Since the economic crisis broke earlier this year this column has never knowingly understated its severity. But I make no apologies for having dwelt on doom and gloom. For most of 2008 government, regulators and monetary authorities were in denial about the severity of the crisis. We were repeatedly told that the end was in sight, that the economic fundamentals were sound, that Britain was well placed to ride out economic turbulence. Well, now we know.
However, there is a point beyond which realism turns into negativity. The danger now is that this pessimism becomes self-reinforcing. Indeed, the difference between a deep recession and an economic depression is, as the term suggests, largely psychological. Beyond a certain point people begin to lose hope of any recovery and a negative feedback loop stifles economic activity. So, as we end the most dramatic year since 1929 we really have t to start thinking now about the economic recovery that will eventually come.
Unfortunately, it isn’t imminent. The Chancellor’s forecast that Britain will emerge from recession late next year is about as likely as Speaker Michael Martin admitting he has made an error of judgement. We face a long and lean time while the economy works through the excesses of a credit boom which lasted over twenty years. However, this doesn’t preclude a stock market rally sometime in the New Year. Indeed, the chances are high that there will be a turnaround in the markets in 2009. Shares are extremely cheap by historic standards and there is a lot of cash sitting on the sidelines of the global stock-markets which is earning next to nothing because interest rates are so low.
This rally will not indicate the end of the financial crisis, or even the beginning of the end. Contrary to myth, the Great Crash of 1929 wasn’t a single event but a series of shocks spread over eight years after a succession of bear market rallies. Slashing rates to zero could even ignite another economic bubble or two - though that is something we should dearly wish to avoid. The global commodities bubble, which has just burst in spectacular fashion , was almost entirely a result of the US Federal Reserve slashing interest rates in America at the end of last year. Oil rose to nearly $150 a barrel; now it is forecast to fall to $25.
The 2008 Crash was in reality the bursting of succession of bubbles: a credit bubble, a property bubble, a commodities bubble and even an emerging nations bubble. Never in history have so many asset classes collapsed at the same time and across the globe. Everything has been marked down, from oil to house prices, from gold to shares. This is why the crisis is so profound. It is the first truly global synchronised economic collapse - a product of the internationalisation of financial markets and the growth of world trade.
However, the good news is that when the recovery begins, it is also likely to be global, and co-ordinated. The nations of the world are now linked together through trading and financial markets as never before in history. Only if there is a return to outright protectionism - to countries protecting their industries by tariff walls - is this global network of economic linkages likely to be broken. Which is why it is so important for bodies like the G20 of leading nations to promote free trade at the same time as seeking to control and regulate international financial markets. New products are being created all the time, in everything from life sciences to robotics, which will provide the markets for the future - provided they can get to market.
However, free trade must also coincide with a commitment to social equality. The huge disparities of wealth which had been allowed to develop both within and between nations during the bubble years are a large part of the problem. American consumers are in a debt crisis largely because middle class salaries have stagnated for the last decade as the top one percent of US citizens has acquired disproportionate wealth. Rich people do not spend most of their money; they invest it in assets like houses and shares, which boosted the bubble economy.
The New Deal in the 1930s coincided with a very great increase in taxation on wealth. It was this redistribution that allowed the consumer society to be created out of the wreckage of the Second World War. The economy boomed in he 50s because ordinary people could afford to buy things. Even poorer countries like China and India today, which have been investing much of their sovereign wealth in US bonds and mortgage assets, need to develop their own consumer markets to recycle their foreign earnings. Otherwise we will just have yet more asset bubbles.
Of course, this doesn’t mean we can afford to go back to the hyper-consumerism of the recent years. The noughties will go down in history as the dumbest boom in history, as we squandered the world’s precious resources shipping across the world huge quantities of toys and trinkets that we didn’t need, and mostly didn’t want. The new consumer industries will have to be environmentally sustainable and focussed on conserving rather than exploiting natural resources. There is no law that says economies have to built on the irresponsible burning of fossil fuels.
Indeed, the markets that will provide the impetus for the economic upswing in the 2010s will largely be in the field of renewable energy and conservation. These will be immense markets because they are environmental imperatives. We really don’t have any choice but to combat climate change, which is now happening faster even than the worst pessimists believed possible ten years ago. The economic effort that will have to be mobilised to restore the climatic balance of the planet will bring even the deepest economic depression to an end.
In truth, it wasn’t the New Deal in America that ended the Great Depression, it was the Second World War. The Keynsian reforms introduced by governments across the world after 1932 helped, but mass unemployment continued until America and Europe began rearmament programmes in the late 1930s. Well, the challenge today is not European war but the threat of planetary extinction. This will again force governments to override market mechanisms in order focus on the greatest challenge humanity has ever faced.
Well, no one said recovery was going to be easy.
Monday, December 08, 2008
We are drowing in debt
It’s not bad being a banker, really. All you have to do is borrow money at a low interest rate from the government and then lend it at a higher interest rate to businesses and mortgagees. Doesn’t take a lot of genius to do that. Even I could make money out of it.
So, why does the government waste its breath squealing at the financiers to pass on interest rate reductions? If they’re serious, why don’t they just move in and take operational control of the banks - many of them are state-owned already like Northern Rock and Bradford and Bingley, or with a large state holding like RBS. It’s not as if banking requires any special skills. You could nationalise the lot and no one would notice except luxury car dealers and yacht builders.
But no, ministers would prefer to stand on the sidelines shouting and pointing fingers at the nasty bankers for refusing to lend. Well, the banksters deserve it, you cannot deny that. I was one of the first to denounce the practices that got us into this mess. Their predatory lending, extravagant greed, short-sightedness and plain stupidity have condemned them in the public eye for a generation. Everyone is talking about a return to the Seventies, with economic crisis and mass unemployment, but this time it’s not the trades union barons who are in the dock of history, but bankers.
However, like the trades unoins the banks aren’t always wrong, and in one respect they are introducing an element of sanity into monetary policy as the government tries to turn the clock back to 2007. They are pointing out that this is a debt crisis and that taking on more debt isn’t necessarily going to get us out of it. That we have to save for the future, and that means making it worthwhile for people so to do. The governmente seems to have been persuaded to adopt the opposit policy, of slashing interest rates and debasing the currency by “quantitative easing” or printing money. The idea - though they won’t put it quite this way - is to ignite inflation so that people with savings are forced to spend it, or see its value evaporate.
Someone needs to say this right now as caution, and money, is thrown to the winds. The government and the Bank of England have gone from complacency to panic in a matter of weeks. Only last summer we were still being told that the economic fundamentals were sound and that the end was in sight; now it’s just The End they see. Instead of the measured dont-frighten-the-horses quarter percent steps on interst rates, the Bank of England has taken to massive one and one-and-a-half point leaps which not only frighten the horses, they make the rest of the world bolt for the door. If the government were trying to engineer a sterling crisis, it couldn’t do much better.
Now, it is true that deflation is not very nice. Prices fall and businesses go bust. But there is a logic to it. After all, the present crisis is almost entirely a result of an unsustainable consumer boom financed by debt. The British people owe £1.5 trillion in personal debt - considerably more than the nation’s GDP. The number of people who spend more than they earn has risen to nearly 5.3 trillion, according to Legal in General. Meanwhile the government is on the way to a trillion pound deficit. This means that, by next year, very household in Britain will carry £50,000 of public debt as well as an average of £60,000 in personal debt - that’s a almost Icelandic total of £110,000. The governmenet hope that rising prices will lower the value of these debts. But this is not just an temporary imbalance on peoples’ domestic accounts we are talking about, ;it is a chronic and ingrained debt habit which must be broken if the economy is to be stabilised in future.
The inconvenient truth is that we simply have to save. The banks are doing this trying to keep their deposit interest rates high to encouage people to save with them. This isn’t out of philanthropy - they need the cash to rebuild their balance sheets. But they point out, fairly, that low interest rates penalise many older people who rely on their savings in retirement. We have yet to hear from silver surfers about the raid on their living standards, but the government might do well to reflect on the fact tht there are now more people over 65 in Brtiain than there are under 16, and that older people are much more likely to vote than the under 34s.,
The government hopes that low interest rates will get people buying houses again. But there is no guarantee that slashing rates and printing money will necessarily stabilise the housing market. Frankly, no one is going to buy houses in a collapsing market no matter how low interest rates go. In neither America nor Japan has low interest rates halted the collapse of unsustainable house prices. Indeed, the Japanese housing crash has lasted nearly twenty years. Anyway, the last thing we need is another housing bubble.
There’s no mystery about what the government is trying to do. After the Black October crash, the government and the Bank of England got out their history books and started looking at what happened in the Great Depression. In September 1931, as unemployment reached 3 million, the National Government slashed interest rates and abandoned the gold standard. The value of the pound fell by 25%, just as it has today. Interest rates fell from 6% to 2% - deja vu - and this led to a modest, export-led recovery. Unemployment fell marginally in 1935 as a recovery in the housing market, mainly in the south of England, boosted economic activity. The government is clearly trying to do the same today.
However, this isn’t the 1930s. For one thing, there was a lot of spare capacity then in the economy, which is not the case today. We also had the Empire. Britain erected tariff walls against imports and used the colonies - yes we still had them - to provide cheap food imports. The 1930s depression wasn’t caused by consumer spending and debt, it was a classic crisis of ineffective demand.
Also: it didn’t really work. Unemployment remained stubbornly high throughout the 1930s outside the South East of England, and it was only rearmament, as the Second World War approached, that ended mass joblessness. We are in a very different sitution today. We cannot seek salvation in another unsustainable boom and we certainly cannot afford to go to war. We have to get out of this one ourselves. And I fear that the government is going in the wrong direction.
So, why does the government waste its breath squealing at the financiers to pass on interest rate reductions? If they’re serious, why don’t they just move in and take operational control of the banks - many of them are state-owned already like Northern Rock and Bradford and Bingley, or with a large state holding like RBS. It’s not as if banking requires any special skills. You could nationalise the lot and no one would notice except luxury car dealers and yacht builders.
But no, ministers would prefer to stand on the sidelines shouting and pointing fingers at the nasty bankers for refusing to lend. Well, the banksters deserve it, you cannot deny that. I was one of the first to denounce the practices that got us into this mess. Their predatory lending, extravagant greed, short-sightedness and plain stupidity have condemned them in the public eye for a generation. Everyone is talking about a return to the Seventies, with economic crisis and mass unemployment, but this time it’s not the trades union barons who are in the dock of history, but bankers.
However, like the trades unoins the banks aren’t always wrong, and in one respect they are introducing an element of sanity into monetary policy as the government tries to turn the clock back to 2007. They are pointing out that this is a debt crisis and that taking on more debt isn’t necessarily going to get us out of it. That we have to save for the future, and that means making it worthwhile for people so to do. The governmente seems to have been persuaded to adopt the opposit policy, of slashing interest rates and debasing the currency by “quantitative easing” or printing money. The idea - though they won’t put it quite this way - is to ignite inflation so that people with savings are forced to spend it, or see its value evaporate.
Someone needs to say this right now as caution, and money, is thrown to the winds. The government and the Bank of England have gone from complacency to panic in a matter of weeks. Only last summer we were still being told that the economic fundamentals were sound and that the end was in sight; now it’s just The End they see. Instead of the measured dont-frighten-the-horses quarter percent steps on interst rates, the Bank of England has taken to massive one and one-and-a-half point leaps which not only frighten the horses, they make the rest of the world bolt for the door. If the government were trying to engineer a sterling crisis, it couldn’t do much better.
Now, it is true that deflation is not very nice. Prices fall and businesses go bust. But there is a logic to it. After all, the present crisis is almost entirely a result of an unsustainable consumer boom financed by debt. The British people owe £1.5 trillion in personal debt - considerably more than the nation’s GDP. The number of people who spend more than they earn has risen to nearly 5.3 trillion, according to Legal in General. Meanwhile the government is on the way to a trillion pound deficit. This means that, by next year, very household in Britain will carry £50,000 of public debt as well as an average of £60,000 in personal debt - that’s a almost Icelandic total of £110,000. The governmenet hope that rising prices will lower the value of these debts. But this is not just an temporary imbalance on peoples’ domestic accounts we are talking about, ;it is a chronic and ingrained debt habit which must be broken if the economy is to be stabilised in future.
The inconvenient truth is that we simply have to save. The banks are doing this trying to keep their deposit interest rates high to encouage people to save with them. This isn’t out of philanthropy - they need the cash to rebuild their balance sheets. But they point out, fairly, that low interest rates penalise many older people who rely on their savings in retirement. We have yet to hear from silver surfers about the raid on their living standards, but the government might do well to reflect on the fact tht there are now more people over 65 in Brtiain than there are under 16, and that older people are much more likely to vote than the under 34s.,
The government hopes that low interest rates will get people buying houses again. But there is no guarantee that slashing rates and printing money will necessarily stabilise the housing market. Frankly, no one is going to buy houses in a collapsing market no matter how low interest rates go. In neither America nor Japan has low interest rates halted the collapse of unsustainable house prices. Indeed, the Japanese housing crash has lasted nearly twenty years. Anyway, the last thing we need is another housing bubble.
There’s no mystery about what the government is trying to do. After the Black October crash, the government and the Bank of England got out their history books and started looking at what happened in the Great Depression. In September 1931, as unemployment reached 3 million, the National Government slashed interest rates and abandoned the gold standard. The value of the pound fell by 25%, just as it has today. Interest rates fell from 6% to 2% - deja vu - and this led to a modest, export-led recovery. Unemployment fell marginally in 1935 as a recovery in the housing market, mainly in the south of England, boosted economic activity. The government is clearly trying to do the same today.
However, this isn’t the 1930s. For one thing, there was a lot of spare capacity then in the economy, which is not the case today. We also had the Empire. Britain erected tariff walls against imports and used the colonies - yes we still had them - to provide cheap food imports. The 1930s depression wasn’t caused by consumer spending and debt, it was a classic crisis of ineffective demand.
Also: it didn’t really work. Unemployment remained stubbornly high throughout the 1930s outside the South East of England, and it was only rearmament, as the Second World War approached, that ended mass joblessness. We are in a very different sitution today. We cannot seek salvation in another unsustainable boom and we certainly cannot afford to go to war. We have to get out of this one ourselves. And I fear that the government is going in the wrong direction.
Saturday, November 29, 2008
Let's buy more stuff
"From New Labour to hard labour" was Alex Salmond's verdict on the Chancellor's emergency budget last week. Actually there's not likely to be a lot of labour, hard or otherwise, since many of us will be unemployed by the time the Darling squeeze hits in two years time. .The rate of job losses in recent weeks has been astounding, with famous names like Woolies and MFI joining BT, AstraZeneca, Citigroup. You could be forgiven for thinking that the roof is falling in.
Of course, the government has tried to fix the roof (which they insist was in a very good state anyway) by the Chancellor's much-vaunted fiscal stimulus. Last week was supposed to be a give-away budget, but not a lot was given away - about £20bn - and most of us don't intend to spend it anyway. Given the state of the public finances, Darling's room for manoeuvre was not great. Then there's the issue of consumer fatigue.
In Keynsian economic theory - the government’s version of it anyway - the way to stop the economy from seizing up is to persuade people to buy more stuff. You may have wardrobes stuffed full of rubbish already. Primark clothing is clogging landfill sites. And the nation may be mired in debt as a result of retail therapy. But no: your duty is to consume. So get out there onto the Christmas front line and spend spend spend!
Except that if we have half a brain we won't. Spending more money we don't have on rubbish we don't need is not a rational response to this credit crisis. Nor is it a rational approach to the environment. And we're just too well informed nowadays to respond to crude Pavlovian stimuli like upfront tax cuts. We can all read on the internet that taxes are going to go up sharply in two years to take it all back. The only sensible thing to do right now is to save and pay off debt
But the government is determined to force us to spend even though they know, and we know, that the days of mindless consumerism are over. When this fiscal stimulus fails, as it did in America last year, the monetary authorities will turn to more pernicious ways of forcing us to spend. In the States, the Federal Reserve has turned to what they call "quantitative easing" and what the rest of us call printing money.
The Fed Chairman, Ben Berenanke, is often called "helicopter Ben" because he once said that, to head off deflation, he would drop piles of dollars on Wall Street by helicopter if necessary. The Fed is throwing hundreds of billions, indeed trillions of unfunded dollars at the broken banking system - buying up worthless mortgages and keeping bankrupt behemoths like AIG and Citigroup and Fannie and Freddie going. This will cause a fall in the purchasing power of the dollar, but the monetary authorities hope that this inflation will cut the value of the huge debts of banks and homeowners and make them more inclined to lend and borrow again. Inflation penalises savers, and forces them to spend because if they don't, and if interest rates are low, the value of their bank accounts will just dwindle to nothing.In other words, the cost of this bailout could be the impoverishment of millions of people who are about to retire and live on fixed incomes. Talk about moral hazard! Who is ever going to save again if all they do is reward people who get into debt?
Now, there is a lot to be said for Keynsianism, but a lot of things are being done in the late economist’s name of which he would surely disapprove. Irresponsible monetary inflation is one of them. Keynes advocated ‘deficit financing’ (government borrowing to invest) in very different circumstances to those operating today. In the 1930s, there was huge unused capacity ( factories and machines lying idle) in Britain and America. Today, most manufacturing has been out sourced to countries like India and China, where factories are becoming idle at a rate of a thousand a week. It isn't so easy to promote productive activity in an economy like ours which has become dominated by a huge parasitical financial services industry.
Government borrowing is looking bad enough already without any more deficits being financed The institute for Fiscal Studies has calculated that the squeeze in public spending - the Chancellor wants it to fall to 1.1 percent in 2011-14 - will involve GBP37bn being cut from planned departmental budgets - more even than the Tories were calling for before the budget. Yes, while condemning George Osborne for seeking to cut schools and hospitals, Labour were planning to do exactly the same.
And that's on the Chancellor's best case scenario of the economy coming out of recession next year, which is complete fantasy. This recession is going to be long and deep. Moreover, the government figures don't include the cost of the banking bailouts, the PFI projects that have to come onto the public spending figures under new accounting rules next April, or the unfunded liabilities of public sector pensions. This amounts to a colossal risk added to the public accounts.
We are not talking of 'just' a doubling of public debt next year to GBP 118bn, but potentially very much more than that. This is why the international markets are turning against sterling. Really, we are in for very substantial spending cuts - far greater than the GBP 500m off the Scottish budget that the First Minister flagged up last week. This will lead to job losses in the labour intensive public sector just as the private sector is dumping hundreds of thousands on the dole.
Things are not good for UKPLC. Our delinquent banks have been borrowing beyond our means, turning Britain into something like a giant hedge fund. The emergency budget will make little difference. Financially, we are in a similar situation to Iceland before the crunch, and we cannot rule out sharing their fate. Hyperinflation could follow a brief deflation next year and there is likely to be a run on the pound. No one knows how to deal with this yet. Unlike the US, we cannot export our debt to other countries because sterling isn't a reserve currency.
There seems only one solution and that is to ask the EU very, very nicely if we could - ahem - join the security of the single currency without delay. All of Brown's 1997 'tests' are anyway met. The only thing he has to fear is fear itself.
Of course, the government has tried to fix the roof (which they insist was in a very good state anyway) by the Chancellor's much-vaunted fiscal stimulus. Last week was supposed to be a give-away budget, but not a lot was given away - about £20bn - and most of us don't intend to spend it anyway. Given the state of the public finances, Darling's room for manoeuvre was not great. Then there's the issue of consumer fatigue.
In Keynsian economic theory - the government’s version of it anyway - the way to stop the economy from seizing up is to persuade people to buy more stuff. You may have wardrobes stuffed full of rubbish already. Primark clothing is clogging landfill sites. And the nation may be mired in debt as a result of retail therapy. But no: your duty is to consume. So get out there onto the Christmas front line and spend spend spend!
Except that if we have half a brain we won't. Spending more money we don't have on rubbish we don't need is not a rational response to this credit crisis. Nor is it a rational approach to the environment. And we're just too well informed nowadays to respond to crude Pavlovian stimuli like upfront tax cuts. We can all read on the internet that taxes are going to go up sharply in two years to take it all back. The only sensible thing to do right now is to save and pay off debt
But the government is determined to force us to spend even though they know, and we know, that the days of mindless consumerism are over. When this fiscal stimulus fails, as it did in America last year, the monetary authorities will turn to more pernicious ways of forcing us to spend. In the States, the Federal Reserve has turned to what they call "quantitative easing" and what the rest of us call printing money.
The Fed Chairman, Ben Berenanke, is often called "helicopter Ben" because he once said that, to head off deflation, he would drop piles of dollars on Wall Street by helicopter if necessary. The Fed is throwing hundreds of billions, indeed trillions of unfunded dollars at the broken banking system - buying up worthless mortgages and keeping bankrupt behemoths like AIG and Citigroup and Fannie and Freddie going. This will cause a fall in the purchasing power of the dollar, but the monetary authorities hope that this inflation will cut the value of the huge debts of banks and homeowners and make them more inclined to lend and borrow again. Inflation penalises savers, and forces them to spend because if they don't, and if interest rates are low, the value of their bank accounts will just dwindle to nothing.In other words, the cost of this bailout could be the impoverishment of millions of people who are about to retire and live on fixed incomes. Talk about moral hazard! Who is ever going to save again if all they do is reward people who get into debt?
Now, there is a lot to be said for Keynsianism, but a lot of things are being done in the late economist’s name of which he would surely disapprove. Irresponsible monetary inflation is one of them. Keynes advocated ‘deficit financing’ (government borrowing to invest) in very different circumstances to those operating today. In the 1930s, there was huge unused capacity ( factories and machines lying idle) in Britain and America. Today, most manufacturing has been out sourced to countries like India and China, where factories are becoming idle at a rate of a thousand a week. It isn't so easy to promote productive activity in an economy like ours which has become dominated by a huge parasitical financial services industry.
Government borrowing is looking bad enough already without any more deficits being financed The institute for Fiscal Studies has calculated that the squeeze in public spending - the Chancellor wants it to fall to 1.1 percent in 2011-14 - will involve GBP37bn being cut from planned departmental budgets - more even than the Tories were calling for before the budget. Yes, while condemning George Osborne for seeking to cut schools and hospitals, Labour were planning to do exactly the same.
And that's on the Chancellor's best case scenario of the economy coming out of recession next year, which is complete fantasy. This recession is going to be long and deep. Moreover, the government figures don't include the cost of the banking bailouts, the PFI projects that have to come onto the public spending figures under new accounting rules next April, or the unfunded liabilities of public sector pensions. This amounts to a colossal risk added to the public accounts.
We are not talking of 'just' a doubling of public debt next year to GBP 118bn, but potentially very much more than that. This is why the international markets are turning against sterling. Really, we are in for very substantial spending cuts - far greater than the GBP 500m off the Scottish budget that the First Minister flagged up last week. This will lead to job losses in the labour intensive public sector just as the private sector is dumping hundreds of thousands on the dole.
Things are not good for UKPLC. Our delinquent banks have been borrowing beyond our means, turning Britain into something like a giant hedge fund. The emergency budget will make little difference. Financially, we are in a similar situation to Iceland before the crunch, and we cannot rule out sharing their fate. Hyperinflation could follow a brief deflation next year and there is likely to be a run on the pound. No one knows how to deal with this yet. Unlike the US, we cannot export our debt to other countries because sterling isn't a reserve currency.
There seems only one solution and that is to ask the EU very, very nicely if we could - ahem - join the security of the single currency without delay. All of Brown's 1997 'tests' are anyway met. The only thing he has to fear is fear itself.
Saturday, November 22, 2008
Labour isn't working. Again
The poster that won the 1979 general election was, of course, a fake. The “Labour isn’t working” dole queue was actually composed of twenty fully-employed Hendon Conservatives photographed again and again. But there was nothing synthetic about the impact on Labour government of James Callaghan. Never again, Labour resolved, could the party afford to go to the country when the country was out of work. Yet that is what Gordon Brown risks doing if you believe the spin about the PM delaying the next general election until 2010. There is an unemployment tsunami hitting approaching Britain.
2008 was the year of the panic as oil prices spiked, banks exploded and stock markets collapsed. 2009 will be the year of the dole as unemployment, already higher than at any time since Labour came to office in 1997, climbs inexorably to 3 million by 2010, according to the CBI. The turnaround in the UK employment market has been astonishing. The pace of current job losses, led by the shakeout in the banking sector, has staggered analysts. 300,000 private sector jobs have gone in the last six months of this year alone (CEBR). The 3 million forecast made only ten days ago is almost certainly an underestimate, since the CBI based it on Britain’s GDP declining by 1.7% in 2009, and the Bank of England is now talking about the economy shrinking by 2% next year as Britain enters the worst recession since 1980 . And let’s not even mention that analysts like Stephen King of HSBC say that the official ILO unemployment figures exclude two million people who are economically inactive but would like a job.
What is undeniable is that British firms are indulging in an orgy of redundancy as the 'flexible' labour market allows them to fire first and think later. The good news is that the region hardest hit is likely to be the one most able to cope: the South East, and in particular the London area which is going to lose 650 thousand jobs according to the Local Government Association. This is the one of the wealthiest areas on the planet thanks to the financial services sector based in the City. Mind you, all those redundant middle class professionals might find life a little different on £60 a week job seekers allowance. But they can look after themselves. The people who will have their lives destroyed first are the legions of temporary and casual workers many of whom don’t figure on the unemployment figures because of their age or country of origin. Polish plumbers at least have somewhere to go home to.
Here there are signs that redundancies are being used by some firms as a means of communicating with shareholders and bolstering equity prices. When BT announced 10,000 redundancies two weeks ago it made no attempt to play down the human cost, and according to some analysts, even exaggerated the job losses for effect. Certainly, companies no longer feel they need to apologise for throwing workers on the scrap heap. Firms like Virgin, AstraZeneca, Rolls Royce, Yell, Wolesley, Citigroup have been falling over themselves to announce thousand-plus job reductions in the last fortnight alone. The flexible labour market, inspired by the Tories and realised by New Labour, has allowed contraction to be a first, rather than a last resort. It is the quickest way for a management in trouble to show that they are doing something.
The problem is that this job destruction, rather like banks refusing to lend to small business, is enormously destructive to the broader economy. After nearly three decades of de-industrialisation, the UK desperately needs to protect those skills it has, not allow them to decay on the dole queues. But with trades unions weak, employment law liberal and the government compliant, firms are being allowed to cut the seed corn of the future. This week, following the Pre Budget Report, we are looking to the state to counter the effect of this attrition, as the Chancellor’s tax cuts boost pre-Christmas demand in the high streets. But the government's ability to directly fill the job gap is severely limited. Yes, the public sector is still hiring, and has put on 50,000 jobs in six months according to CEBR. But with public borrowing likely to reach at least £118bn next year, there will have to be a retrenchment in the highly labour-intensive public sector to get public finances into some kind of order in the medium term. Make no mistake - this year's fiscal stimulus will likely be bought at the cost of public sector job losses, even with the Chancellor's heroic assumptions about an economic recovery in 2010.
Nor can the low pound be relied upon to boost employment in export industries in the meantime. This is a global recession, perhaps a global depression, and Britain cannot rely on international markets to replace lost domestic demand. There is also likely to be a wave of protectionism, starting in the US, as countries seek to save their own core industries by state subsidies and other anticompetitive practices. The world market may be a tougher sell in future. Anyway, Britain has lost most of its manufacturing base in the last three decades - down to 14% of GDP - and most of our "exports" in recent years have been in financial services, “invisibles”, the demand for which will be slight for the duration of the credit crunch.
We can be thankful at least that the right man is in the White House at the right time. The Chancellor has moved some way towards matching Barack Obama’s plan to create 2.5 million jobs over the next two years through public work projects and alternative energy investment. But this won’t happen overnight, and will do little to alter the job losses already in train. And in America, which is a 12 to 18 months ahead of Britain, things have already become desperate for people on the margin. U.S. Department of Agriculture reported last week that the number of children who went hungry in 2007 - the first year of the credit crunch - jumped by 50% to over 700,000. Overall, 12.2 of Americans, 36.2 million, "do not have the money or assistance to get enough food to maintain active, healthy lives." Don’t think it couldn’t happen here.
At the very least, Britain faces a return to the early Eighties: a period of sustained joblessness and the destructive psychology that accompanies it. Time perhaps to dig out those old newsreels of industrial armies facing the police lines as they fought to save their jobs. Except, of course, that it won't be like that this time round. There will be dole queues, of course, but the social composition of the new jobless - led by financial services, property, retail - will be very different. As a recent report from the Chartered Institute of Personnel Development argued, those at most risk in the coming “redundancy torrent” will be managers, professionals and skilled non manual workers.
The talk of a "white collar recession" is not all myopic hogwash by middle class journalists facing an insecure future. Just look at the tens of thousands of jobs about to evaporate from the British banks. Then multiply that by all the professional jobs that depended on those middle class incomes like estate agents and lawyers. Of course, in this recession, as in all previous ones, the first people to be hit will be those at he bottom . But they are likely to be joined by large numbers of articulate middle class individuals shaken out of sectors like finance, the media and the countless peripheral service occupations - from aromatherapy to management consultancy - which have grown up during the long boom.
This is going to be a severe shock to the self-confidence and self-esteem of the middle class - a social and cultural transformation that could have profound political implications. In the 1980s, the middle classes were still relatively secure in their career structures in management and the professions. They had homes, occupational pensions, assured promotion. Certainly, they were a world away from the trades unionists fighting for their jobs in the old industrial heartlands of Britain. Margaret Thatcher could rely on the middle class to support her war on the militants with their braziers - the people who were blamed for 80's recession. Well, the braziers are gone, and industrial working class has largely been dismantled, but so have the secure middle class career structures.
When i joined the BBC from university in the 80s, it was very much a job for life with annual pay increments, annual promotion, pension rights and a predictable future. Not any more. The modern media is a shifting sea of freelance and contract workers working for subcontractors to the large institutions. In the BBC there is a crust of highly paid performers like Jonathan Ross and all those anonymous executives who earn more than the Prime Minister, and a huge army of irregulars often on startlingly low salaries coming in and out of the corporation's revolving doors. The commercial sector has been relying on large numbers of underpaid or unpaid "interns" who will do anything to get a job. The flexible labour market operates in a particularly pernicious manner in the media for obvious reasons: a lot of people want to get a foothold in that world. But is not so different from the British economy as a whole.
After a couple of decades of deregulation and leveraged buy-outs by private equity, many firms have flattened their management structures considerably, often relying on outside consultants to get them through busy periods. Occupational pensions have become a rarity. Promotion has become intensely meritocratic. Companies have also begun to "offshore" many white collar functions to countries like India with an educated middle class willing to work for much lower wages than in the UK. Most of the job losses at BT are among self-employed contract workers in the UK, while the company has not axed any of the jobs it has outsourced to India. As a consequence of all this the middle classes are - outside the public sector - facing a very difficult time. Small wonder that there are record numbers of applicants for jobs like teaching and lecturing.
The group hit most hard are the under-thirty 35s, the sons and daughter of the post war baby-boom, who have emerged from university with large debts and even larger expectations. Sometimes called the "smug generation" these are the young people who have little experience of recession in their adult lives and none of mass unemployment. Neither have their parents, who lived sailed through the 70.s and 80s largely untouched by unemployment or debt. if there is going to be a political response to the new depression, it is likely to emerge from this group of déclassé graduates, many of whom now face a future without the middle class security they have been brought up to expect - who cannot afford to buy houses, are unable to establish a career. Indeed the under-35s have so much personal debt that their net wealth is actually negative. Locked out of the housing market, three quarters of under-35s are in the red, according to the Skipton Building Society, owing more than £9,000 on average. They will look to the state for security, but the state will not be able to deliver.
As I was researching this piece I came across a remarkable forecast from a Ministry of Defence think tank about the future of political militancy. Published in April 2007 this DCDC report speculated that in coming years “The world’s middle classes might unite, using access to knowledge, resources and skills to shape transnational processes in their own class interest,” and that, “The middle classes could become a revolutionary class taking the role envisaged for he proletariat by Marx...the growing gap between themselves and a small number of highly visible super-rich might fuel disillusion...” This was dismissed as idle futurology at the time, and the idea of Marxist revolution sweeping suburbia is faintly risible. But the MoD may have grasped an important truth about the nature of politics in the new global economy - that it has begun to erode class differentiation and left many middle income earners exposed to the kind of insecurities which formerly afflicted lower class workers. Clearly, the economic circumstances of management consultants cannot be compared directly with those of retail workers. But when they find themselves losing their jobs, they face now many of the same challenges: mortgage, debt, catastrophic loss of earnings and retraining. At the very least, it will be very much more difficult for political leader to find scapegoats as the current recession develops. Already the government is having to backtrack on attempts to force single parents, older workers and people with disabilities back into the labour force.
Part of the Conservative leader, David Cameron’s difficulty in developing a coherent political response to Gordon Brown’s neo-Keynsianism, is that the party of capital has lost its 'class enemy': the industrial working class. There is no trade union menace to blame for economic distress and the Conservatives have had to fall back on fiscal conservatism - spending down public debt - which is simply not a priority for an electorate which is looking to the state to protect it from the predations of the market. Equally, New Labour under Gordon Brown, has been forced almost against its will to become more critical of the plutocrats running the Banks, to accept nationalisation and greatly increased government spending. Gordon Brown has even abandoned one of the founding principles of New Labour by proposing higher taxes on the rich after the next general election.
The Conservatives, who have not entirely lost their Thatcherite reflexes, are looking to the middle classes to react against the new profligacy - but they will find it very difficult to do so. A unemployment mounts among the middle classes, especially among the under-35s, there is going to be a much stronger demand for policies which promote jobs and growth even at the cost of public borrowing. The Tories cannot afford to be on the wrong side of this battle. As Martin Hutchieson, author of Great Conservatives put it: “A world in which few if any have security in their livelihood is not conservative, it is anarchist. It is also deeply repugnant to the average voter”. If Labour isn't working, neither are the Conservatives.
2008 was the year of the panic as oil prices spiked, banks exploded and stock markets collapsed. 2009 will be the year of the dole as unemployment, already higher than at any time since Labour came to office in 1997, climbs inexorably to 3 million by 2010, according to the CBI. The turnaround in the UK employment market has been astonishing. The pace of current job losses, led by the shakeout in the banking sector, has staggered analysts. 300,000 private sector jobs have gone in the last six months of this year alone (CEBR). The 3 million forecast made only ten days ago is almost certainly an underestimate, since the CBI based it on Britain’s GDP declining by 1.7% in 2009, and the Bank of England is now talking about the economy shrinking by 2% next year as Britain enters the worst recession since 1980 . And let’s not even mention that analysts like Stephen King of HSBC say that the official ILO unemployment figures exclude two million people who are economically inactive but would like a job.
What is undeniable is that British firms are indulging in an orgy of redundancy as the 'flexible' labour market allows them to fire first and think later. The good news is that the region hardest hit is likely to be the one most able to cope: the South East, and in particular the London area which is going to lose 650 thousand jobs according to the Local Government Association. This is the one of the wealthiest areas on the planet thanks to the financial services sector based in the City. Mind you, all those redundant middle class professionals might find life a little different on £60 a week job seekers allowance. But they can look after themselves. The people who will have their lives destroyed first are the legions of temporary and casual workers many of whom don’t figure on the unemployment figures because of their age or country of origin. Polish plumbers at least have somewhere to go home to.
Here there are signs that redundancies are being used by some firms as a means of communicating with shareholders and bolstering equity prices. When BT announced 10,000 redundancies two weeks ago it made no attempt to play down the human cost, and according to some analysts, even exaggerated the job losses for effect. Certainly, companies no longer feel they need to apologise for throwing workers on the scrap heap. Firms like Virgin, AstraZeneca, Rolls Royce, Yell, Wolesley, Citigroup have been falling over themselves to announce thousand-plus job reductions in the last fortnight alone. The flexible labour market, inspired by the Tories and realised by New Labour, has allowed contraction to be a first, rather than a last resort. It is the quickest way for a management in trouble to show that they are doing something.
The problem is that this job destruction, rather like banks refusing to lend to small business, is enormously destructive to the broader economy. After nearly three decades of de-industrialisation, the UK desperately needs to protect those skills it has, not allow them to decay on the dole queues. But with trades unions weak, employment law liberal and the government compliant, firms are being allowed to cut the seed corn of the future. This week, following the Pre Budget Report, we are looking to the state to counter the effect of this attrition, as the Chancellor’s tax cuts boost pre-Christmas demand in the high streets. But the government's ability to directly fill the job gap is severely limited. Yes, the public sector is still hiring, and has put on 50,000 jobs in six months according to CEBR. But with public borrowing likely to reach at least £118bn next year, there will have to be a retrenchment in the highly labour-intensive public sector to get public finances into some kind of order in the medium term. Make no mistake - this year's fiscal stimulus will likely be bought at the cost of public sector job losses, even with the Chancellor's heroic assumptions about an economic recovery in 2010.
Nor can the low pound be relied upon to boost employment in export industries in the meantime. This is a global recession, perhaps a global depression, and Britain cannot rely on international markets to replace lost domestic demand. There is also likely to be a wave of protectionism, starting in the US, as countries seek to save their own core industries by state subsidies and other anticompetitive practices. The world market may be a tougher sell in future. Anyway, Britain has lost most of its manufacturing base in the last three decades - down to 14% of GDP - and most of our "exports" in recent years have been in financial services, “invisibles”, the demand for which will be slight for the duration of the credit crunch.
We can be thankful at least that the right man is in the White House at the right time. The Chancellor has moved some way towards matching Barack Obama’s plan to create 2.5 million jobs over the next two years through public work projects and alternative energy investment. But this won’t happen overnight, and will do little to alter the job losses already in train. And in America, which is a 12 to 18 months ahead of Britain, things have already become desperate for people on the margin. U.S. Department of Agriculture reported last week that the number of children who went hungry in 2007 - the first year of the credit crunch - jumped by 50% to over 700,000. Overall, 12.2 of Americans, 36.2 million, "do not have the money or assistance to get enough food to maintain active, healthy lives." Don’t think it couldn’t happen here.
At the very least, Britain faces a return to the early Eighties: a period of sustained joblessness and the destructive psychology that accompanies it. Time perhaps to dig out those old newsreels of industrial armies facing the police lines as they fought to save their jobs. Except, of course, that it won't be like that this time round. There will be dole queues, of course, but the social composition of the new jobless - led by financial services, property, retail - will be very different. As a recent report from the Chartered Institute of Personnel Development argued, those at most risk in the coming “redundancy torrent” will be managers, professionals and skilled non manual workers.
The talk of a "white collar recession" is not all myopic hogwash by middle class journalists facing an insecure future. Just look at the tens of thousands of jobs about to evaporate from the British banks. Then multiply that by all the professional jobs that depended on those middle class incomes like estate agents and lawyers. Of course, in this recession, as in all previous ones, the first people to be hit will be those at he bottom . But they are likely to be joined by large numbers of articulate middle class individuals shaken out of sectors like finance, the media and the countless peripheral service occupations - from aromatherapy to management consultancy - which have grown up during the long boom.
This is going to be a severe shock to the self-confidence and self-esteem of the middle class - a social and cultural transformation that could have profound political implications. In the 1980s, the middle classes were still relatively secure in their career structures in management and the professions. They had homes, occupational pensions, assured promotion. Certainly, they were a world away from the trades unionists fighting for their jobs in the old industrial heartlands of Britain. Margaret Thatcher could rely on the middle class to support her war on the militants with their braziers - the people who were blamed for 80's recession. Well, the braziers are gone, and industrial working class has largely been dismantled, but so have the secure middle class career structures.
When i joined the BBC from university in the 80s, it was very much a job for life with annual pay increments, annual promotion, pension rights and a predictable future. Not any more. The modern media is a shifting sea of freelance and contract workers working for subcontractors to the large institutions. In the BBC there is a crust of highly paid performers like Jonathan Ross and all those anonymous executives who earn more than the Prime Minister, and a huge army of irregulars often on startlingly low salaries coming in and out of the corporation's revolving doors. The commercial sector has been relying on large numbers of underpaid or unpaid "interns" who will do anything to get a job. The flexible labour market operates in a particularly pernicious manner in the media for obvious reasons: a lot of people want to get a foothold in that world. But is not so different from the British economy as a whole.
After a couple of decades of deregulation and leveraged buy-outs by private equity, many firms have flattened their management structures considerably, often relying on outside consultants to get them through busy periods. Occupational pensions have become a rarity. Promotion has become intensely meritocratic. Companies have also begun to "offshore" many white collar functions to countries like India with an educated middle class willing to work for much lower wages than in the UK. Most of the job losses at BT are among self-employed contract workers in the UK, while the company has not axed any of the jobs it has outsourced to India. As a consequence of all this the middle classes are - outside the public sector - facing a very difficult time. Small wonder that there are record numbers of applicants for jobs like teaching and lecturing.
The group hit most hard are the under-thirty 35s, the sons and daughter of the post war baby-boom, who have emerged from university with large debts and even larger expectations. Sometimes called the "smug generation" these are the young people who have little experience of recession in their adult lives and none of mass unemployment. Neither have their parents, who lived sailed through the 70.s and 80s largely untouched by unemployment or debt. if there is going to be a political response to the new depression, it is likely to emerge from this group of déclassé graduates, many of whom now face a future without the middle class security they have been brought up to expect - who cannot afford to buy houses, are unable to establish a career. Indeed the under-35s have so much personal debt that their net wealth is actually negative. Locked out of the housing market, three quarters of under-35s are in the red, according to the Skipton Building Society, owing more than £9,000 on average. They will look to the state for security, but the state will not be able to deliver.
As I was researching this piece I came across a remarkable forecast from a Ministry of Defence think tank about the future of political militancy. Published in April 2007 this DCDC report speculated that in coming years “The world’s middle classes might unite, using access to knowledge, resources and skills to shape transnational processes in their own class interest,” and that, “The middle classes could become a revolutionary class taking the role envisaged for he proletariat by Marx...the growing gap between themselves and a small number of highly visible super-rich might fuel disillusion...” This was dismissed as idle futurology at the time, and the idea of Marxist revolution sweeping suburbia is faintly risible. But the MoD may have grasped an important truth about the nature of politics in the new global economy - that it has begun to erode class differentiation and left many middle income earners exposed to the kind of insecurities which formerly afflicted lower class workers. Clearly, the economic circumstances of management consultants cannot be compared directly with those of retail workers. But when they find themselves losing their jobs, they face now many of the same challenges: mortgage, debt, catastrophic loss of earnings and retraining. At the very least, it will be very much more difficult for political leader to find scapegoats as the current recession develops. Already the government is having to backtrack on attempts to force single parents, older workers and people with disabilities back into the labour force.
Part of the Conservative leader, David Cameron’s difficulty in developing a coherent political response to Gordon Brown’s neo-Keynsianism, is that the party of capital has lost its 'class enemy': the industrial working class. There is no trade union menace to blame for economic distress and the Conservatives have had to fall back on fiscal conservatism - spending down public debt - which is simply not a priority for an electorate which is looking to the state to protect it from the predations of the market. Equally, New Labour under Gordon Brown, has been forced almost against its will to become more critical of the plutocrats running the Banks, to accept nationalisation and greatly increased government spending. Gordon Brown has even abandoned one of the founding principles of New Labour by proposing higher taxes on the rich after the next general election.
The Conservatives, who have not entirely lost their Thatcherite reflexes, are looking to the middle classes to react against the new profligacy - but they will find it very difficult to do so. A unemployment mounts among the middle classes, especially among the under-35s, there is going to be a much stronger demand for policies which promote jobs and growth even at the cost of public borrowing. The Tories cannot afford to be on the wrong side of this battle. As Martin Hutchieson, author of Great Conservatives put it: “A world in which few if any have security in their livelihood is not conservative, it is anarchist. It is also deeply repugnant to the average voter”. If Labour isn't working, neither are the Conservatives.
Strictly One Chancer
Supporters of the star of “Strictly One Chancer”, Alex Salmond, are urging him to resist pressure to leave the Holyrood show following his recent poor performance. Judges are insisting that “Lecky” as he has come to be known by his many adoring fans, is not fit to remain in the contest and is becoming and embarrassment.
“Salmond just isn’t up to it”, said judge Jim Murphy. ‘He has tripped up over any number of issues, like local income tax and the futures trust”, “it’s time for Salmond to take a jump for the sake of the programme and make way for someone who doesn’t have two left feet ”
However, Holyrood commentators fear there could be a popular outcry if the Strictly star were driven out by judges just because he is useless. “Alex is just what the doctor ordered”, said a voter who didn’t want to be named. “His humour and his willingness to take the knocks show that he is just the man for these difficult times. I can’t stop laughing whenever he comes on stage! Go on yersel’ Lecky!”
Since he entered the Holyrood show in 2007, Salmond has wowed audiences with his fancy footwork and his often hilarious quips and asides, such as promising to save Scotland’s bankrupt banks at the cost of hundreds of billions of pounds. His popularity soared week after week. But the Strictly contender fell on his face trying to do the notoriously difficult “arc of prosperity” dance with his Icelandic partner who had to retire. When he attempted the Glenrothes reel single-handed, even some of his greatest fans thought the time had come for Salmond to hang up his dancing shoes. “Salmond got the choreography wrong. He has angered some of the other contenders who think they should be where he is now. No one likes a person who tries to hog the limelight”.
However, it is Salmond’s continuing popularity that has angered the Westminster judging panel. They fear that if he is allowed to remain in the limelight Salmond might be even win the contest when the people are asked to deliver their final verdict in a referendum in 2010. “That would be a catastrophe”, said another prominent Westminster judge. “Just because a lot of the public like him is no reason why he should be allowed to win. He should do the decent thing.”
As for Salmond, he says he’ll pick himself up, dust himself off and start all over again. “It’s the punters who call the shots in this game and, as they say in showbiz: while the band still plays, you just gotta dance”.
“Salmond just isn’t up to it”, said judge Jim Murphy. ‘He has tripped up over any number of issues, like local income tax and the futures trust”, “it’s time for Salmond to take a jump for the sake of the programme and make way for someone who doesn’t have two left feet ”
However, Holyrood commentators fear there could be a popular outcry if the Strictly star were driven out by judges just because he is useless. “Alex is just what the doctor ordered”, said a voter who didn’t want to be named. “His humour and his willingness to take the knocks show that he is just the man for these difficult times. I can’t stop laughing whenever he comes on stage! Go on yersel’ Lecky!”
Since he entered the Holyrood show in 2007, Salmond has wowed audiences with his fancy footwork and his often hilarious quips and asides, such as promising to save Scotland’s bankrupt banks at the cost of hundreds of billions of pounds. His popularity soared week after week. But the Strictly contender fell on his face trying to do the notoriously difficult “arc of prosperity” dance with his Icelandic partner who had to retire. When he attempted the Glenrothes reel single-handed, even some of his greatest fans thought the time had come for Salmond to hang up his dancing shoes. “Salmond got the choreography wrong. He has angered some of the other contenders who think they should be where he is now. No one likes a person who tries to hog the limelight”.
However, it is Salmond’s continuing popularity that has angered the Westminster judging panel. They fear that if he is allowed to remain in the limelight Salmond might be even win the contest when the people are asked to deliver their final verdict in a referendum in 2010. “That would be a catastrophe”, said another prominent Westminster judge. “Just because a lot of the public like him is no reason why he should be allowed to win. He should do the decent thing.”
As for Salmond, he says he’ll pick himself up, dust himself off and start all over again. “It’s the punters who call the shots in this game and, as they say in showbiz: while the band still plays, you just gotta dance”.
Friday, November 21, 2008
Labour ARE thinking of a Spring election
Labour can hardly dare to believe their luck; the nation’s misfortune has been their salvation. The greatest economic crisis in half a century (and counting) has transformed their leader’s performance and their electoral prospects. The opinion polls are going Gordon Brown’s way. The Tories are all over the place, the Liberal Democrats are sinking without trace, and even the SNP is back in its hole (for the moment) after Glenrothes.
Do not believe the hype - Labour ARE thinking about an early election, in fact they can think of very little else. Only the bitter memory of the ‘election that never was’ in 2007 has stopped Labour ministers and MPs screaming from the rooftops “we’re back!” and that an early election is a foregone conclusion. Indeed, that election campaign will effectively begin tomorrow with the Chancellor, Alistair Darling’s, Pre Budget report.
This will set the scene for an election-winning budget in March which will feature a programme of spending projects and tax cuts on the theme of getting Britain back to work. Pie in the sky it may be, playing dangerous games with the public finances too, perhaps - but it will sound like a Keynsian return to the politics of growth and jobs, a New Deal from the “global chancellor”. And with tax cuts too, from a Labour not a Tory government, and plausibly justified on the grounds of fiscal stimulus.
David Cameron and George Osborne, have rejected tax cuts - to the dismay of the Tory core - and have called instead for public spending cuts.(ok, they say that they only want to halt increases, not cut headline figures - but it comes to the same thing) This allows Gordon Brown to cast them as latter day Thatcherites who would break the productive economy on the wheel of fiscal conservatism. Labour will dig out grainy footage of the Tory recessions in the 1980s, and evoke memories of punk monetarism and millions on the dole to hammer home the point that the Tories cannot be trusted to keep Britain in work.
David Cameron may be right to warn that you can’t get out of a debt crisis by borrowing. Cameron is certainly correct in saying that any big spending programmes and tax cuts will have to be paid for by higher taxes in future, if the size of the state is not reduced. But this is an very difficult argument to make in a country which may be falling, not just into a recession, but into a depression. The case for fiscal stimulus is almost unanswerable: the private sector is in ruin and can no longer deliver, so the state has no choice but to step in.
Gordon Brown will appear with Barack Obama at the next G20 meeting of industrial nations in London in April to hammer it home. The PM will lead the call for a new global financial system and Keynsian government interventionism. He will be applauded by economics professors like Reich and Nobel Prize-winner, Paul Krugman who are advising Obama and have been praising the Prime Minister for his vision. Profligacy is the new prudence.
The G20 will be an opportunity for Gordon Brown to bask in the reflected glory of the Obama presidency, still in its heroic phase. It could be the ideal springboard for an election in the spring or early summer of 2009 on the theme of keeping Britain in work. The CBI is forecasting three million unemployed by 2010, and while this will probably be an underestimate, it’s clear that most redundancies will not hit until later in 2009. Next spring unemployment will still be something of a novelty for most people.
Cutting and running? Hardly - the present government will be four years old by May 2009 and the two previous Labour administrations lasted four year terms. Indeed, not going to the country next year might begin to look like self-indulgence, or even lack of confidence. And after the disaster of the ‘election-that-never-was’ in 2007 the PM has to do everything possible to look decisive and purposeful. He has to meet his electoral destiny sometime and the sooner now the better.
So, it seems to me that an election next spring is almost unavoidable. But would he win it? Well, the opinion polls are going the right way, with the Tory lead cut to three percent last week in a MORi poll <> It is too early to say that Brown would win a working majority, but he would be in with a chance. And even if he misses narrowly he could still fall back on an alliance with the Liberal Democrats - “uniting the two radical strands of UK politics” which was a part of the original Blairite project.
The PM could even enlist the Liberal Democrat treasury spokesman, Vince Cable, into his government of national unity. Cable and Brown go back a long way, since the former contributed to Brown’s “Red Paper on Scotland” back in the 1970s. The Libdem economics guru is not only an astute politician but one of the best economic commentators around and was warning about the credit crisis before anyone else. Cable has called for nothing short of a “war economy”. Enlisting him into the new Brown administration, perhaps as a revamped employment minister, would convey the right sense of wartime cooperation - of parties pulling together to get the economy right. It would be blood, sweat and tears as the nation spits in the teeth of economic depression.
All except the Tories, of course, who have opted to play scrooge with their horrid public spending cuts. The Conservatives would be cast as latter day Thatcherites, hopelessly out of tune with the times. And Brown wouldn’t have to worry about the SNP spoiling the show, since - following Glenrothes - it looks improbable that Alex Salmond will be able to deliver his 20 nationalist MPs in any general election in June 2009.
The SNP leader cannot be written off, of course, and nationalism isn’t over just because HBOS has died the death. But most nationalists agree that there was a marked change in the air after the Glenrothes by-election. Tens of thousands of jobs are likely to go in the near future, and just as the banking unions have looked south for guarantees on job losses, so many Scots will - rightly or wrongly - look to London for their security, at least in the short term. at the very least it will take time for the nationalists to re-boot their politics to take account of the new situation.
The only person whose nose might be out of joint is Peter Mandelson the Business Secretary Last week the Business Secretary expressed a wish to emulate John Sergeant’s success on Strictly Come Dancing. He will face the humiliation of sitting around the same cabinet table as Vince Cable who was a great success on the reality dance contest two years ago. It could be murder on the dance-floor. But it’s a price worth paying for getting Gordon his second term
Do not believe the hype - Labour ARE thinking about an early election, in fact they can think of very little else. Only the bitter memory of the ‘election that never was’ in 2007 has stopped Labour ministers and MPs screaming from the rooftops “we’re back!” and that an early election is a foregone conclusion. Indeed, that election campaign will effectively begin tomorrow with the Chancellor, Alistair Darling’s, Pre Budget report.
This will set the scene for an election-winning budget in March which will feature a programme of spending projects and tax cuts on the theme of getting Britain back to work. Pie in the sky it may be, playing dangerous games with the public finances too, perhaps - but it will sound like a Keynsian return to the politics of growth and jobs, a New Deal from the “global chancellor”. And with tax cuts too, from a Labour not a Tory government, and plausibly justified on the grounds of fiscal stimulus.
David Cameron and George Osborne, have rejected tax cuts - to the dismay of the Tory core - and have called instead for public spending cuts.(ok, they say that they only want to halt increases, not cut headline figures - but it comes to the same thing) This allows Gordon Brown to cast them as latter day Thatcherites who would break the productive economy on the wheel of fiscal conservatism. Labour will dig out grainy footage of the Tory recessions in the 1980s, and evoke memories of punk monetarism and millions on the dole to hammer home the point that the Tories cannot be trusted to keep Britain in work.
David Cameron may be right to warn that you can’t get out of a debt crisis by borrowing. Cameron is certainly correct in saying that any big spending programmes and tax cuts will have to be paid for by higher taxes in future, if the size of the state is not reduced. But this is an very difficult argument to make in a country which may be falling, not just into a recession, but into a depression. The case for fiscal stimulus is almost unanswerable: the private sector is in ruin and can no longer deliver, so the state has no choice but to step in.
Gordon Brown will appear with Barack Obama at the next G20 meeting of industrial nations in London in April to hammer it home. The PM will lead the call for a new global financial system and Keynsian government interventionism. He will be applauded by economics professors like Reich and Nobel Prize-winner, Paul Krugman who are advising Obama and have been praising the Prime Minister for his vision. Profligacy is the new prudence.
The G20 will be an opportunity for Gordon Brown to bask in the reflected glory of the Obama presidency, still in its heroic phase. It could be the ideal springboard for an election in the spring or early summer of 2009 on the theme of keeping Britain in work. The CBI is forecasting three million unemployed by 2010, and while this will probably be an underestimate, it’s clear that most redundancies will not hit until later in 2009. Next spring unemployment will still be something of a novelty for most people.
Cutting and running? Hardly - the present government will be four years old by May 2009 and the two previous Labour administrations lasted four year terms. Indeed, not going to the country next year might begin to look like self-indulgence, or even lack of confidence. And after the disaster of the ‘election-that-never-was’ in 2007 the PM has to do everything possible to look decisive and purposeful. He has to meet his electoral destiny sometime and the sooner now the better.
So, it seems to me that an election next spring is almost unavoidable. But would he win it? Well, the opinion polls are going the right way, with the Tory lead cut to three percent last week in a MORi poll <
The PM could even enlist the Liberal Democrat treasury spokesman, Vince Cable, into his government of national unity. Cable and Brown go back a long way, since the former contributed to Brown’s “Red Paper on Scotland” back in the 1970s. The Libdem economics guru is not only an astute politician but one of the best economic commentators around and was warning about the credit crisis before anyone else. Cable has called for nothing short of a “war economy”. Enlisting him into the new Brown administration, perhaps as a revamped employment minister, would convey the right sense of wartime cooperation - of parties pulling together to get the economy right. It would be blood, sweat and tears as the nation spits in the teeth of economic depression.
All except the Tories, of course, who have opted to play scrooge with their horrid public spending cuts. The Conservatives would be cast as latter day Thatcherites, hopelessly out of tune with the times. And Brown wouldn’t have to worry about the SNP spoiling the show, since - following Glenrothes - it looks improbable that Alex Salmond will be able to deliver his 20 nationalist MPs in any general election in June 2009.
The SNP leader cannot be written off, of course, and nationalism isn’t over just because HBOS has died the death. But most nationalists agree that there was a marked change in the air after the Glenrothes by-election. Tens of thousands of jobs are likely to go in the near future, and just as the banking unions have looked south for guarantees on job losses, so many Scots will - rightly or wrongly - look to London for their security, at least in the short term. at the very least it will take time for the nationalists to re-boot their politics to take account of the new situation.
The only person whose nose might be out of joint is Peter Mandelson the Business Secretary Last week the Business Secretary expressed a wish to emulate John Sergeant’s success on Strictly Come Dancing. He will face the humiliation of sitting around the same cabinet table as Vince Cable who was a great success on the reality dance contest two years ago. It could be murder on the dance-floor. But it’s a price worth paying for getting Gordon his second term
Sunday, November 02, 2008
Call Johnathan Ross
Brrng Brrrng Hi this is Johnathan Ross but I’m out so please leave a message...
Hey Woss! Your wife is a fat slag with a mental condition and I’ve had sex with your daughters. Don’t worry, mate. Only a joke. Like your wife Jane - with her big boobs and orange hair. Talk about scary. Do you only let her out at Halloween? Ha ha No wonder she presents that programme on Living TV about the paranormal - she just needs to investigate herself. Just a laugh mate, no hard feelings. And what were you doing calling your daugher “Betty Kitten”. That mean she’s a pussy? Can I come and stroke her? Don’t worry, mate, this is just edgy groundbreaking comedy, like from your own shows.
So, Wossy, you’ve been suspended from the BBC because of that call to Andrew Sachs where you talked about soaking him in gin and then, er, pleasuring him. Bit of ‘Manuel relief’ you might say. Maybe we could come and do that to Jane? Better cut out the gin though given her spell at the Priory rehab clinic. No wonder being married to you - enough to give anyone a breakdown. Oh and Wossy, is she still going out with that bloke from the Barenaked Ladies. Takes one to know one. Ha Ha Ha. Oh, by the way - don’t mind if we broadcast this do you?
Wonder how Johnathan Ross would have reacted if he’d found that - all based on fact by the way - on his answerphone? Would he have laughed it off, or would he have gone all boring and unfunny and complained about invasion of privacy? Is it all that different from phoning up 78 year old Andrew Sachs and saying that you’ve f....d his daughter and want to break into his house? I suppose it’s the way you tell them.
Seriously though, it’s difficult to know what’s funny nowadays. Ross often makes jokes about his wife’s ample physique - he even asked Susannah Constantine on his show if he could feel her breasts to see if they were bigger than Jane’s. Then there's that joke from Mock the Week about the Queen's pussy being so old it was haunted that's caused the latest row. Can pussies be haunted?
As for the Sachs case, there was just a hint of hypocrisy in the nation’s press leaping to defend the honour of Georgina Baillie - a stripper with a troupe called The Satanic Sluts Xtreme who according to her website do: “violent, horrific and sexy burlesque shows”. Clerly a lady of impeccable virtue who needs protected from smackhead scum like Russell Brand.
No you couldn’t make it up. Tell you what the real joke is though : Mark Thompson. How could a glove puppet become Director General of the BBC?
Hey Woss! Your wife is a fat slag with a mental condition and I’ve had sex with your daughters. Don’t worry, mate. Only a joke. Like your wife Jane - with her big boobs and orange hair. Talk about scary. Do you only let her out at Halloween? Ha ha No wonder she presents that programme on Living TV about the paranormal - she just needs to investigate herself. Just a laugh mate, no hard feelings. And what were you doing calling your daugher “Betty Kitten”. That mean she’s a pussy? Can I come and stroke her? Don’t worry, mate, this is just edgy groundbreaking comedy, like from your own shows.
So, Wossy, you’ve been suspended from the BBC because of that call to Andrew Sachs where you talked about soaking him in gin and then, er, pleasuring him. Bit of ‘Manuel relief’ you might say. Maybe we could come and do that to Jane? Better cut out the gin though given her spell at the Priory rehab clinic. No wonder being married to you - enough to give anyone a breakdown. Oh and Wossy, is she still going out with that bloke from the Barenaked Ladies. Takes one to know one. Ha Ha Ha. Oh, by the way - don’t mind if we broadcast this do you?
Wonder how Johnathan Ross would have reacted if he’d found that - all based on fact by the way - on his answerphone? Would he have laughed it off, or would he have gone all boring and unfunny and complained about invasion of privacy? Is it all that different from phoning up 78 year old Andrew Sachs and saying that you’ve f....d his daughter and want to break into his house? I suppose it’s the way you tell them.
Seriously though, it’s difficult to know what’s funny nowadays. Ross often makes jokes about his wife’s ample physique - he even asked Susannah Constantine on his show if he could feel her breasts to see if they were bigger than Jane’s. Then there's that joke from Mock the Week about the Queen's pussy being so old it was haunted that's caused the latest row. Can pussies be haunted?
As for the Sachs case, there was just a hint of hypocrisy in the nation’s press leaping to defend the honour of Georgina Baillie - a stripper with a troupe called The Satanic Sluts Xtreme who according to her website do: “violent, horrific and sexy burlesque shows”. Clerly a lady of impeccable virtue who needs protected from smackhead scum like Russell Brand.
No you couldn’t make it up. Tell you what the real joke is though : Mark Thompson. How could a glove puppet become Director General of the BBC?
Tuesday, October 28, 2008
Europe's sub-prime problem
It was Europe’s dirty little secret. While American banks were lending irresponsibly to homeowners who couldn’t pay, European banks were lending emerging countries who couldn’t pay. Europe’s sub-prime crisis has now come home as heavily-indebted nations of the Eastern bloc - Hungary, Ukraine, Bulgaria, the Baltic states - are collapsing one by one into the arms of the IMF. “Icelandisation” is the new spectre stalking Europe.
And, as with sub-prime in urban America, this latest crisis was shockingly predictable. I visited Latvia at the height of the credit bubble eighteen months ago, and it was clearly an accident waiting to happen. Riga, the capital, ws bristling with upmarket shopping malls and classy bars that were all quite empty. Stalin-era flats were going for $200,000 in a country where the average wage was less than $400 a month. Latvia has hardly any industry, no energy and few natural resources - except trees. But such was the irrational exuberance of foreign banks like Swedbank, it was awash with credit.
According to the Bank for International Settlement, Western European banks have lent over $1.5 trillion to Eastern Europe. Austria has loans equivalent to 80% of GDP and stands to make huge losses as Hungary and Ukraine collapse. This week, the Austrian government had to cancel an auction of government bonds (like our gilts) because it couldn’t be be sure that investors would buy them. It is not inconceivable that Austria itself could end up needing rescued.
Other European countries implicated in global sub-prime include Spain, which has loaned immense sums ($316bn) to Latin American countries like Argentina. Britain hasa $329bn tied up in Asia - or did until values collapsed in the Asian stock market rout. Japan’s Nikkei index fell to a twenty six year low this week wiping out tens of billions. The losses are now winging their way home to British pension funds and banks like RBS and HSBC.
So, banks behaving badly, what’s new? Well, the Bank of England told us this week that global losses from the financial crisis so far amounts to $2.8 trillion, but that only includes a fraction of the likely losses from global sub prime, which have yet to land on balance sheets. Until last week’s rout in the Asian bourses, there were still economists who believed that emerging markets wouldn’t be greatly affected by the credit crunch. Now, the theory that developing countries, led by China and India, have “decoupled” from the West, has been thoroughly discredited. It’s clear that they have been dependent on consumer spending in America and Europe all along - and now that these Western consumers are shopped out, no one is buying their cheap goods. The Baltic Dry Shipping Index, which tracks the cost of hiring ships for international trade, has collapsed by 79% this year signalling a severe global recession.
So, when Gordon Brown hints that Britain might spend his way out of this recession he needs to consider how his remarks might be viewed abroad. There’s no guarantee, in this climate, that the British government will be able to borrow the money to pay for further bank rescues (they’re coming), plus the cost of three million unemployed, plus a programme of Keynsian infrastructure spending, however desirable that may be. Investors are already shunning the pound because of anticipated losses from the UK property crash. Sterling has fallen 28% this year, further than in the ERM crisis of 1992 when interest rates rose to 15%. We could be heading for a classic 1960s run on the pound.
The government hoped that a devalued pound would stimulate exports and pull Britain out of recession, as happened after the Black Wednesday sixteen years ago - but times change. We don’t actually make things anymore and the world isn’t buying anyway, and it has also had quite enough of our ‘innovative’ financial services. This means that Britain’s current account deficit of 6% - what used to be called loosely the balance of payments - suddenly becomes a major economic issue again Borrowing may be a good thing in a recession, but international financiers, sovereign wealth funds, hedge funds and banks may not agree.
The UK of course has the honour of having been the last G7 country to call in the IMF - during the 1976 sterling crisis - and while the government isn’t dusting down the application forms quite yet, Britain’s finances would not impress the fund’s economists. The standard IMF lending conditions are: privatisation, cuts in government spending and increased interest rates. You may notice that we are going in exactly the opposite direction, slashing interest rates, borrowing to spend, and nationalising the banks.
Of course, seen another way, this is only an indication of the extent to which the IMF is no longer fit for purpose in the Great Deleveraging. In recent years, the IMF has been an engine of Wall Street neoliberalism, of financial deregulation, which makes it ill equipped to deal with the new international environment of deflation and banking crashes. There is anyway a fiscal crisis facing the IMF. It only has about $250bn in reserves to throw at a rolling financial crisis that has now engulfed half the planet, from Iceland to Pakistan. Gordon Brown has called on energy exporting nations to stump up more cash for the fund, but there is a strong case for reviewing how the IMF operates also.
Set up as part of the Bretton Woods financial system in 1944, the IMF was designed to cope with episodic currency crises. It is now having to deal with potential insolvencies in countries the size of Argentina as well as bailing out entire regions like Eastern Europe. It will have to be very much better capitalised if it is going to perform this role, and it will have to abandon much of its free market ideology. We need a new set of interventionist institutions capable of managing financial rescues on an international scale.
Ultimately, what is needed is an international central bank with resources to provide liquidity guarantees, recapitalise banks and regulate international financial flows. This is an immense task, and the world may not appear to be ready for it. But it is not a new idea: John Maynard Keynes argued for precisely this during the Bretton Woods negotiations in 1944. He even suggested a world reserve currency “bancor”. This is the kind of thinking we need today.
The alternative, if nothing is done, is international tension and war - all history tells us this. Consider countries today like crippled Ukraine with its large Russian population and its dependency on Russia for energy supplies, right at the moment when Russian dreams of becoming an energy superpower have been dashed by the collapse of the oil price bubble. Look at nuclear Pakistan, where the entire country is disintegrating in financial chaos. And will all those unemployed workers in China - where half the toy manufacturers have gone bust - go peacefully back to the paddy fields?
When leaders of the “G20” group of leading and emergnt nations meet in Washington next month for what is being called “Bretton Woods 11” they’d better believe that they are not just dealing with a banking crisis. They could be deciding the future of civilisation itself.
And, as with sub-prime in urban America, this latest crisis was shockingly predictable. I visited Latvia at the height of the credit bubble eighteen months ago, and it was clearly an accident waiting to happen. Riga, the capital, ws bristling with upmarket shopping malls and classy bars that were all quite empty. Stalin-era flats were going for $200,000 in a country where the average wage was less than $400 a month. Latvia has hardly any industry, no energy and few natural resources - except trees. But such was the irrational exuberance of foreign banks like Swedbank, it was awash with credit.
According to the Bank for International Settlement, Western European banks have lent over $1.5 trillion to Eastern Europe. Austria has loans equivalent to 80% of GDP and stands to make huge losses as Hungary and Ukraine collapse. This week, the Austrian government had to cancel an auction of government bonds (like our gilts) because it couldn’t be be sure that investors would buy them. It is not inconceivable that Austria itself could end up needing rescued.
Other European countries implicated in global sub-prime include Spain, which has loaned immense sums ($316bn) to Latin American countries like Argentina. Britain hasa $329bn tied up in Asia - or did until values collapsed in the Asian stock market rout. Japan’s Nikkei index fell to a twenty six year low this week wiping out tens of billions. The losses are now winging their way home to British pension funds and banks like RBS and HSBC.
So, banks behaving badly, what’s new? Well, the Bank of England told us this week that global losses from the financial crisis so far amounts to $2.8 trillion, but that only includes a fraction of the likely losses from global sub prime, which have yet to land on balance sheets. Until last week’s rout in the Asian bourses, there were still economists who believed that emerging markets wouldn’t be greatly affected by the credit crunch. Now, the theory that developing countries, led by China and India, have “decoupled” from the West, has been thoroughly discredited. It’s clear that they have been dependent on consumer spending in America and Europe all along - and now that these Western consumers are shopped out, no one is buying their cheap goods. The Baltic Dry Shipping Index, which tracks the cost of hiring ships for international trade, has collapsed by 79% this year signalling a severe global recession.
So, when Gordon Brown hints that Britain might spend his way out of this recession he needs to consider how his remarks might be viewed abroad. There’s no guarantee, in this climate, that the British government will be able to borrow the money to pay for further bank rescues (they’re coming), plus the cost of three million unemployed, plus a programme of Keynsian infrastructure spending, however desirable that may be. Investors are already shunning the pound because of anticipated losses from the UK property crash. Sterling has fallen 28% this year, further than in the ERM crisis of 1992 when interest rates rose to 15%. We could be heading for a classic 1960s run on the pound.
The government hoped that a devalued pound would stimulate exports and pull Britain out of recession, as happened after the Black Wednesday sixteen years ago - but times change. We don’t actually make things anymore and the world isn’t buying anyway, and it has also had quite enough of our ‘innovative’ financial services. This means that Britain’s current account deficit of 6% - what used to be called loosely the balance of payments - suddenly becomes a major economic issue again Borrowing may be a good thing in a recession, but international financiers, sovereign wealth funds, hedge funds and banks may not agree.
The UK of course has the honour of having been the last G7 country to call in the IMF - during the 1976 sterling crisis - and while the government isn’t dusting down the application forms quite yet, Britain’s finances would not impress the fund’s economists. The standard IMF lending conditions are: privatisation, cuts in government spending and increased interest rates. You may notice that we are going in exactly the opposite direction, slashing interest rates, borrowing to spend, and nationalising the banks.
Of course, seen another way, this is only an indication of the extent to which the IMF is no longer fit for purpose in the Great Deleveraging. In recent years, the IMF has been an engine of Wall Street neoliberalism, of financial deregulation, which makes it ill equipped to deal with the new international environment of deflation and banking crashes. There is anyway a fiscal crisis facing the IMF. It only has about $250bn in reserves to throw at a rolling financial crisis that has now engulfed half the planet, from Iceland to Pakistan. Gordon Brown has called on energy exporting nations to stump up more cash for the fund, but there is a strong case for reviewing how the IMF operates also.
Set up as part of the Bretton Woods financial system in 1944, the IMF was designed to cope with episodic currency crises. It is now having to deal with potential insolvencies in countries the size of Argentina as well as bailing out entire regions like Eastern Europe. It will have to be very much better capitalised if it is going to perform this role, and it will have to abandon much of its free market ideology. We need a new set of interventionist institutions capable of managing financial rescues on an international scale.
Ultimately, what is needed is an international central bank with resources to provide liquidity guarantees, recapitalise banks and regulate international financial flows. This is an immense task, and the world may not appear to be ready for it. But it is not a new idea: John Maynard Keynes argued for precisely this during the Bretton Woods negotiations in 1944. He even suggested a world reserve currency “bancor”. This is the kind of thinking we need today.
The alternative, if nothing is done, is international tension and war - all history tells us this. Consider countries today like crippled Ukraine with its large Russian population and its dependency on Russia for energy supplies, right at the moment when Russian dreams of becoming an energy superpower have been dashed by the collapse of the oil price bubble. Look at nuclear Pakistan, where the entire country is disintegrating in financial chaos. And will all those unemployed workers in China - where half the toy manufacturers have gone bust - go peacefully back to the paddy fields?
When leaders of the “G20” group of leading and emergnt nations meet in Washington next month for what is being called “Bretton Woods 11” they’d better believe that they are not just dealing with a banking crisis. They could be deciding the future of civilisation itself.
Wednesday, October 15, 2008
Bankers should resign now
Well, the first thing that has to happen is that those in positions of responsibility take responsibility and resign. Today will see the biggest banking rescue in history as the government effectively nationalises HBOS and Royal Bank of Scotland by taking majority shareholdings in both banks. If confidence is to be restored, then it is surely essential that those who were in charge to step aside. Otherwise, how can investors - now effectively us - be sure that they will be run any differently in future?
There are now indications that Sir Fred “the shred” Goodwin of RBS may be prepared to be dragged from his post if the shareholders demand it. But in what other walk of life would leaders who have presided over such a comprehensive disaster have remained in their jobs for so long? He should have gone six months ago after he promised that the Royal Bank didn’t need to raise money and then launched the biggest rights issue in corporate history. Sir Fred and his doppleganger, Andy Hornby of HBOS have made immense personal fortunes - Goodwin paid himself four million last year alone - from wrecking these two great Scottish institutions. If you accept huge rewards you must accept that when you mess up hugely you accept the consequences.
Their behaviour tells you all you need to know about the culture of modern banking. Andy Hornby is a supermarket salesman out of his depth who moved into dodgy mortgage lending in the belief that house prices would rise forever. Sir Fred went on a buying spree he couldn’t afford at the height of the credit bubble and bulldozed through the sale of the banking group ABN Amro on sheer ego alone , even as the credit crunch deepened. He also led RBS into buying sub-prime mortgages in America and bet heavily on the derivatives market. Yet like the rest of the banking fraternity they continue to behave like masters of the universe even though there universe has imploded and their companies are on life support from the state.
A little contrition would not go amiss - like those Japanese bankers last week who bowed humbly before the people on TV. Not a single British banker has uttered any kind of apology for what has happened over the last year. Yet these are the same people who lectured governments about irresponsible public spending, who attacked trades unionists for trying to save their jobs, who called for manufacturing industries to be closed if they required public subsidies. Now they are demanding the biggest public subsidies in history.
In America they take a more robust approach. When the mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddy Mac were nationalised, the top managers walked the plank immediately. Same with the investment banksters who ran Bear Stearns when it collapsed and had to be rescued. Dick “the ape” Fuld of bankrupt Lehman Brothers has been hauled before congressional inquiries to explain how he justified his hundreds of millions in remuneration. No, it hasn’t stopped the stock market from collapsing, but it has at least given some hope to taxpayers that those who have destroyed the financial system may some day be held accountable for their greed and irresponsibility.
Personally, I would call in the Serious Fraud Office, just as the FBI has been called in to investigate Wall St..banking scams. The practices that have been routine in the City of London - like setting up special purpose vehicles to allow risky trades and dodgy assets to be kept of bank balance sheets - must surely have been unlawful. Enron executives are in jail today for doing much the same . These special purpose vehicles - many set up, unbelievably, as charitable trusts - were purpose designed to get avoid tax and evade regulations on banking capitalisation. The collapse of this shadow banking system is one important reason why the banks are now coming cap in hand to the state to save them from insolvency.
Confidence needs to be restored as a matter of urgency. If the stock markets fall again by 20% this week - as the IMF believes is likely - then the entire banking system in Britain will effectively have to be nationalised. The complete failure of banks to lend to each other - or anyone else for that matter - is now becoming a threat to the entire economy. This cannot be allowed to continue. The credit famine will result in a wave of corporate collapses across the world, starting with companies like Ford and General Motors in America which are already effectively bankrupt. There will be thousands of business failures in the UK and millions will lose their jobs.
Iceland, which was big on ‘financial engineering” is bankrupt, and it is not impossible that a large country could default, especially if it happens to be a world centre of the dodgy credit industry. Our banks are insolvent yet with liabilities running into trillions. The government last week threw £500bn at the City in the hope that it would sort the problem, but the verdict of the markets was clear on Friday when panic consumed investors. People keep asking why, if the “plumbing” of the financial system are clogged, can’t someone just unblock it But simplistic metaphors don’t really help in this situation because it fails to understand the psychology of the actors. Plumbing doesn’t panic, it doesn’t indulge in derivative trading, and it doesn’t try to hide from its own responsibilities.
The banks are not lending to each other because they are stuffed with assets which are not worth the paper they are printed on. They don’t want to expose their shaky assets to any market because they will then have to confront the scale of their losses on the property markets and on obscure derivative trades. The countless billions in cash the government - the bank of you and me - is giving to the banks in the form of treasury bond swaps is not working because the banks are hoarding this cash to rebuild their balance sheets. The only way out of this is for all the banks to ‘fess up and for all the dodgy mortgage backed securities to be thrown into a market to find out what they are really worth. The assets are worth something - after all, most are based on mortgages which will be repaid. It is only the fear and, yes, the greed of the banks that is preventing this triage taking place.
This is why it is so imperative that a new generation of banking executives are installed who are not tainted by the debt and bonus culture of the bubble years. We need people who have a degree of social responsibility and a willingness to accept political direction, not plutocratic monsters drunk on their own vanity. There is a very real possibility now that the entire banking systems of the developed world - the G7 - may now have to be nationalised. This is the end of an era - but the last people to realise it are the people who have brought the age of risk capitalism to its end. History will not look kindly on them - so why should we?
There are now indications that Sir Fred “the shred” Goodwin of RBS may be prepared to be dragged from his post if the shareholders demand it. But in what other walk of life would leaders who have presided over such a comprehensive disaster have remained in their jobs for so long? He should have gone six months ago after he promised that the Royal Bank didn’t need to raise money and then launched the biggest rights issue in corporate history. Sir Fred and his doppleganger, Andy Hornby of HBOS have made immense personal fortunes - Goodwin paid himself four million last year alone - from wrecking these two great Scottish institutions. If you accept huge rewards you must accept that when you mess up hugely you accept the consequences.
Their behaviour tells you all you need to know about the culture of modern banking. Andy Hornby is a supermarket salesman out of his depth who moved into dodgy mortgage lending in the belief that house prices would rise forever. Sir Fred went on a buying spree he couldn’t afford at the height of the credit bubble and bulldozed through the sale of the banking group ABN Amro on sheer ego alone , even as the credit crunch deepened. He also led RBS into buying sub-prime mortgages in America and bet heavily on the derivatives market. Yet like the rest of the banking fraternity they continue to behave like masters of the universe even though there universe has imploded and their companies are on life support from the state.
A little contrition would not go amiss - like those Japanese bankers last week who bowed humbly before the people on TV. Not a single British banker has uttered any kind of apology for what has happened over the last year. Yet these are the same people who lectured governments about irresponsible public spending, who attacked trades unionists for trying to save their jobs, who called for manufacturing industries to be closed if they required public subsidies. Now they are demanding the biggest public subsidies in history.
In America they take a more robust approach. When the mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddy Mac were nationalised, the top managers walked the plank immediately. Same with the investment banksters who ran Bear Stearns when it collapsed and had to be rescued. Dick “the ape” Fuld of bankrupt Lehman Brothers has been hauled before congressional inquiries to explain how he justified his hundreds of millions in remuneration. No, it hasn’t stopped the stock market from collapsing, but it has at least given some hope to taxpayers that those who have destroyed the financial system may some day be held accountable for their greed and irresponsibility.
Personally, I would call in the Serious Fraud Office, just as the FBI has been called in to investigate Wall St..banking scams. The practices that have been routine in the City of London - like setting up special purpose vehicles to allow risky trades and dodgy assets to be kept of bank balance sheets - must surely have been unlawful. Enron executives are in jail today for doing much the same . These special purpose vehicles - many set up, unbelievably, as charitable trusts - were purpose designed to get avoid tax and evade regulations on banking capitalisation. The collapse of this shadow banking system is one important reason why the banks are now coming cap in hand to the state to save them from insolvency.
Confidence needs to be restored as a matter of urgency. If the stock markets fall again by 20% this week - as the IMF believes is likely - then the entire banking system in Britain will effectively have to be nationalised. The complete failure of banks to lend to each other - or anyone else for that matter - is now becoming a threat to the entire economy. This cannot be allowed to continue. The credit famine will result in a wave of corporate collapses across the world, starting with companies like Ford and General Motors in America which are already effectively bankrupt. There will be thousands of business failures in the UK and millions will lose their jobs.
Iceland, which was big on ‘financial engineering” is bankrupt, and it is not impossible that a large country could default, especially if it happens to be a world centre of the dodgy credit industry. Our banks are insolvent yet with liabilities running into trillions. The government last week threw £500bn at the City in the hope that it would sort the problem, but the verdict of the markets was clear on Friday when panic consumed investors. People keep asking why, if the “plumbing” of the financial system are clogged, can’t someone just unblock it But simplistic metaphors don’t really help in this situation because it fails to understand the psychology of the actors. Plumbing doesn’t panic, it doesn’t indulge in derivative trading, and it doesn’t try to hide from its own responsibilities.
The banks are not lending to each other because they are stuffed with assets which are not worth the paper they are printed on. They don’t want to expose their shaky assets to any market because they will then have to confront the scale of their losses on the property markets and on obscure derivative trades. The countless billions in cash the government - the bank of you and me - is giving to the banks in the form of treasury bond swaps is not working because the banks are hoarding this cash to rebuild their balance sheets. The only way out of this is for all the banks to ‘fess up and for all the dodgy mortgage backed securities to be thrown into a market to find out what they are really worth. The assets are worth something - after all, most are based on mortgages which will be repaid. It is only the fear and, yes, the greed of the banks that is preventing this triage taking place.
This is why it is so imperative that a new generation of banking executives are installed who are not tainted by the debt and bonus culture of the bubble years. We need people who have a degree of social responsibility and a willingness to accept political direction, not plutocratic monsters drunk on their own vanity. There is a very real possibility now that the entire banking systems of the developed world - the G7 - may now have to be nationalised. This is the end of an era - but the last people to realise it are the people who have brought the age of risk capitalism to its end. History will not look kindly on them - so why should we?
Sunday, October 12, 2008
What banks do. And how we got in this mess
Last week, something happened which I never expected to see in my lifetime. There was a general run on the entire British banking system, something that hasn’t happened before, even in wartime. Ordinary people started moving their money around from bank to bank in fear that they might lose their cash. Millions of pound were flowing across the Irish sea for the safe haven of the Irish government’s 100% depositor guarantee. The banks were on the verge of losing public trust, and public trust is the one thing banks need to survive.
We are witnessing what the commentator Martin Wolf of the Financial Times, calls “the disintegration of the financial system”. But how did we get here? How did a few dodgy sub-prime mortgages in American inner cities lead to what is beginning to look like the collapse of capitalism? This is the great unanswered question in the midst of this extraordinary crisis, as banks explode one after the other across the world. We hear endless talk about “deleveraging” “derivatives” “collateralised debt obligation” “credit default swaps” most of which is completely incomprehensible - and very often designed to be. A lot of what has been going on is essentially fraudulent. But underlying it all the jargon is a fundamental truth about banking; that it is based on a kind of confidence trick
It's called "fractional reserve banking". Alone of commercial institutions, banks are allowed to create value out of nothing - they are allowed to lend out money they don’t have. To explain: at any one time a bank may have, say, a billion in assets, but it will have lent out at least ten billion. That ten billion will yield interest - interest on money the bank doesn’t actually own, that is not based on deposits in its accounts. Magic. Money for nothing. But this magic only works if the debtors the bank has lent to don’t default on their loans and that the savers who have placed deposits in a bank do not all try to take them out all at once. If they did, then the bank would rapidly become insolvent, because of the nine billion it has lent out that it never had in the first place. That’s what started to happen last week. The confidence trick began to fail.
Banking practice dates from medieval times when kings and aristocrats deposited their gold with goldsmiths for safe keeping. The goldsmiths noted that they owners didn’t all ask for all the precious metals back at the same time, so they started to lend it out. This is why, until very recently, bank notes “promised to pay the bearer” a sum of sterling silver. It was all based on precious metals. Not any more. Currency ceased to be linked to precious metals in 1971 when America abandoned the gold standard and ordained that, instead, the world should regard dollars as “good as gold” and use it as the universal medium of exchange. This is called “fiat” money, and some economists believe that it is the root of all evil because, with no intrinsic value, governments cannot resist printing more and more of it thus devaluing their currency.
Now, the prevailing view nowadays among economists is that central banks can maintain the value of their currencies by manipulating interest rates up or down to control inflation. But this depends on the willingness of the central banks to do so. It also depends on the wisdom and prudence of the banks who manufacture this magic stuff called credit. For the past twenty years, central banks have seen economic growth as more important than combating inflation, and banks have thrown prudence to the winds.
After the 1987 crash, central banks cut interest rates, and economic life resumed. Again in the late 1990s, after the Asian financial crisis and the near collapse of the hedge fund Long Term Capital Management, banks cut interest rates again. After the dot com crash in 2001, the US Federal Reserve followed by the Bank of England cut rates dramatically yet again, and kept them low for the next three years, stimulating house price bubbles in both countries. The central bankers made saving money a loser’s game. Interest rates were held below the rate of inflation, so anyone who saved actually lost money. The bankers knew perfectly what they were doing - the former Bank of England governor, Eddie George, told a Commons Select Committee two years ago that the housing boom was “unsustainable” but that he and Gordon Brown deliberately inflated it prevent a recession. Unfortunately, it got a bit out of hand.
The other problem with central banks always cutting interest rates was that this encourages the banks to stop behaving themselves. Huge institutions like Lehman Brothers and HBOS started to think they were invincible, masters of the universe, ‘too big to fail’. Banks like Halifax Bank of Scotland piled into property, believing that house prices would never fall, and if they did, the Bank of England would slash interest rates and house prices would rise again. Banks like Northern Rock stopped bothering about the boring business of attracting deposits from savers and started borrowing money on the international money markets to fund ever more ludicrous mortgage lending - such as their 125% “suicide” loans. Northern Rock was still selling these “Together” loans six months after it was nationalised.
This confidence that central banks would ride to the rescue led banks to take bigger and bigger risks. Instead of lending ten times the value of its underlying assets, investment banks like Lehmans started lending out thirty times asset value. This is called leverage, and allowed the hedge funds and private equity groups financed by Lehmans to go on buying sprees across corporate world. They were getting colossal quantities of almost free money. “Leveraged buy outs (LBOs)” became the name of the corporate game. Groups of investors would get together, target a company like AA, borrow to buy it, load it up with more debt, sell it, and move on. Hedge funds flipped multi-billion companies the way amateur property speculators in California flipped houses.
But it was all based on credit, and the dark side of credit is debt. All of this works only so long as the underlying assets retain their value. Using leverage seemed like free money. But when assets decline in value, the ugly side of debt appears in the form of “deleveraging”. If a bank has loaned out thirty times its assets, it has loaned out three trillion on the basis of only a hundred billion in reserves. If those assets lose half their value, the bank finds itself in the hole to the tune of one and a half trillion. Greatly oversimplified, this is what has happened in the last year. A class of complex paper assets called “securities”, based on the value of residential mortgages, started to lose value as US house prices started to slide. The banks suddenly stopped trading these mortgage backed securities because they were afraid of the potential losses that might show up if they did. These assets included the infamous sub-prime loans - fraudulently lent to Americans who couldn’t possibly pay - which were packaged up into “collateralised debt obligations” and sold on to other banks and governments who didn’t really know what they were buying.
That’s about where we stood at the time of the collapse of Northern Rock in August 2007. A general panic among banks froze interbank lending. Governments then stepped in, first to nationalise Northern Rock, then to pump billions of so called “liquidity” loans into the system. In essence, the Bank of England agreed to exchange valuable treasury bonds for dodgy mortgage assets. The banks could use these treasury bonds as a kind of currency, because everyone accepted their value was underwritten by the government - ie you and me.
But then something else happened. Huge Wall St investment banks like Bear Sterns started to discover their assets were declining even more rapidly than expected, and investors started withdrawing their funds from them, causing a kind of bank run. To prevent widespread defaults, the US government stepped in an forced a another bank JP Morgan to buy Bear at a fraction of its value. But this didn’t stop the contagion.
Within the space of six months all the big investment banks on Wall St had collapsed or been merged with other institutions in one of the greatest banking crashes of all time. Then the big mortgage banks started to go under, like IndyMac, Washington Mutual, Wachovia, HBOS, Bradford and Bingley. The two huge state supported US mortgage banks, responsible for $5 trillion in mortgages, Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae had to be nationalised, along with the world’s largest insurance company AIG. Banks which had handled hundreds of trillions of investments were finding that they were becoming insolvent almost overnight. Because fo the global reach of these companies, this became a crash even more severe than the series of banking failures that led to the Great Depression in the 1930s.
We are now reaching what might be called the terminal stage in this crisis. The contagion has spread through the entire banking structure of the West. It has moved from a crisis of liquidity, to a crisis of insolvency and finally to a crisis of confidence in the entire banking system. Suddenly, everyone wants their money out because no one trusts their banks. That essential trust that allowed the goldsmiths to lend on the basis of their borrowed gold, has begun to evaporate. To prevent Ireland’s banks going bust, the Taoiseach last week decided to guarantee all of the deposts in Irish banks, even though it would be impossible for the Irish government to pay up if everyone withdrew. Money is now flooding out of British banks to the Irish “safe haven” which is why Britain and the EU are furious at this unilateral action by the Irish. Meanwhile, European banks are now starting to explode, one by one.
So, what made the collapse quite so catastrophic that even hundreds of billions of liquidity loans were not enough to staunch the flow? Well, the answer appears to lie in what is called the “shadow banking system”. This refers to the unregulated dealing by banks in what are called “derivatives” - these are financial instruments which don’t have a value in themselves, but relate to a future value. Originally, derivatives were things like pork belly futures - essentially bets on the value of that year’s cull of hogs. But a hugely complex market evolved in the trading of derivatives called credit default swaps, which are like insurance policies taken out on corporate debt. In the space of five years the value of credit default swap contracts rose to $62 trillion, larger than the value of all the world’s stock markets. The bank of international settlement in Basel calculated that the total value of all derivatives in the world last year amounted to some $500 trillion dollars.
The market in these ‘over the counter’ derivatives is completely unregulated, and traders are allowed to make bets and enter into contracts without necessarily having assets to back them up. The derivatives banks thought they had removed the risk by using complex mathematical formulae which seemed to indicate that they could so finely calculate the likelihood of making a loss that they could insure against it. These derivatives and the mathematics underlying them were immensely complicated and very few people understand them. Indeed, it has emerged that the people who devised them didn’t understand them either because the whole derivatives pyramid is now collapsing.
But through all the confusion the simple essential fact is that banks have hugely over-lent, their assets are declining, debtors are defaulting and their losses, multiplied by complex derivatives and deleveraging, the losses have become almost incalculable. The banks have had to cut back their lending drastically to build up their capital reserves, and they are now appealing to governments for direct injections of capital. This is what the $700bn Troubled Asset Relief Programme was all about - using taxpayers money to try to shore up banking capital by buying their worthless assets. But the trouble with this scheme. devised by the former Goldman Sachs boss, Henry Paulson who is now US Treasury Secretary, is that no one really knows how big the losses of the banks are, because of this huge amorphous cloud of impenetrable derivatives contracts.
But the story isn’t over there. Not only did the banks lend too much, and binge on dodgy derivatives, they based most of their devilish formulae on a presumption that house prices always go up. Now, statistically speaking, this is arguably the case - over time, house prices have always risen in the long run. However, in the short run, the graph can be a very lumpy one, with rises and big falls. For some reason, the banks forgot this, and thought that the bubble in house prices that was ignited by the 2001 interest rate cuts, would continue forever.
This was utter madness. House prices are now falling to trend - which means to their historic values. This means a reduction of something like 30-50%, because the graph of prices always overshoots on the upside and downside. Look at any historical table of house prices and this is blindingly obvious - but for some reason the banks believed that the laws of economics had been suspended by their brilliant mathematics.
So now what happens? Well, as house prices continue to fall, as fall they must, the value of the assets in companies like HBOS will continue to be marked down. This is why LLoyds TSB shareholders are very reluctant to take on HBOS at any price, because it is stuffed with dodgy mortgages which are falling in value. The banks all hoped that by now the central banks would have cut interest rates and people would all have started buying houses again - and that is what the US and British governments are still hoping will happen. But it won’t and it can’t. House prices are simply too high and have to fall, even with cuts in interest rates. The banks know this, which is why they are refusing to lend unless people can put up large deposits.
This creates a vicious circle which can only be resolved by the assets being revalued. House prices must come down; the banks’ assets must be repriced; insolvent banks must be closed; interest rates must be recalibrated to encourage saving; consumers will have to stop borrowing to spend and everyone will have to start paying their debts. It’s a tall order, and governments across the world are in denial. But the only way out of this mess is some very hard medicine. The longer governments and banks put off swallowing it, the longer the slump will last.
We are witnessing what the commentator Martin Wolf of the Financial Times, calls “the disintegration of the financial system”. But how did we get here? How did a few dodgy sub-prime mortgages in American inner cities lead to what is beginning to look like the collapse of capitalism? This is the great unanswered question in the midst of this extraordinary crisis, as banks explode one after the other across the world. We hear endless talk about “deleveraging” “derivatives” “collateralised debt obligation” “credit default swaps” most of which is completely incomprehensible - and very often designed to be. A lot of what has been going on is essentially fraudulent. But underlying it all the jargon is a fundamental truth about banking; that it is based on a kind of confidence trick
It's called "fractional reserve banking". Alone of commercial institutions, banks are allowed to create value out of nothing - they are allowed to lend out money they don’t have. To explain: at any one time a bank may have, say, a billion in assets, but it will have lent out at least ten billion. That ten billion will yield interest - interest on money the bank doesn’t actually own, that is not based on deposits in its accounts. Magic. Money for nothing. But this magic only works if the debtors the bank has lent to don’t default on their loans and that the savers who have placed deposits in a bank do not all try to take them out all at once. If they did, then the bank would rapidly become insolvent, because of the nine billion it has lent out that it never had in the first place. That’s what started to happen last week. The confidence trick began to fail.
Banking practice dates from medieval times when kings and aristocrats deposited their gold with goldsmiths for safe keeping. The goldsmiths noted that they owners didn’t all ask for all the precious metals back at the same time, so they started to lend it out. This is why, until very recently, bank notes “promised to pay the bearer” a sum of sterling silver. It was all based on precious metals. Not any more. Currency ceased to be linked to precious metals in 1971 when America abandoned the gold standard and ordained that, instead, the world should regard dollars as “good as gold” and use it as the universal medium of exchange. This is called “fiat” money, and some economists believe that it is the root of all evil because, with no intrinsic value, governments cannot resist printing more and more of it thus devaluing their currency.
Now, the prevailing view nowadays among economists is that central banks can maintain the value of their currencies by manipulating interest rates up or down to control inflation. But this depends on the willingness of the central banks to do so. It also depends on the wisdom and prudence of the banks who manufacture this magic stuff called credit. For the past twenty years, central banks have seen economic growth as more important than combating inflation, and banks have thrown prudence to the winds.
After the 1987 crash, central banks cut interest rates, and economic life resumed. Again in the late 1990s, after the Asian financial crisis and the near collapse of the hedge fund Long Term Capital Management, banks cut interest rates again. After the dot com crash in 2001, the US Federal Reserve followed by the Bank of England cut rates dramatically yet again, and kept them low for the next three years, stimulating house price bubbles in both countries. The central bankers made saving money a loser’s game. Interest rates were held below the rate of inflation, so anyone who saved actually lost money. The bankers knew perfectly what they were doing - the former Bank of England governor, Eddie George, told a Commons Select Committee two years ago that the housing boom was “unsustainable” but that he and Gordon Brown deliberately inflated it prevent a recession. Unfortunately, it got a bit out of hand.
The other problem with central banks always cutting interest rates was that this encourages the banks to stop behaving themselves. Huge institutions like Lehman Brothers and HBOS started to think they were invincible, masters of the universe, ‘too big to fail’. Banks like Halifax Bank of Scotland piled into property, believing that house prices would never fall, and if they did, the Bank of England would slash interest rates and house prices would rise again. Banks like Northern Rock stopped bothering about the boring business of attracting deposits from savers and started borrowing money on the international money markets to fund ever more ludicrous mortgage lending - such as their 125% “suicide” loans. Northern Rock was still selling these “Together” loans six months after it was nationalised.
This confidence that central banks would ride to the rescue led banks to take bigger and bigger risks. Instead of lending ten times the value of its underlying assets, investment banks like Lehmans started lending out thirty times asset value. This is called leverage, and allowed the hedge funds and private equity groups financed by Lehmans to go on buying sprees across corporate world. They were getting colossal quantities of almost free money. “Leveraged buy outs (LBOs)” became the name of the corporate game. Groups of investors would get together, target a company like AA, borrow to buy it, load it up with more debt, sell it, and move on. Hedge funds flipped multi-billion companies the way amateur property speculators in California flipped houses.
But it was all based on credit, and the dark side of credit is debt. All of this works only so long as the underlying assets retain their value. Using leverage seemed like free money. But when assets decline in value, the ugly side of debt appears in the form of “deleveraging”. If a bank has loaned out thirty times its assets, it has loaned out three trillion on the basis of only a hundred billion in reserves. If those assets lose half their value, the bank finds itself in the hole to the tune of one and a half trillion. Greatly oversimplified, this is what has happened in the last year. A class of complex paper assets called “securities”, based on the value of residential mortgages, started to lose value as US house prices started to slide. The banks suddenly stopped trading these mortgage backed securities because they were afraid of the potential losses that might show up if they did. These assets included the infamous sub-prime loans - fraudulently lent to Americans who couldn’t possibly pay - which were packaged up into “collateralised debt obligations” and sold on to other banks and governments who didn’t really know what they were buying.
That’s about where we stood at the time of the collapse of Northern Rock in August 2007. A general panic among banks froze interbank lending. Governments then stepped in, first to nationalise Northern Rock, then to pump billions of so called “liquidity” loans into the system. In essence, the Bank of England agreed to exchange valuable treasury bonds for dodgy mortgage assets. The banks could use these treasury bonds as a kind of currency, because everyone accepted their value was underwritten by the government - ie you and me.
But then something else happened. Huge Wall St investment banks like Bear Sterns started to discover their assets were declining even more rapidly than expected, and investors started withdrawing their funds from them, causing a kind of bank run. To prevent widespread defaults, the US government stepped in an forced a another bank JP Morgan to buy Bear at a fraction of its value. But this didn’t stop the contagion.
Within the space of six months all the big investment banks on Wall St had collapsed or been merged with other institutions in one of the greatest banking crashes of all time. Then the big mortgage banks started to go under, like IndyMac, Washington Mutual, Wachovia, HBOS, Bradford and Bingley. The two huge state supported US mortgage banks, responsible for $5 trillion in mortgages, Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae had to be nationalised, along with the world’s largest insurance company AIG. Banks which had handled hundreds of trillions of investments were finding that they were becoming insolvent almost overnight. Because fo the global reach of these companies, this became a crash even more severe than the series of banking failures that led to the Great Depression in the 1930s.
We are now reaching what might be called the terminal stage in this crisis. The contagion has spread through the entire banking structure of the West. It has moved from a crisis of liquidity, to a crisis of insolvency and finally to a crisis of confidence in the entire banking system. Suddenly, everyone wants their money out because no one trusts their banks. That essential trust that allowed the goldsmiths to lend on the basis of their borrowed gold, has begun to evaporate. To prevent Ireland’s banks going bust, the Taoiseach last week decided to guarantee all of the deposts in Irish banks, even though it would be impossible for the Irish government to pay up if everyone withdrew. Money is now flooding out of British banks to the Irish “safe haven” which is why Britain and the EU are furious at this unilateral action by the Irish. Meanwhile, European banks are now starting to explode, one by one.
So, what made the collapse quite so catastrophic that even hundreds of billions of liquidity loans were not enough to staunch the flow? Well, the answer appears to lie in what is called the “shadow banking system”. This refers to the unregulated dealing by banks in what are called “derivatives” - these are financial instruments which don’t have a value in themselves, but relate to a future value. Originally, derivatives were things like pork belly futures - essentially bets on the value of that year’s cull of hogs. But a hugely complex market evolved in the trading of derivatives called credit default swaps, which are like insurance policies taken out on corporate debt. In the space of five years the value of credit default swap contracts rose to $62 trillion, larger than the value of all the world’s stock markets. The bank of international settlement in Basel calculated that the total value of all derivatives in the world last year amounted to some $500 trillion dollars.
The market in these ‘over the counter’ derivatives is completely unregulated, and traders are allowed to make bets and enter into contracts without necessarily having assets to back them up. The derivatives banks thought they had removed the risk by using complex mathematical formulae which seemed to indicate that they could so finely calculate the likelihood of making a loss that they could insure against it. These derivatives and the mathematics underlying them were immensely complicated and very few people understand them. Indeed, it has emerged that the people who devised them didn’t understand them either because the whole derivatives pyramid is now collapsing.
But through all the confusion the simple essential fact is that banks have hugely over-lent, their assets are declining, debtors are defaulting and their losses, multiplied by complex derivatives and deleveraging, the losses have become almost incalculable. The banks have had to cut back their lending drastically to build up their capital reserves, and they are now appealing to governments for direct injections of capital. This is what the $700bn Troubled Asset Relief Programme was all about - using taxpayers money to try to shore up banking capital by buying their worthless assets. But the trouble with this scheme. devised by the former Goldman Sachs boss, Henry Paulson who is now US Treasury Secretary, is that no one really knows how big the losses of the banks are, because of this huge amorphous cloud of impenetrable derivatives contracts.
But the story isn’t over there. Not only did the banks lend too much, and binge on dodgy derivatives, they based most of their devilish formulae on a presumption that house prices always go up. Now, statistically speaking, this is arguably the case - over time, house prices have always risen in the long run. However, in the short run, the graph can be a very lumpy one, with rises and big falls. For some reason, the banks forgot this, and thought that the bubble in house prices that was ignited by the 2001 interest rate cuts, would continue forever.
This was utter madness. House prices are now falling to trend - which means to their historic values. This means a reduction of something like 30-50%, because the graph of prices always overshoots on the upside and downside. Look at any historical table of house prices and this is blindingly obvious - but for some reason the banks believed that the laws of economics had been suspended by their brilliant mathematics.
So now what happens? Well, as house prices continue to fall, as fall they must, the value of the assets in companies like HBOS will continue to be marked down. This is why LLoyds TSB shareholders are very reluctant to take on HBOS at any price, because it is stuffed with dodgy mortgages which are falling in value. The banks all hoped that by now the central banks would have cut interest rates and people would all have started buying houses again - and that is what the US and British governments are still hoping will happen. But it won’t and it can’t. House prices are simply too high and have to fall, even with cuts in interest rates. The banks know this, which is why they are refusing to lend unless people can put up large deposits.
This creates a vicious circle which can only be resolved by the assets being revalued. House prices must come down; the banks’ assets must be repriced; insolvent banks must be closed; interest rates must be recalibrated to encourage saving; consumers will have to stop borrowing to spend and everyone will have to start paying their debts. It’s a tall order, and governments across the world are in denial. But the only way out of this mess is some very hard medicine. The longer governments and banks put off swallowing it, the longer the slump will last.
Saturday, October 11, 2008
Darling's having a good war
You wonder why they bother, finance ministers I mean. The stock market fell when Alistair Darling dithered over a rescue package for the banks. So he handed the banks the biggest bail out in history - £500bn of our money - and what happened? The market crashed in the worst panic since 1987. There’s just no pleasing some people
The same thing happened in America. When Congress rejected Treasury Secretary Paulson’s $700bn TARP plan last month the Dow collapsed; when Congress passed it, the markets collapsed again. The lesson seems to be that if you dither things get worse, but when you act they still get worse.
This revolution of falling expectations was a phenomenon noted by the economist JK Galbraith in his study of the Great Depression. It’s all part of the process called “deleveraging” - the modern term for drowning in your own debt. Government interventions, however well intentioned, become stages in the continuing crisis of insolvency.
Shocks like the Icelandic default, itself a knock on effect of the collapse of the investment bank Lehman Brothers last month, leave British savers bereft and British councils with hundreds of millions of losses. This breeds more fear and more government interventions which make markets even more nervous. The latest epic falls in the stock market are partly a consequence of the Icelandic insolvency reinforced by obscure traumas in the credit default swap market. And don’t be fooled that these are just paper losses. Last week’s share-price collapse will hit the asset base of companies and banks causing a further wave of write downs, fire-sales and bankruptcies. We are now in a kind of death spiral.
Last week we nearly saw a run on the entire UK banking system - an event which was only forestalled by the Chancellor, Alistair Darling’s, rescue package on Wednesday. Darling is having a good war, so far. His unflappable calm - which I witnessed at close hand at a reception at Downing St last week at the height of the crisis- has turned into a real asset for the government. He must have known about the bank run as he nibbled at canapés with various hyperventilating hacks. But he looked as if he’d just dropped in on his way to the opera. Not that the Chancellor appeared complacent or detached. No one can accuse Darling of failing to appreciate the gravity of the situation because of that Guardian interview two months warning us that this could be the worst financial crisis in 60 years. He was not wrong.
It’s a sobering thought, but our own Alistair Darling will now forever be associated with one of the greatest economic catastrophes of modern times. His face will adorn every website devoted to the Great Crash of 2008. That curry he bought in to feed his team on the night of the rescue has already become part of history as the “Balti bailout”. Economists and historians will now assess his every move, his slightest utterance. Remember hapless Tory Chancellor, Norman Lamont, outside the Treasury on Black Wednesday 1992 standing next to a dumpster and trying to sound calm while his hair was blowing away in what seemed like a financial hurricane. Further back, Philip Snowden had the misfortune to be Labour’s Chancellor during the 1929 crash and the Great Depression, and is hardly a congenial role model for Darling. The hard-bitten Snowden imposed a fiscal crackdown and split the government, and the Labour Party. with his call for cuts in unemployment benefit. Snowden never recovered. Let’s just not go there.
No, it’s really not a good idea to be a Chancellor in a recession - which may explain why Gordon got out when he did. Finance ministers are largely there to carry the can for everything that goes wrong - and as we know, in a financial crisis, everything goes wrong, even the things that go right. Darling’s economic package last week was in many ways a triumph. It was hailed by economists, commentators and financial analysts as an imaginative and comprehensive solution to the problem of credit drought and insolvency in the banking system. The recapitalisation of the leading banks, backed by colossal sums in liquidity and debt-relief, almost certainly halted the run on the banks. You could almost see people breathe easier. Coupled with the co-ordinated cuts in interest rates, it looked like the government had stepped up to the plate and hit a home run. How much better it seemed than the US Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson’s botched and divisive TARP bailout last month.
The only problem with Alistair Darling’s cunning plan was that it didn’t actually work - at least not in the markets. The FTSE share index shrugged, thought a bit, and then indulged in a senseless act of panic selling on Black Friday.. The FTSE dropped 9% in one day and is now down 40% on last year. The markets are simply not in the mood to be reassured right now, and the fact that the balti bailout was the biggest in history only made them more fearful that things must be really, really bad.
This is what Roosevelt meant in the 1930s when he said that there was “nothing to fear but fear itself”. It is the nature of markets to indulge in self-reinforcing panics which prolong and intensify economic crises. Unfortunately, it is not that easy to halt the fear spiral, as we saw last week. It takes more than a financial package, however well crafted.
So what would work? Well first of all heads should roll - and yes, I know that sounds a bit petty and vindictive, but it’s true. The fact that the bosses of those banks, like Sir Fred “the shred” Goodwin of RBS and Andy “spiv’s spiv” Hornby of HBOS are still in post with their multimillion pound salaries and bonuses is not just a scandal, it is an obstacle to recovery. Until the people responsible are cleared out of insolvent and irresponsibly-managed financial institutions, how can the public, and the markets, be sure that things have actually changed? In any other walk of life, when there is a major failure of leadership, the leaders take the walk to restore confidence.
The other failing is more profound. Everyone accepts that the problem has been one of an irresponsible credit and housing bubble which has now burst with spectacular consequences. House prices are falling faster than in 1991. The debt-model for the British economy is dead, the markets understand that viscerally. Just cutting interest rates and stuffing the banks with public money will not work - and, if it did, might just lay the ground for the next bubble.
We cannot live on house prices alone. Recovery will require a broad economic strategy - like the New Deal in the 30s - involving investment in infrastructure, like fast rail, sunrise industries like renewable energy, and a manufacturing and technology strategy. This is a lot harder than giving money to banks. But as someone said in another context: there is no alternative.
The same thing happened in America. When Congress rejected Treasury Secretary Paulson’s $700bn TARP plan last month the Dow collapsed; when Congress passed it, the markets collapsed again. The lesson seems to be that if you dither things get worse, but when you act they still get worse.
This revolution of falling expectations was a phenomenon noted by the economist JK Galbraith in his study of the Great Depression. It’s all part of the process called “deleveraging” - the modern term for drowning in your own debt. Government interventions, however well intentioned, become stages in the continuing crisis of insolvency.
Shocks like the Icelandic default, itself a knock on effect of the collapse of the investment bank Lehman Brothers last month, leave British savers bereft and British councils with hundreds of millions of losses. This breeds more fear and more government interventions which make markets even more nervous. The latest epic falls in the stock market are partly a consequence of the Icelandic insolvency reinforced by obscure traumas in the credit default swap market. And don’t be fooled that these are just paper losses. Last week’s share-price collapse will hit the asset base of companies and banks causing a further wave of write downs, fire-sales and bankruptcies. We are now in a kind of death spiral.
Last week we nearly saw a run on the entire UK banking system - an event which was only forestalled by the Chancellor, Alistair Darling’s, rescue package on Wednesday. Darling is having a good war, so far. His unflappable calm - which I witnessed at close hand at a reception at Downing St last week at the height of the crisis- has turned into a real asset for the government. He must have known about the bank run as he nibbled at canapés with various hyperventilating hacks. But he looked as if he’d just dropped in on his way to the opera. Not that the Chancellor appeared complacent or detached. No one can accuse Darling of failing to appreciate the gravity of the situation because of that Guardian interview two months warning us that this could be the worst financial crisis in 60 years. He was not wrong.
It’s a sobering thought, but our own Alistair Darling will now forever be associated with one of the greatest economic catastrophes of modern times. His face will adorn every website devoted to the Great Crash of 2008. That curry he bought in to feed his team on the night of the rescue has already become part of history as the “Balti bailout”. Economists and historians will now assess his every move, his slightest utterance. Remember hapless Tory Chancellor, Norman Lamont, outside the Treasury on Black Wednesday 1992 standing next to a dumpster and trying to sound calm while his hair was blowing away in what seemed like a financial hurricane. Further back, Philip Snowden had the misfortune to be Labour’s Chancellor during the 1929 crash and the Great Depression, and is hardly a congenial role model for Darling. The hard-bitten Snowden imposed a fiscal crackdown and split the government, and the Labour Party. with his call for cuts in unemployment benefit. Snowden never recovered. Let’s just not go there.
No, it’s really not a good idea to be a Chancellor in a recession - which may explain why Gordon got out when he did. Finance ministers are largely there to carry the can for everything that goes wrong - and as we know, in a financial crisis, everything goes wrong, even the things that go right. Darling’s economic package last week was in many ways a triumph. It was hailed by economists, commentators and financial analysts as an imaginative and comprehensive solution to the problem of credit drought and insolvency in the banking system. The recapitalisation of the leading banks, backed by colossal sums in liquidity and debt-relief, almost certainly halted the run on the banks. You could almost see people breathe easier. Coupled with the co-ordinated cuts in interest rates, it looked like the government had stepped up to the plate and hit a home run. How much better it seemed than the US Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson’s botched and divisive TARP bailout last month.
The only problem with Alistair Darling’s cunning plan was that it didn’t actually work - at least not in the markets. The FTSE share index shrugged, thought a bit, and then indulged in a senseless act of panic selling on Black Friday.. The FTSE dropped 9% in one day and is now down 40% on last year. The markets are simply not in the mood to be reassured right now, and the fact that the balti bailout was the biggest in history only made them more fearful that things must be really, really bad.
This is what Roosevelt meant in the 1930s when he said that there was “nothing to fear but fear itself”. It is the nature of markets to indulge in self-reinforcing panics which prolong and intensify economic crises. Unfortunately, it is not that easy to halt the fear spiral, as we saw last week. It takes more than a financial package, however well crafted.
So what would work? Well first of all heads should roll - and yes, I know that sounds a bit petty and vindictive, but it’s true. The fact that the bosses of those banks, like Sir Fred “the shred” Goodwin of RBS and Andy “spiv’s spiv” Hornby of HBOS are still in post with their multimillion pound salaries and bonuses is not just a scandal, it is an obstacle to recovery. Until the people responsible are cleared out of insolvent and irresponsibly-managed financial institutions, how can the public, and the markets, be sure that things have actually changed? In any other walk of life, when there is a major failure of leadership, the leaders take the walk to restore confidence.
The other failing is more profound. Everyone accepts that the problem has been one of an irresponsible credit and housing bubble which has now burst with spectacular consequences. House prices are falling faster than in 1991. The debt-model for the British economy is dead, the markets understand that viscerally. Just cutting interest rates and stuffing the banks with public money will not work - and, if it did, might just lay the ground for the next bubble.
We cannot live on house prices alone. Recovery will require a broad economic strategy - like the New Deal in the 30s - involving investment in infrastructure, like fast rail, sunrise industries like renewable energy, and a manufacturing and technology strategy. This is a lot harder than giving money to banks. But as someone said in another context: there is no alternative.
Friday, October 10, 2008
Baugur it! We'll not let Johnny Icelander seize our assets!
Well, it makes a change from fighting over fish. I can dimly recall scenes of from last cod war with Iceland in the 70s - gallant British trawlers biffing Johnny Icelander where it hurt, right in the fish stocks. We lost that one.
But this time it’s personal. The Icelandic fiends have frozen British bank accounts - and they know a thing or two about cold storage up there. Britain retaliated by seizing £4bn of Icelandic bank assets under our anti-terrorist laws. Clearly, these assets were dangerous Icelandic militants armed with suicide belts set to explode in branches of the Bradford and Bingley.
But as ceasefire talks begin in Rejkyavik the horror continues. British savers are being slaughtered in their savings accounts. Other casualties include local authorities with millions lost in Icelandic accounts, housing associations, charities. Even police authorities lost their shirts and now want Mr Landsbanki to help them with their inquiries.
It’s at times like this that the nation has to pull together, so thank goodness for our Great Leader. It's Gordon’s finest hour. “We shall fight them in the branches, we shall fight them in the savings accounts, we shall fight them in the bankruptcy courts and shopping tills- we shall never surrender”.
It may seem an unequal struggle. Iceland has 330,000 against our 60,000,000 - but they do have a lot of puffins on their side. And Iceland is a very cold country where British soldiers would not be allowed actually to fight because of the health and safety. So we will have to use British ingenuity to win this great fight. Undercover bankers with golden parachutes will be dropped on Reykjavik to wreak havoc on their banking system with crazy derivative schemes.
There is one problem though. The Icelanders have already conquered most of our high streets. Over he last decade House of Fraser, Debenhams, Whistles,, Iceland (honestly) and West Ham United, have all fallen into Viking hands as a result of brutal raids led by flame-haired billionaire Jon Asgeir Johannesson backed by Icelandic bank-terrorists. Plans are afoot to seize these stores for Britain and hand them over to the councils as part of recreation and leisure.
Only it isn’t quite as easy as that. Turns out that the Icelandic retail group, Baugur, didn’t actually buy shares in the high street companies, but bought derivatives called “contracts for difference”. This is a wonderful piece of bubble-era financial “engineering” which allows investors to hold a stake in companies without actually owning shares. Or owning the money to buy the non-shares. It means that no one knows who owns what. It’s a mess.
There’s only one solution. Alistair Darling will have to organise a new multi-billion pound bail out of the Icelandic banks, so that Gordon can demand our money back. That’ll Baugur them!
But this time it’s personal. The Icelandic fiends have frozen British bank accounts - and they know a thing or two about cold storage up there. Britain retaliated by seizing £4bn of Icelandic bank assets under our anti-terrorist laws. Clearly, these assets were dangerous Icelandic militants armed with suicide belts set to explode in branches of the Bradford and Bingley.
But as ceasefire talks begin in Rejkyavik the horror continues. British savers are being slaughtered in their savings accounts. Other casualties include local authorities with millions lost in Icelandic accounts, housing associations, charities. Even police authorities lost their shirts and now want Mr Landsbanki to help them with their inquiries.
It’s at times like this that the nation has to pull together, so thank goodness for our Great Leader. It's Gordon’s finest hour. “We shall fight them in the branches, we shall fight them in the savings accounts, we shall fight them in the bankruptcy courts and shopping tills- we shall never surrender”.
It may seem an unequal struggle. Iceland has 330,000 against our 60,000,000 - but they do have a lot of puffins on their side. And Iceland is a very cold country where British soldiers would not be allowed actually to fight because of the health and safety. So we will have to use British ingenuity to win this great fight. Undercover bankers with golden parachutes will be dropped on Reykjavik to wreak havoc on their banking system with crazy derivative schemes.
There is one problem though. The Icelanders have already conquered most of our high streets. Over he last decade House of Fraser, Debenhams, Whistles,, Iceland (honestly) and West Ham United, have all fallen into Viking hands as a result of brutal raids led by flame-haired billionaire Jon Asgeir Johannesson backed by Icelandic bank-terrorists. Plans are afoot to seize these stores for Britain and hand them over to the councils as part of recreation and leisure.
Only it isn’t quite as easy as that. Turns out that the Icelandic retail group, Baugur, didn’t actually buy shares in the high street companies, but bought derivatives called “contracts for difference”. This is a wonderful piece of bubble-era financial “engineering” which allows investors to hold a stake in companies without actually owning shares. Or owning the money to buy the non-shares. It means that no one knows who owns what. It’s a mess.
There’s only one solution. Alistair Darling will have to organise a new multi-billion pound bail out of the Icelandic banks, so that Gordon can demand our money back. That’ll Baugur them!
Thursday, October 09, 2008
Fifty billion here, fifty billion there, and pretty soon you’re talking serious money. Except that you aren’t anymore. Fifty billion has become a trivial sum in the new post-bubble world. If it doesn’t have at least eleven noughts at the end of it, people’s eyes glaze over in boredom.
John Paulson the US Treasury Secretary started it with his epic $700 billion Troubled Asset Relief Programme. Chancellor Alistair Darling couldn’t let that pass, so he launched last week’s one trillion dollar bank bail out - that’s 500 billion of your English pounds. The biggest gamble in history. Proportionately, UK’s help for troubled assets is four times as high as the American one. So there.
But this is only the start. This latest phase of the credit crisis has involved the implosion of the $62 trillion dollar - that’s $62,000,000,000,000 - market in credit default swaps. These are insurance policies on bond default, and have been described as being like betting on your neighbour’s house burning down. Only multiplied so that hundreds of thousands of investors are waiting for your neighbours house to burn down.
Trouble with CDS’s is that no one actually knows what happens if the house actually does burn down, because no one knows who is to pay the losses on all those contracts if there is what is called a “credit event”. This is basically what happened after the huge Wall St bank Lehman’s Brothers - a big player in this market burned down leaving a $400bn or so charred hole. No one wants to know who takes the losses for this and banks won’t lend to each other in case they find out.
You might wonder how a 62 trillion dollar derivative market could grow to this size in only seven years when no one knows whether the contracts can be honoured. It’s like betting with a bookmaker who doesn’t have any money to pay you when you win. But no doubt the good old taxpayer will stump up to finance all these derivative losses. It’s what we do. As we speak Mr Paulson is putting the finishing touches to his 62 trillion dollar Derivative Assets Finance Trust (DAFT) which he says will finally get the system going again.
Only that wouldn’t be nearly enough. The bank of international settlement in Basel estimated last year that the global derivatives market has grown to $500 trillion. Now, at half a quadrillion, that really is serious money: $500,000,000,000,000 A nice round sum equivalent to ten times the value of all the shares on all the world’s stock markets.
Soon the trillion will be a pathetic joke uttered only by villains Austin Powers films. If you’re not in the quadrillion game now you ain’t even at the races. Next time Alistair Darling has a curry he’ll have to add three noughts if he wants to catch our attention. .
Now someone might ask where all this money comes from, and it is a good question There isn’t enough real money in the world to settle all those swaps, futures, puts, options and other bizarre contracts - if they all had to be monetized. So what actually are they? The answer is that no one really knows. Somehow bankers have managed to create a kind of virtual world of synthetic finance, a derivative Second Life, where they have been trading all sorts of exotic financial instruments without actually having to put money up front.
But you can be sure they have been making real money out of this virtual machine otherwise they wouldn’t have done it. But that has all gone into property and retirement yachts. So it’s down to the bank of you and me to pay for the next collapse through our taxes and inflated prices. They’ve got a name for this state we’re in - it’s called Zimbabwe.
John Paulson the US Treasury Secretary started it with his epic $700 billion Troubled Asset Relief Programme. Chancellor Alistair Darling couldn’t let that pass, so he launched last week’s one trillion dollar bank bail out - that’s 500 billion of your English pounds. The biggest gamble in history. Proportionately, UK’s help for troubled assets is four times as high as the American one. So there.
But this is only the start. This latest phase of the credit crisis has involved the implosion of the $62 trillion dollar - that’s $62,000,000,000,000 - market in credit default swaps. These are insurance policies on bond default, and have been described as being like betting on your neighbour’s house burning down. Only multiplied so that hundreds of thousands of investors are waiting for your neighbours house to burn down.
Trouble with CDS’s is that no one actually knows what happens if the house actually does burn down, because no one knows who is to pay the losses on all those contracts if there is what is called a “credit event”. This is basically what happened after the huge Wall St bank Lehman’s Brothers - a big player in this market burned down leaving a $400bn or so charred hole. No one wants to know who takes the losses for this and banks won’t lend to each other in case they find out.
You might wonder how a 62 trillion dollar derivative market could grow to this size in only seven years when no one knows whether the contracts can be honoured. It’s like betting with a bookmaker who doesn’t have any money to pay you when you win. But no doubt the good old taxpayer will stump up to finance all these derivative losses. It’s what we do. As we speak Mr Paulson is putting the finishing touches to his 62 trillion dollar Derivative Assets Finance Trust (DAFT) which he says will finally get the system going again.
Only that wouldn’t be nearly enough. The bank of international settlement in Basel estimated last year that the global derivatives market has grown to $500 trillion. Now, at half a quadrillion, that really is serious money: $500,000,000,000,000 A nice round sum equivalent to ten times the value of all the shares on all the world’s stock markets.
Soon the trillion will be a pathetic joke uttered only by villains Austin Powers films. If you’re not in the quadrillion game now you ain’t even at the races. Next time Alistair Darling has a curry he’ll have to add three noughts if he wants to catch our attention. .
Now someone might ask where all this money comes from, and it is a good question There isn’t enough real money in the world to settle all those swaps, futures, puts, options and other bizarre contracts - if they all had to be monetized. So what actually are they? The answer is that no one really knows. Somehow bankers have managed to create a kind of virtual world of synthetic finance, a derivative Second Life, where they have been trading all sorts of exotic financial instruments without actually having to put money up front.
But you can be sure they have been making real money out of this virtual machine otherwise they wouldn’t have done it. But that has all gone into property and retirement yachts. So it’s down to the bank of you and me to pay for the next collapse through our taxes and inflated prices. They’ve got a name for this state we’re in - it’s called Zimbabwe.
Sunday, October 05, 2008
The arc of prosperity become the arc of insolvency
Typical. After three hundred years Scotland elects an aspirational and popular nationalist government and looks to make its own way in the world, and what happens? A global financial catastrophe threatens to clobber the Scottish economy senseless. Just Scotland?s luck. It?s back to the drawing board.
Well, not quite. But the SNP government can be in no doubt about the seriousness of what has happened in the last few months. The landscape has changed utterly. The Nationalists rode to power on high employment, high house prices and a sense of optimism that was restoring the nation?s battered self-confidence. Now we will see how they cope with national disillusion as Scots discover that houses are not after all a source of free money, that you actually have to make things to have a viable economy, and that while the state can help it can?t make up for what isn?t there.
The idea of turning Scotland into a Celtic Tiger like Ireland looks decidedly sick now that the Tiger is dead and its cubs are looking to emigrate because they seen no future. Ireland made the terrible mistake of believing that a property bubble equated to real wealth. It wasn?t alone, the UK made the same mistake on an ever greater scale ? but Ireland is now faced with the mother of all crashes in a small island. Property prices are plummeting, and the Irish banks are effectively bankrupt as their extravagant loans face default.
But it is as nothing compared to what is happening in Iceland ? the Nordic Leopard that tried to buy up Britain?s high streets. Iceland became a kind of private equity island in which buccaneering bankers, who would give spivs a bad name, used cheap money to go on a leveraged buy out binge of big retail names like Matalan, Debenhams House of Fraser. They bank-rolled entrepreneurs like Sir Tom Hunter and seized trophy assets like West Ham football club. The Icelanders made Russian oligarchs look prudent. But now that their cheap money has been taken away, the Icelandic banks are collapsing one by one, interest rates and inflation have rocketed above fifteen percent, businesses can?t get loans, supermarkets are running short of currency to buy food and people have reportedly resorted to barter to sell houses because of the lack of credit. The Icelandic krona has collapsed and the betting is that it will not survive as Iceland faces national bankruptcy.
National insolvency may await Ireland too. In a state of panic last week the Irish Taoiseach took the astonishing step last week of guaranteeing all bank deposits without limit. This four hundred billion euro gamble is even more of a moral hazard than the US Treasury Secretary, Hank Paulson?s, seven hundred billion dollar bung to Wall St.. The Irish government has placed the profits of its banks above the welfare of its people by mobilising the entire nation?s financial resources in a desperate bid to bolster the share prices of delinquent financial institutions. Moral hazard is too small a word for it.
This is a tragedy for the countries involved, both of which believed they had transformed themselves from sluggish ruminants into entrepreneurial predators within a generation. The effects will be devastating and long lasting as the ?arc of prosperity? has become an arc of insolvency. It is a crisis for what might be called Celtic neoliberalism ? the idea that small countries like Ireland could slash taxes, borrow like there?s no tomorrow and go on raiding parties to the big old economies of Europe. It?s been a salutary lesson too in not placing all your eggs in one basket case: the banks. Iceland and Ireland thought that they could rely on financial expertise alone to build what used to be called ?a modern service economy? and now looks more like a pyramid selling scheme. Only fools believe that you can build an economy on inflated property prices
It?s a lesson that Scotland needs to learn too because we are too dependent on the banks for our own good. Banks like HBOS delude themselves that they create wealth by manufacturing exotic ?financial products? and generating humungous profits from irresponsible property lending. But all they do is create more and more debt, which ultimately trashes real economy. The Royal Bank of Scotland, under Sir Fred ?the shred? Goodwin went on a buying binge, lapping up sub-prime loans in America and dodgy European banks like ABN Amro. It is astonishing that, after the largest rights issue in corporate history, and an unprecedented collapse in RBS shares, Sir Fred is still in post. As is the spiv?s spiv himself, Andy Hornby of HBOS. I?m sorry: these are not the people you want anywhere near running the country.
So the SNP needs to learn how to distance itself from the banks and shun the financial pirates who brought Ireland and Iceland to its knees. The Nationalists have already damaged themselves by association, holding up these egregious examples of collective greed as national role models. This is all the more surprising because there are other rather better models which the SNP could have be looking as as small countires which have tamed their banking tigers.
Both Sweden and Norway had banking crises in the early Nineties. The Scandinavian banks collapsed after ? yes you?ve guessed it, a credit and property bubble in the 1980s that burst just like ours. The Norwegian government moved quickly, driving down the shares of the banks to zero, nationalising many and taking an equity stake in the rest. It restructured and recapitalised the banks and then sold them off, so that the Norwegian taxpayers didn?t lose and the bankers didn?t get bailed out. It was the reverse of what the Irish have done, which is to hand unlimited taxpayers money as collateral to the very bankers whose irresponsibility brought the country to ruin.
Why has there not been more discussion of the Norwegian bust? I don?t know, but perhaps it is because it carries a hard lesson: that you have to destroy the bad banks before you can rebuild good ones. Bailing out the existing banks is folly, as is basing a national economic policy on insititutions that have little financial wisdom and even less moral integrity. It is understandable that the First Minister, Alex Salmond, has like his Labour predecessors been bigging up Scotland?s banks as national champions ? they employ a lot of people. But it is a devil?s embrace which could destroy his party and destroy the country. If independence were to happen, it cannot be on the terms set by the banks. As Thomas Jefferson observed, if you let them anywhere near the seat of power: ?the banks will,first by inflation then by deflation, deprive the people of all property until their children wake up homeless?.
Well, not quite. But the SNP government can be in no doubt about the seriousness of what has happened in the last few months. The landscape has changed utterly. The Nationalists rode to power on high employment, high house prices and a sense of optimism that was restoring the nation?s battered self-confidence. Now we will see how they cope with national disillusion as Scots discover that houses are not after all a source of free money, that you actually have to make things to have a viable economy, and that while the state can help it can?t make up for what isn?t there.
The idea of turning Scotland into a Celtic Tiger like Ireland looks decidedly sick now that the Tiger is dead and its cubs are looking to emigrate because they seen no future. Ireland made the terrible mistake of believing that a property bubble equated to real wealth. It wasn?t alone, the UK made the same mistake on an ever greater scale ? but Ireland is now faced with the mother of all crashes in a small island. Property prices are plummeting, and the Irish banks are effectively bankrupt as their extravagant loans face default.
But it is as nothing compared to what is happening in Iceland ? the Nordic Leopard that tried to buy up Britain?s high streets. Iceland became a kind of private equity island in which buccaneering bankers, who would give spivs a bad name, used cheap money to go on a leveraged buy out binge of big retail names like Matalan, Debenhams House of Fraser. They bank-rolled entrepreneurs like Sir Tom Hunter and seized trophy assets like West Ham football club. The Icelanders made Russian oligarchs look prudent. But now that their cheap money has been taken away, the Icelandic banks are collapsing one by one, interest rates and inflation have rocketed above fifteen percent, businesses can?t get loans, supermarkets are running short of currency to buy food and people have reportedly resorted to barter to sell houses because of the lack of credit. The Icelandic krona has collapsed and the betting is that it will not survive as Iceland faces national bankruptcy.
National insolvency may await Ireland too. In a state of panic last week the Irish Taoiseach took the astonishing step last week of guaranteeing all bank deposits without limit. This four hundred billion euro gamble is even more of a moral hazard than the US Treasury Secretary, Hank Paulson?s, seven hundred billion dollar bung to Wall St.. The Irish government has placed the profits of its banks above the welfare of its people by mobilising the entire nation?s financial resources in a desperate bid to bolster the share prices of delinquent financial institutions. Moral hazard is too small a word for it.
This is a tragedy for the countries involved, both of which believed they had transformed themselves from sluggish ruminants into entrepreneurial predators within a generation. The effects will be devastating and long lasting as the ?arc of prosperity? has become an arc of insolvency. It is a crisis for what might be called Celtic neoliberalism ? the idea that small countries like Ireland could slash taxes, borrow like there?s no tomorrow and go on raiding parties to the big old economies of Europe. It?s been a salutary lesson too in not placing all your eggs in one basket case: the banks. Iceland and Ireland thought that they could rely on financial expertise alone to build what used to be called ?a modern service economy? and now looks more like a pyramid selling scheme. Only fools believe that you can build an economy on inflated property prices
It?s a lesson that Scotland needs to learn too because we are too dependent on the banks for our own good. Banks like HBOS delude themselves that they create wealth by manufacturing exotic ?financial products? and generating humungous profits from irresponsible property lending. But all they do is create more and more debt, which ultimately trashes real economy. The Royal Bank of Scotland, under Sir Fred ?the shred? Goodwin went on a buying binge, lapping up sub-prime loans in America and dodgy European banks like ABN Amro. It is astonishing that, after the largest rights issue in corporate history, and an unprecedented collapse in RBS shares, Sir Fred is still in post. As is the spiv?s spiv himself, Andy Hornby of HBOS. I?m sorry: these are not the people you want anywhere near running the country.
So the SNP needs to learn how to distance itself from the banks and shun the financial pirates who brought Ireland and Iceland to its knees. The Nationalists have already damaged themselves by association, holding up these egregious examples of collective greed as national role models. This is all the more surprising because there are other rather better models which the SNP could have be looking as as small countires which have tamed their banking tigers.
Both Sweden and Norway had banking crises in the early Nineties. The Scandinavian banks collapsed after ? yes you?ve guessed it, a credit and property bubble in the 1980s that burst just like ours. The Norwegian government moved quickly, driving down the shares of the banks to zero, nationalising many and taking an equity stake in the rest. It restructured and recapitalised the banks and then sold them off, so that the Norwegian taxpayers didn?t lose and the bankers didn?t get bailed out. It was the reverse of what the Irish have done, which is to hand unlimited taxpayers money as collateral to the very bankers whose irresponsibility brought the country to ruin.
Why has there not been more discussion of the Norwegian bust? I don?t know, but perhaps it is because it carries a hard lesson: that you have to destroy the bad banks before you can rebuild good ones. Bailing out the existing banks is folly, as is basing a national economic policy on insititutions that have little financial wisdom and even less moral integrity. It is understandable that the First Minister, Alex Salmond, has like his Labour predecessors been bigging up Scotland?s banks as national champions ? they employ a lot of people. But it is a devil?s embrace which could destroy his party and destroy the country. If independence were to happen, it cannot be on the terms set by the banks. As Thomas Jefferson observed, if you let them anywhere near the seat of power: ?the banks will,first by inflation then by deflation, deprive the people of all property until their children wake up homeless?.
Saturday, October 04, 2008
Peter Mandelson is to politics what the naked short seller is to corporate finance. Bringing back the @prince of darkness@ was one of those ideas that probably sounded great late at night after a few beers, but should have been abandoned in the cold light of day. What is worrying is that there is clearly no one around the Prime Minister capable of telling him so.
Yes ,I know all the arguments for having the former Labour spin-doctor back in cabinet - about ?keeping your friends close and your enemies closer?. Having Peter Mandelson in the tent stops the Blairites setting fire to it; grabs the attention of the business community; shows Brown is capable of commanding the news agenda; marginalises rivals like David Miliband; creates a kind of ?war cabinet? of all the talents to deal with the economic crisis. But really, this is not an act of decisive leadership; it is a gesture of Prime Ministerial attention-seeking . Brown couldn?t think of anything sensible to do, so he did something daft.
Why is it daft? Well first of all, because Peter Mandelson is, as the Labour MP John McDonnell poijnted out, the most divisive figure in Labour politics. He is an accident waiting to happen. He has resigned from cabinet twice ? the first time as Trade and Industry Secretary in 1998 after he failed to disclose a large loan he had accepted from a wealthy ministerial colleague, Geoffrey Robinson, who was under investigation by his own department. His second resignation, in 2001, followed his apparent canvassing for a passport on behalf of a billionaire businessman, Scrichand Hinduja. With form like this, every action of the new Business Secretary, will be under scrutiny by a sceptical press. Every disaffected official and political contact will be on the lookout for dirt.
.And is twice-disgraced Peter Mandelson really the man to clean up the City.? There is a lot of prima facia evidence emerging from the mortgage bust of fraud, malfeasance, misselling, accountancy irregularities and plain theft. Look at what we are learning about the corporate culture of banks like HBOS. Of Bradford and Bingley. How can Mandelson,with his record, be expected to crack down on bad behaviour by the banks? Yes, he has done the crime and served his time in political obscurity. But his resignations have fatally undermined his probity, and that will make it very difficult for Peter Mandelson to carry credibility when it counts, when dealing with the spivs and speculators. They will sense his moral vulnerability and will exploit it.
Moreover, Peter Mandelson is an evangelist for globalisation and deregulation right at the moment when free market idolatry has become discredited. He is the minister who famously said he was ?seriously relaxed about people becoming filthy rich?. Well, he should not be relaxed. It was the pursuit of extravagant personal gain that led to the breakdown in the financial system, as bonus-driven executives took greater and greater risks in their determination to become filthy rich before the system collapsed. At this crucial time we do not need someone in charge of the store who adores wealth the way Peter Mandelson evidently does.
As European trade commissioner, Peter Mandelson antagonised developing countries because of his commitment to free market globalisation and his willingness to expose vulnerable economies to the predations of supercapitalism. And it isn?t just development organisations like the World Development Movement who think he is a neoliberal bully. Mandelson managed to fall out spectacularly with the Chinese over clothing exports ? the infamous @bra wars~- and with the French President Nicholas Sarkozy over agriculture tariffs. The Doha round of international trade liberalisation collapsed under Peter Mandelson?s watch, and while he cannot be held entirely to blame for that, his unthinking commitment to globalisation certainly played a part in its downfall. The Prime Minister has hailed his experience in international economic affairs ? but what exactly does this experience bring to the UK cabinet as Secretary for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform? Further deregulation, no doubt, of the kind that has turned Britain into an unstable hedge fund.
So, Peter Mandelson is unreliable, tainted with sleaze, handicapped in office, confrontational in negotiations and passionately committed to precisely the kind of unregulated financial globalisation that has brought the world economy to the bring of total collapse. But there is something much worse that Peter Mandelson brings to the cabinet table. He is the author of Labour?s original sin: spin.
I well remember, on the day of John Smith?s death in 1994, watching Peter Mandelson oiling around the Lobby in Westminster - where I was a political hack - working the press, easing Brown out and easing Blair in. Mandelson functions by cultivating a handful of press insiders who are fed stories provided they remain on message. Sometimes the stories are even true. He is an incorrigible manipulator of the media, a politician who simply cannot stop plotting and briefing. He tried on many occasions to give up his addiction to the black arts of spin after he entered government in 1997, and invariably failed.
A cabinet with Mandelson sitting in it will be a cabinet which is always looking over its shoulder, permanently waiting for the knife in the back. Brown hopes that they will all think Mandelson?s knife is now being wielded in the interest of the Prime Minister, and that this will keep them all in line. Like Stalin who used the psychopathic secret policeman Beria to frighten his politburo. But fear is not a climate that encourages stable and effective government.
Gordon Brown clearly feels rejuvenated, intoxicated even by his conference success and his recovery in the opinion polls. He feels he is in charge again, driving events, making headlines, just like the old days. But this isn?t the old days. Labour is a tired and discredited administration led by a Prime Minister who has lost his way and is profoundly unpopular ? more unpopular than any Labour Prime Minister in history. His attempts to surround himself with cronies and manipulators will not help him recover his political standing and will only diminish him in the eyes of history.
Gordon Brown faces his nemesis in Glenrothes in about four week?s time. Does he seriously think that Peter Mandelson is going to help him win that important by-election? Of course not. He expects Mandy to do what Mandy does, and find ways of creating diversions, identifying scapegoats, burying bad news. It is another profound shock to those who have always respected Gordon Brown as one of the great Labour politicians of his generation. That Gordon should have descended to this desperate rehabilitation of a discredited political fixer is not just bad, it is sad.
Yes ,I know all the arguments for having the former Labour spin-doctor back in cabinet - about ?keeping your friends close and your enemies closer?. Having Peter Mandelson in the tent stops the Blairites setting fire to it; grabs the attention of the business community; shows Brown is capable of commanding the news agenda; marginalises rivals like David Miliband; creates a kind of ?war cabinet? of all the talents to deal with the economic crisis. But really, this is not an act of decisive leadership; it is a gesture of Prime Ministerial attention-seeking . Brown couldn?t think of anything sensible to do, so he did something daft.
Why is it daft? Well first of all, because Peter Mandelson is, as the Labour MP John McDonnell poijnted out, the most divisive figure in Labour politics. He is an accident waiting to happen. He has resigned from cabinet twice ? the first time as Trade and Industry Secretary in 1998 after he failed to disclose a large loan he had accepted from a wealthy ministerial colleague, Geoffrey Robinson, who was under investigation by his own department. His second resignation, in 2001, followed his apparent canvassing for a passport on behalf of a billionaire businessman, Scrichand Hinduja. With form like this, every action of the new Business Secretary, will be under scrutiny by a sceptical press. Every disaffected official and political contact will be on the lookout for dirt.
.And is twice-disgraced Peter Mandelson really the man to clean up the City.? There is a lot of prima facia evidence emerging from the mortgage bust of fraud, malfeasance, misselling, accountancy irregularities and plain theft. Look at what we are learning about the corporate culture of banks like HBOS. Of Bradford and Bingley. How can Mandelson,with his record, be expected to crack down on bad behaviour by the banks? Yes, he has done the crime and served his time in political obscurity. But his resignations have fatally undermined his probity, and that will make it very difficult for Peter Mandelson to carry credibility when it counts, when dealing with the spivs and speculators. They will sense his moral vulnerability and will exploit it.
Moreover, Peter Mandelson is an evangelist for globalisation and deregulation right at the moment when free market idolatry has become discredited. He is the minister who famously said he was ?seriously relaxed about people becoming filthy rich?. Well, he should not be relaxed. It was the pursuit of extravagant personal gain that led to the breakdown in the financial system, as bonus-driven executives took greater and greater risks in their determination to become filthy rich before the system collapsed. At this crucial time we do not need someone in charge of the store who adores wealth the way Peter Mandelson evidently does.
As European trade commissioner, Peter Mandelson antagonised developing countries because of his commitment to free market globalisation and his willingness to expose vulnerable economies to the predations of supercapitalism. And it isn?t just development organisations like the World Development Movement who think he is a neoliberal bully. Mandelson managed to fall out spectacularly with the Chinese over clothing exports ? the infamous @bra wars~- and with the French President Nicholas Sarkozy over agriculture tariffs. The Doha round of international trade liberalisation collapsed under Peter Mandelson?s watch, and while he cannot be held entirely to blame for that, his unthinking commitment to globalisation certainly played a part in its downfall. The Prime Minister has hailed his experience in international economic affairs ? but what exactly does this experience bring to the UK cabinet as Secretary for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform? Further deregulation, no doubt, of the kind that has turned Britain into an unstable hedge fund.
So, Peter Mandelson is unreliable, tainted with sleaze, handicapped in office, confrontational in negotiations and passionately committed to precisely the kind of unregulated financial globalisation that has brought the world economy to the bring of total collapse. But there is something much worse that Peter Mandelson brings to the cabinet table. He is the author of Labour?s original sin: spin.
I well remember, on the day of John Smith?s death in 1994, watching Peter Mandelson oiling around the Lobby in Westminster - where I was a political hack - working the press, easing Brown out and easing Blair in. Mandelson functions by cultivating a handful of press insiders who are fed stories provided they remain on message. Sometimes the stories are even true. He is an incorrigible manipulator of the media, a politician who simply cannot stop plotting and briefing. He tried on many occasions to give up his addiction to the black arts of spin after he entered government in 1997, and invariably failed.
A cabinet with Mandelson sitting in it will be a cabinet which is always looking over its shoulder, permanently waiting for the knife in the back. Brown hopes that they will all think Mandelson?s knife is now being wielded in the interest of the Prime Minister, and that this will keep them all in line. Like Stalin who used the psychopathic secret policeman Beria to frighten his politburo. But fear is not a climate that encourages stable and effective government.
Gordon Brown clearly feels rejuvenated, intoxicated even by his conference success and his recovery in the opinion polls. He feels he is in charge again, driving events, making headlines, just like the old days. But this isn?t the old days. Labour is a tired and discredited administration led by a Prime Minister who has lost his way and is profoundly unpopular ? more unpopular than any Labour Prime Minister in history. His attempts to surround himself with cronies and manipulators will not help him recover his political standing and will only diminish him in the eyes of history.
Gordon Brown faces his nemesis in Glenrothes in about four week?s time. Does he seriously think that Peter Mandelson is going to help him win that important by-election? Of course not. He expects Mandy to do what Mandy does, and find ways of creating diversions, identifying scapegoats, burying bad news. It is another profound shock to those who have always respected Gordon Brown as one of the great Labour politicians of his generation. That Gordon should have descended to this desperate rehabilitation of a discredited political fixer is not just bad, it is sad.
Friday, October 03, 2008
Tories offer free buckfast
We all know that Alex Salmond is a miracle worker, but last week he surpassed even himself. He managed to get students up early enough to go to nine o’clock lectures. Admittedly they were up at the crack to lobby parliament against banning alcohol sales to under 21 year olds, but at least it was a start. Perhaps the Scottish government should propose banning sales of pot noodles or mobile phone ring tones. It would be a revolution in student behaviour, a new dawn of higher education.
The Scottish Government’s plan to come between the Scottish teenager and his bottle has won few supporters. Libdem, Tories, Labour, Greens - even Margo MacDonald - agree that banning off licence drink sales to under 21s is a violation of human rights. A unique and historic political consensus has been forged in Holyrood. They may not have been able to unite in defence of the Union, but when it comes to alcohol, the opposition parties are shoulder to shoulder at the bar of public opinion.
“It would be a ludicrous situation”, thundered the Tory spokesman, Murdo Fraser, during last week’s debate, “when a 20 year old soldier back from Iraq or Afghanistan cannot buy a bottle of champagne from an off-license to celebrate his safe return with his wife”. This conjured an image of battle-hardened squaddies roaring around Buchanan St waving bottles of Heidsieck and Mumm. Clearly Murdo knows some pretty well-heeled sodjers.
The point is taken, though. What does the SNP Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill think he's doing trying to stop young adults who can vote, fight and marry being able to buy a six pack in Tescos? Especially when they can legally blow the housekeeping getting rat-arsed in the pub next door. Perhaps a lot of SNP supporters are publicans and this is a fund-raising project. The Nats say that pilots in Larbert, Stenhousemuir, Armadale and Cupar showed a reduction in crime, but they would wouldn’t they. They’ve probably got nothing better to do there than go to the pub and drown their sorrows.
Clearly the SNP think it will show them to be tough on neds and tough on the causes of neds. Kenny MacAskill tore into the Tories for having “moved from Cameron hugging a hoodie to Murdo Fraser’s free bottle of Buckie”. Tories giving away free tonic wine! Now, that’s the way to win the youth vote. Another MSP helpfully pointed out that in Inverness offys they’re knocking £2 off a bottle of Buckfast if you buy two. Now they were talking.
MSPs rejected the alcohol sales limit in the Tory-sponsored debate by a wide margin - and then knocked off to the pub for a post-match analysis.
The Scottish Government’s plan to come between the Scottish teenager and his bottle has won few supporters. Libdem, Tories, Labour, Greens - even Margo MacDonald - agree that banning off licence drink sales to under 21s is a violation of human rights. A unique and historic political consensus has been forged in Holyrood. They may not have been able to unite in defence of the Union, but when it comes to alcohol, the opposition parties are shoulder to shoulder at the bar of public opinion.
“It would be a ludicrous situation”, thundered the Tory spokesman, Murdo Fraser, during last week’s debate, “when a 20 year old soldier back from Iraq or Afghanistan cannot buy a bottle of champagne from an off-license to celebrate his safe return with his wife”. This conjured an image of battle-hardened squaddies roaring around Buchanan St waving bottles of Heidsieck and Mumm. Clearly Murdo knows some pretty well-heeled sodjers.
The point is taken, though. What does the SNP Justice Secretary Kenny MacAskill think he's doing trying to stop young adults who can vote, fight and marry being able to buy a six pack in Tescos? Especially when they can legally blow the housekeeping getting rat-arsed in the pub next door. Perhaps a lot of SNP supporters are publicans and this is a fund-raising project. The Nats say that pilots in Larbert, Stenhousemuir, Armadale and Cupar showed a reduction in crime, but they would wouldn’t they. They’ve probably got nothing better to do there than go to the pub and drown their sorrows.
Clearly the SNP think it will show them to be tough on neds and tough on the causes of neds. Kenny MacAskill tore into the Tories for having “moved from Cameron hugging a hoodie to Murdo Fraser’s free bottle of Buckie”. Tories giving away free tonic wine! Now, that’s the way to win the youth vote. Another MSP helpfully pointed out that in Inverness offys they’re knocking £2 off a bottle of Buckfast if you buy two. Now they were talking.
MSPs rejected the alcohol sales limit in the Tory-sponsored debate by a wide margin - and then knocked off to the pub for a post-match analysis.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)