of the other candidates the ego boost diminishes just a little. But it was still immensely flattering to be told that I could take on, in electoral combat, someone like Lord George Foulkes, a former cabinet minister, one of the most experienced political operators around. Or that I could beat the Respect MP, George Galloway, one of the greatest parliamentary orators of his generation and the man who faced down the US Congress over those alleged oil dealings with Saddam.

But you rapidly discover that it’s not really about the candidate, but the effectiveness of the campaign - which in my case was led by the dynamic Edinburgh undergraduate Devin Dunseath, and devised by the President of the Edinburgh University Students Association, Adam Ramsay, whose sometimes shambolic appearance disguises one of the sharpest political brains I have come across. Certainly, my campaign worked and delivered one of the largest votes in the history of rectorial politics - something of which I am immensely proud. I haven’t stood in a competitive election since I left school, but political inexperience turned out to be an advantage. There is such a depth of cynicism about politics at all levels now, that just being a politician has become an electoral handicap - at least in an election like this.

Of course we had policies on student debt, the accommodation crisis, the quality of teaching and such like, as well as on broader issues like Gaza. But being independent of any party line was very important as was being remote from parliamentary sleaze. The Lords-for-hire scandal broke just as the campaign got underway, inflicting immense collateral damage on the unfortunate Lord Foulkes. While he'd broken no rules by peforming parliamentary services for the international law firm Eversheds, it was very hard for him not to suffer guilt by association. There was a whole range of issues which made Lord Foulkes’s campaign an uphill struggle - not least his record of support for university top up fees, the Iraq war and identity cards. He fought a very dignified and effective campaign for all that.

But the hyper-cynicism that has afflicted our political culture has left us in a very difficult situation. The way things are going, not being a politicians may be the best way of winning elections. Even my uncertain delivery in the hustings debates, where I was no match for my rivals’ oratorical skill, added in a curious way to my credibility. I was clearly not comfortable selling myself and I struggled with the stilted discourse of electoral politics, where what you don't say is as important as what you do.

So what now? Well, there will be little opportunity for motivational navel-gazing because Universities are heading for difficult times. Budgets are going to be under immense pressure. Graduates, burdened with £20,000 debts, are going to be dumped onto a jobs market that no longer wants them - at least not in the numbers of the last ten years. Universities are in the front line of the financial crisis, and it is going to require hard lobbying to remind governments that investment in higher education is even more important in an economic downturn. There’s a whole range of issues requiring attention. So, once I find out what I’m doing it for, I’ll let you know.

Monday, February 09, 2009

Hate speak - look who's talking.

Yesterday, I committed an act of hate speak. Upon reflection I have decided to apologise unreservedly for remarks I made about Gordon Brown in the Sunday Herald. In the heat of the moment I wrote that: “To describe Gordon as an unmade bed is an insult to teenage bedrooms”. This was derogatory and I offer my sincere apologies to the teenage community for suggesting that they are deficient in their domestic arrangements.

Further I would like to apologise to the bedroom community for any pain and distress caused by a comparison with the Prime Minister’s state of dress. Finally, may I apologise to Gordon Brown, who has himself the target of hate speak from the Gauleiter of the Top Gear Nazi Party, Herr Jeremy Clarkson, and who is in no way untidily dressed, exhausted, not looking 100% or any of the other things I may or may not have said. And while I’m at it, let me issue a prophylactic apology to Britain’s petrol heads for comparing the presenter of their favourite television programme to a member of the far right.

Sadly, I’m only half joking here. I’m really not sure what is acceptable to say any more, in public or private, after this astonishing week in which Orwellian thought crime became a potent reality in the British media. A kind of madness has infected the country - an incomprehensibe witch-hunt for petty offence. I’m no apologist for Jeremy Clarkson, but I don't believe Scots are racially offended by his description of the Prime Minister as a “one-eyed Scottish idiot”? I’m Scottish and I’m not offended, and I don’t need to be defended from people like Clarkson by self-appointed cultural guardians or rent-a-quote politicians. I’m frequently called an idiot myself and I refuse to take offence at the description.

If calling someone Scottish or English or an idiot or one-eyed is to be outlawed then a lot of books are going to have to be burnt and most Scottish comedians will be joining the dole queues. The Declaration of Arbroath will have to be banned as will the National Anthem with its talk of crushing rebellious Scots. Programmes like Mock the Week and Have I Got News For You are toast. I’m a republican, but I can see that jokes, such as the one on MTW about the Queen’s p***y being so old it is haunted, are offensive on so many grounds you hardly know where to begin. Little Britain made its name by being ageist, sexist and offensive to the disabled, rural gays and the people of Wales.

This is beyond a joke. There is a very real danger that satire, irony and other forms of comic abuse are now going to be driven from our screens because of the theoretical possibility that some minority group might be offended. Is the word “chav” offensive to single parents living on housing estates? I don’t like it myself, and don’t use it - but my children do, and so do travel companies who offer “chav-free holidays”. “Redneck” is a term of abuse used against truckers and poor rural whites in the southern states of America. Songs like “Short People” by Randy Newman can surely no longer be broadcast on the BBC; and terms like “one-armed bandit” must now be proscribed. Should Gullivers Travels be banned for its misrepresentation of smaller people?

Laughter is a serious business. The right to be offensive is an important part of our political culture, and was only won after a long struggle against laws on seditious libel. But can cartoonists like Steve Bell of the Guardian and Martin Rowson continue depicting politicians as rotting meat or gibbering morons? The former leader of the Liberal Democrats, Sir Menzies Campbell, was driven from office because cartoonists portrayed him as a corpse propped up by a zimmer frame. That’s surely ageist. It may not be possible to depict Barack Obama at all except as a secular saint because anything offensive might be interpreted as racist. Imagine if Steve Bell were to depict Obama as a chimpanzee in the way he has President George Bush? Or as a criminal, or a vampire or a lunatic, foaming at the mouth.

Freedom of speech is under enough threat in this country from official secrecy, defamation laws, anti-terrorist statutes without overlaying it with excessive sensitivity to minorities. And no, I’m not ranting about ‘political correctness gone mad’ - we are right to cleanse our language of racial abuse. But in our zeal to avoid hateful imagery we must not believe we can police other peoples’ thoughts. I’m sorry, but Carol Thatcher should never have been sacked for whatever she may or may not have said in a private conversation over a glass of wine in the BBC green room - and I speak as someone who has heard many profoundly offensive remarks being made on BBC premises. I am dismayed to see liberal commentators claiming it is acceptable for anyone, even Mrs Thatcher’s daughter, to lose their job because of a private conversation. I am as opposed to racial prejudice as anyone alive, and I might have taken issue with her had she compared a tennis player to a Gollywog in my presence. But I would never have gone telling tales. What were these people thinking of?

In every newsroom in the land there is an undercurrent of banter, much of it sexist, racist or sectarian. In BBC Scotland, whenever there was an old firm game on, the air would fill with jokey remarks about blue noses and papists. Are those who said these things now to be sacked? Should I be naming names? The late Kenny MacIntyre was one of the funniest and most humane journalists BBC Scotland ever produced. As was the butt of much of his humour, the late travel reporter and curry connoisseur Ali Abassi. They spent much of their time hurling hyperbolic abuse at each other much of which, out of context, could have been construed as racist or offensive to crofters and sheep. Yet in their relationship you saw the true image of racial tolerance in Scotland. What if someone reported them?

The surest way to drive a wedge between communities is to try to police what people think and what they say in private. That way lies only intolerance and hate. Now, have you heard the one about the Scotsman, the Irishman and the Englishman....

Monday, February 02, 2009

British jobs for British workers

You can tell a lot about a country by what bring its citizens out on the streets. In France, millions demonstrated last week against banking bailouts and public money being used to prop up a failed financial system built on greed. Here in Britain we go on strike against foreign workers.

I say ‘we’ when of course it is only a relatively small number of workers who have been involved in wildcat strike actions against the importation of Italian and Portuguese workers to the Lindsey oil refinery in North Lincolnshire. But they are mostly in key positions, in power stations and energy plants, and able to make a disproportionate impact on the economy. There are plans this week to shut down filling stations owned by Total, the French company which has imported the workers at Lindsey. Shades of the fuel protests in 2000 which a handful of hauliers and refinery staff brought the country to a standstill.

Workers in Longannet and Cockenzie power stations in Scotland have been active in the strike, though none of their jobs are remotely at risk from immigrants, and there are plans this week to organise an Edinburgh-to-London march against foreign workers. What a grim commentary on the state of industrial politics in modern Britain. In the 1930s, the Jarrow Crusade marched on London to demand work; now in 2009 they will be marching to demand that foreigners are sent home. The British National Party is finally in from the cold - inheritor of the great tradition of British industrial militancy.

It’s not that I don’t have a measure of sympathy with the strikers. It’s easy for politicians and middle class newspaper columnists to accuse workers of xenophobia (a polite word for ‘racism’) when they aren’t facing a similar threat to their jobs. If a barge loaded with Italian politicians were to tie up outside Westminster offering to do MPs’ jobs for less money I suspect we would discover overnight that this was an act of industrial warfare which threatened Britain’s economic livelihood, culture and way of life. MPs and Peers would be linking arms in New Palace Yard to prevent any of them entering the building. Though it’s unlikely there would be a wave of sympathy actions from other workers across the land.

But there are so many better reasons to take to the streets right now than over a handful of European workers in Grimsby who are here entirely legally. As countless billions of taxpayers’ money is handed to the private banks, why is no one demonstrating against socialism for the rich? Why are there no barricades in Downing Street to protest at the government’s monumental incompetence - a decade of policies which have run down manufacturing industry in order to turn Britain into a casino economy based on financial speculation? Why are people not marching down Threadneedle Street, demanding the head of the Governor of the Bank of England for doubling the national debt and printing money in order to bail out delinquent banks which can’t be trusted to manage an honest deposit account let alone the wealth of the nation?

Why not a demonstration against foreign tax havens, which are allowing British companies to evade a hundred billion in taxation? Why not demonstrate against the insurance companies whose dabbling in derivatives has helped destroy the pensions of the very same workers who are taking to the streets against immigrants? Why is it that, in Britain, it is foreigners who are the first to be prime target?

Gangs of foreign workers have been coming here ever since the Irish navigators were imported to dig the canals two hundred years. And immigration is a two way street: the long-running TV series “Aufwiedersehen Pet” was about British workers going to work in Germany on similar terms to the Italian workers in Lincolnshire. There is generally an element of social dumping when workers are shipped abroad - of firms undercutting local labour prices. But in Lindsey, the firm in charge, Total, insists there have been no local redundancies as a result of their sub-contractors, IREM bringing their own staff. Nor, they insist, are the Italian workers being paid less than the British ones - though no one has been able to verify this. No, there is something deeply troubling about the way this local dispute has grown into a rolling national strike of more privileged workers condemning all foreign workers.

There is a latent xenophobia in British society at all levels, but it requires political leadership to bring it out. And that is the most serious charge against Gordon Brown. He has made the British National Party respectable by borrowing its slogan of “a British job for every British worker” - and I don’t believe for a nano-second that a politician as seasoned and sophisticated as the PM didn’t realise the full significance of these words. Labour has been blowing the immigration dog whistle for the last two years, promising to give British families priority in housing, promising to withhold benefits from foreign workers, when most aren’t entitled to them in the first place. Labour has adopted largely the same immigration controls that the Tories advocated in 2005. By subtly appealing to economic nationalism in this way, the government has legitimised actions that set worker against worker. Now the entire strategy has blown up in his face.

Yes, I know that British workers are losing their jobs by the hundreds of thousands, and that unemployment is likely to reach 3.1 million later this year - almost exactly the same as the number of foreign-born workers. Gordon Brown has encouraged mass immigration, along with “flexible” labour policies, in order to drive down the wages and living standards of UK workers in the hope of attracting foreign investment. But that isn’t the fault of the employees who come here.

The British workers holding meetings today to plan the next stage of their campaign should pause and reflect. Do they really think it would be any better if immigrant workers were all sent home? Most public services would collapse. Those taking to the streets are relatively well paid and wouldn’t dream of working in a hospital for £14,000 a year. Perhaps the trades unionists among them should dig out their copies of that great socialist novel, “The Ragged Trousered Philanthropists” by Robert Tressell to see how hostility to foreign workers was exploited by employers a hundred years ago. Plus ca change....

Saturday, January 31, 2009

Budget madness

So what was that all about? The wheels of government nearly seized last week; local authorities prepared for an emergency council tax hike and staff cuts; there was talk of an early election. Yet, what plunged the Scottish parliament into turmoil was an eleven million pound shortfall in a home insulation programme - a sum so vanishingly small as to be lost in the small change of the thirty billion Scottish budget. Not much more than the golden parachute Fred the Shred Goodwin awarded himself when he abandoned the Royal Bank of Scotland. Could the entire system collapse over such a tiny sum?

Well, the answer is no, of course it couldn’t. What happened last week in Holyrood was a kind of parliamentary theatre, a bit like one of those dramatic reconstructions they used to run on Channel 4 before it dumbed down. A kind of ‘what if’’. All the parties in the parliament looked into the abyss of a lost budget and came racing back from the brink. Everyone is chastened by the experience, and Holyrood is probably a better place for it.

What actually happened was this: the two Green MSPs, Patrick Harvie and Robin Harper, had been trying to get a £100m free home insulation project off the ground in Scotland. Scottish homes have all the thermal efficiency of patio heaters, and half of the output of Torness power-station goes on heating the sky. It’s a very good programme, as it happens, tried and tested south of the border, which largely pays for itself in reduced energy costs. Except, of course, government has to put money up front to get the home insulation into the houses first.

Now, it appears that the Greens and the SNP came to a deal over a £33m start up of the scheme, which would have been an honourable compromise. This was being negotiated, by Alex Salmond personally, even as MSPs gathered for the budget debate on Wednesday afternoon. But the compromise came unstuck shortly before the vote. The Greens co-convenor, Patrick Harvie claimed he had not been given a guarantee by the Finance Secretary, John Swinney, that £11 million of the cash would be new money and not drawn from other budgets.

The SNP claim they had given a guarantee, and are very,very angry. But the real reason for the breakdown was that Harvie - who is under pressure from his own party for accepting the M74 extension and other road extensions in the budget - wasn’t in a position to get an endorsement from his party in time. So in a state of frustration and fury he voted against it, risking losing the scheme altogether.

It was just one of those things, really. A combination of confusion, emotion and brinksmanship. Anyway, the budget bill went down and the roof went up. Suddenly, the illusion of government disintegrated; the ship of state was rudderless. Almost immediately, councils started ringing up the Scottish Executive to find out what had happened to the money they were expecting from the budget. Might they have to make emergency council tax increases to meet their financial commitments? Trades unions were in a panic about job losses in countless public sector schemes. Firms were ringing up the Scottish Executive to find out if their contracts were going to be honoured. Now, maybe a lot of this was just needless bureaucratic fuss - but it was not entirely without foundation. The truth is that no one knows what would happen if a budget actually did fall - except that the previous year’s budget is reapplied. In a searing soundbite at FMQs Alex Salmond claimed that it would mean cuts of £1.8bn and the loss of 34,000 jobs. Labour jeered that the budget failure was a result of incompetence by the SNP.

Then, a curious thing happened. The Liberal Democrats, who had voted against the budget all along because they wanted a 2 pence tax cut, suddenly turned round and made conciliatory noises. If Alex would talk with them about borrowing powers for the parliament, they might be able to vote with the government. Then Labour made clear that they would be willing to come to a deal about apprenticeships. Initially Labour had wanted the SNP to drop its plans for a Scottish Futures Trust and its local income tax. Now, all they were wanting a handful of sweeties and a hug.

It didn’t really make sense. Why would Labour and the Liberal Democrats suddenly decide to support the budget when they had already voted against it twice? Why not just leave the mess and blame it on Alex Salmond? Well, the short answer is that they didn’t want to be held responsible for causing council chaos. Minority government cuts both ways - it is for the opposition parties to explain, if they use their majority to overturn the government’s budget, why they are plunging the country into turmoil.

The Greens, who had started it all, were largely forgotten, which may be a good thing for them, since it prevented them becoming the full target of Alex Salmond’s wrath. We don’t know whether the insulation deal is still live - the money for it may be handed to one of the other parties in the renegotiations on the budget. But Salmond says he wants to get a unanimous vote for the budget, so the suggestion is that a deal is still on the table.

The only one smiling on Thursday was Margo Macdonald, the wily Lothians MSP who quietly used her vote to win further concessions on affordable housing for Edinburgh. Everyone else was looking a bit sheepish, as the press rounded on Holyrood for playing politics with peoples’ jobs. But playing politics is precisely the point. This was an exercise in calculated political risk taking - a process of discovery if you will, in which the parties in the Scottish parliament tested their respective strengths, and the strength of the constitution, in a kind of shadow election.

Labour could in theory have joined with the Liberal Democrats to move a confidence motion and try to replace the government. The Labour leadeer Iain Gray actually requested guidance on this from the Presiding Officer, Alex Fergusson. But the opposition parties clearly decided that they were not in a position to fight any elections right now. Since they weren't prepared to beat Alex Salmond, they had to join him, to ensure that they didn’t get the blame for losing thousands of jobs. In other words, reason prevailed. Which, when you think of it, is all you can expect from a parliament.

Monday, January 19, 2009

Obama Messiah

Barack Obama used to joke about his being regarded as the Messiah by awed supporters. But he’s going to have to be a real miracle worker if the 44th Presidency of the United States is not to end in disappointment and disillusion. Never as an incoming world leader had such an in-tray of unmitigated doom: two unpopular wars, a climate out of control, a world economic system in an advanced state of collapse. And that’s before he gets round to race, poverty and the Middle East.

In private, many Republicans are content to let a new and inexperienced leader clean up the mess they’ve left after eight years: a crippling trillion dollar deficit, a dysfunctional financial system, half a million jobs being lost every month. Ten trillion dollars have evaporated in the greatest stock market crash since the 1930s. Twenty million Americans face negative equity, thirty million Americans are in poverty, forty million have no health insurance. The numbers just keep piling up.

And as if that wasn’t enough, the entire world is expecting Obama to solve their problems too by launching some miraculous public works programme to get the planet back to work- the economic equivalent of loaves and fishes. But it ain’t gonna happen. Barack Obama does not walk on water, and as President his ability to alter the disastrous trajectory of his country and he world is limited. The US bet the house on a system of speculation and derivative trading that has exploded in its face, leaving the country with massive debts. America and the world faces a deep and long recession while the bad loans are cleaned out of the system and all the folly and fraud is exposed. There really isn’t much a new President can do about that, except feel his nation’s pain.

And so, pretty soon, we will all probably start to complain that Obama is a man of straw, a media creation, a triumph of style over substance; more a celebrity than a politician - a “polebrity” to use the latest ugly neologism. The President-elect hasn’t exactly shunned the image-makers, and seems to be proud of his 15 appearances on the front page of Time magazine, those paparazzi pics of his pecks, the $2,000 suits. His wife, Michelle, is being groomed as a black Jackie Onassis. His daughters, we learn, will be making their own beds and getting by on a dollar a week pocket money while, er, attending schools costing $25,000 a year.

Obama has been trying to get his disillusion in first. He has antagonised the Left by surrounding himself with establishment figures like Secretary of State, Hillary Clinton, who supported the war in Iraq and wants to bomb Iran. His choice of Chief of Staff, Rahm Emanuel - a fiercely pro-Israeli son of a Zionist partisan - should disabuse those hoping Obama will hold Israel accountable for war crimes in Gaza. His economic advisers include the billionaire Warren Buffett and the ultra-conservative former head of the Federal Reserve, Paul Volcker. He’s even antagonised gays by inviting a homophobic pastor, Reverend Rick Warren, to deliver the invocation at tomorrow’s inaugural address.

Liberal America has got the message. Indeed, it is remarkable that there is still so much optimism about the Obama presidency from radicals like Senator Jesse Jackson who seem to believe that Obama is going to declare a war on poverty, save the planet and apologise to the world for America’s illegal war-making. But Obama’s tax increases are minimal, applying only to those earning over $200,000 a year - and he seems to have no stomach for the kind of redistribution of wealth that FDR promoted in the 1930s. He has dropped strong hints that he favours protectionism to halt the ‘export of American jobs’, which could be disastrous for world trade, not least in developing countries. The President-elect has also given notice that he intends to save the big three car manufacturers, Ford, General Motors and Chrysler, by spending billions of public money subsidising the sale of their abominable gas-guzzlers. Yes, Obama has promised to create four million new jobs and a greening of the American economy. But in a profound economic recession, the likelihood is that job creation will take priority over saving the planet.

Obama is now talking about “phased withdrawal” form Iraq leaving American soldiers there for an indefinite period. He is promising to send tens of thousands more young Americans into Afghanistan to fight another unwinnable war. And of course he famously said he would be prepared to invade Pakistan to root out al Qaeda. There is no indication that America is likely to abandon nuclear weapons or breathe life into the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty.

So, where is the change we can believe in? Is Obama just a suit with a brown face, a latter day Uncle Tom, another careerist politician on the make? Well, no, I don’t think so. Call me naive, but I think Obama will make a difference. As the son of a Muslim he will alter the dynamics of international relations and will speak directly to pariah states like Iran. He won’t launch any more illegal wars. The President-elect is an intellectual who will raise the quality of debate in America ove rissues like climate change, and will bring America into the environmental consensus. Neoliberal economics will be abandoned along with free-market fetishism, as will neoconservative foreign policy and brain-dead “America First” rhetoric. America will become a marginally more equal society, under President Obama, and there will be some progress on health care - though don’t expect the new President to introduce a national health service in the depths of an economic depression.

Perhaps the best guarantee of change is the extent to which Obama has emphasised continuity. He is making a point of including Republicans in his administration, of celebrating his defeated rival, John McCain, the man who accused him of being soft on terrorism. Obama has been hard at work ramping down expectations, qualifying his own radical image and disowning black fundamentalists like his former Pastor, Jeremiah Wright. I see this as ideological capital being placed in the bank, for when Obama does make a radical move, which I believe he will.

Just read his book, Dreams of my Father - the best political autobiography I have ever read - and you will see that this is a very different politician from any we have seen before at this level. He is a humane radical whose experience as a community activist in the Chicago ghetto framed his politics. His destiny is to make a difference for tomorrow a black man will enter the White House and that will be change enough for now.

Friday, January 16, 2009

Shritti Vadera - and other pests

Winter is a time of hibernation, when plants lie low below the ground hiding from the cold. But it is also a time of great expectation, as the garden prepares to come alive again and burst greenly onto the vibrant stage of spring. Tenacious bedding plants like the Vadera Shriti can be found even in the darkest days pushing their little green shoots through the permafrost, bringing hope of horticultural recovery.

But gardeners beware! Vadera can be a vicious colonisier of the flower bed and will be all over the place before you know it. It is best to treat premature Vadera immediately with a powerful brushwood herbicide or even a flamethrower if you don’t want it to crowd out all the other hardy annuals. The Vadera Shriti thrives on harsh treatment and you can be sure that, unlike the Norman Lamontissis, it can be relied upon to come back for more.

The Lamontissis was a great favourite of gardners back in the 1990s when Blue plants were all the rage. But it has fallen out of favour largely because the green shoots of recovery that Lamontissis promised rarely materialised. Instead the stunted tubors of recessionary growth were the bitter reward for putting your faith in the species Conservatonisus. Ugly, brown, barren and with a fragrance of mothballs, the Lamontissis is now relegated to the compost heap along with Thatcheralus and Majorens.

But what of the other bright young things in the flower bed? Will Yvette Cooperallis deliver more than a few random buds? This light seeking plant is always poking its nose into the air but lacks the proper root system necessary to thrive. Then there is the great opportunist of the modern garden, the Mandelsonus Peterii You hardly know it’s there, until suddenly it is all over the garden, bright and brash, grabbing all the light and putting more delicate blooms in the shade. But you know that Mandelsonus is not going to deliver anything but heartache as it poisons the ground around itself to kill off rivals.

True gardners are always on the lookout for the green shoots of recovery, but there is nothing worse than premature celebration of spring. Especially when the recent harsh winter frost has knocked the stuffing out of the garden and destroyed much prospect of any kind of growth for the medium term. Perhaps the best advice for those looking to a fertile future in the political garden would be to cover the entire flower bed in a deep layer of pungent horse manure the better to prepare the ground for more worthwhile species. The answer lies, as always, in the soil.

Thursday, January 15, 2009

Lords a-lobbying

It’s good to see that, in these difficult times, one industry in Britain is still thriving: political sleaze. Firms may be cutting back on hospitality and executive jets, but there’s no shortage of funds to buy members of the House of Lords. We’ve had cash for honours, now it is cash for laws.

The going rate for an amendment to a bill is around £120,000 according to a Sunday Times investigation. Lord Taylor of Blackburn says that £100,000 is “cheap” for his services in promoting business interests in the Upper House. No recession mentality there.

And isn’t it inspiring to learn that 13 Scottish Labour Peers are in the vanguard of this thriving industry. Like Lord Moonie of Bennochy, the former defence minister, who sells advice and expertise to the arms industry. Lord Moonie has also launched his own fiscal stimulus by claiming £170,839 in expenses since he became a Lord in 2005 - £500 a day, when he's there. Forget the Obama plan - stand by for a consumer boom in Scotland as Lord Moonie and his chums spend their way out of recession.

Lord Foulkes of Cumnock, the veteran former minister, is being paid £36,000 for opening parliamentary doors for Eversheds, a legal firm which specialises in securing big construction deals. This on top of some £64,000 in Lords expenses. The former Development Secretary gets a £1,000 a day from Eversheds for making “introductions” in parliament And who could possibly object to that? Well, the Scottish Parliament perhaps which does not allow consultancy and where Lord Foulkes is an MSP. But in the House of Lords anything goes - just as long as it called ‘advice’. Rent-a-Peers have been giving out passes to lobbyists from energy companies, banks, advertising firms and basically anyone who can put up the money.

It’s time for the moaning minnies and the doom mongers to pipe down and stand up for the great British institution of parliamentary payola. No one does it better than us. We have an entire parliamentary institution dedicated to peddling influence: the House of Lords. A fine body of unelected men and women whose sole function appears to be to auction their services to the highest bidder. No parliament in the world has anything like it. A legislature with rules so light of touch that when Lords are found with their fingers in the till, there is nothing whatever that anyone can do about it. They can’t be expelled or suspended. They can’t even be voted out by the electorate. Perfect. Britain has built post-modern irony into its very system of government.

We should celebrate this noble institution of “Lords for Hire” by setting up a metering system - an ermined cab-rank outside the Houses of Parliament where commercial interests can hire noble Lords by the hour. Then no one would be in any doubt about what the real business of the Upper House is.