Monday, September 08, 2008

Could Labour win Glenrothes?

Could we have a new prime minister by Christmas? Possibly, if the Glenrothes by-election goes wrong for Labour.
Another sensational by-election defeat, following Crew and Nantwich and Glasgow East, really could end Gordon Brown’s career. The fate of the Prime Minister, and perhaps the entire government, rests on the shoulders of the voters of this Fife constituency which must deliver its verdict sometime in the next two months

So what can Labour do to win this supposedly safe seat, which the bookies have already awarded to the SNP? So far the debate has centred on timing. Should Gordon Brown delay the vote - deploying the so-called Travolta-Micawber strategy of staying alive in the hope that something turns up? But timing isn’t everything - there is the small matter of the campaign itself. Labour cannot afford to repeat the shambles of Glasgow East, where they launched their campaign without a candidate and failed dismally to counter the Alex Salmond effect.

So, what can Labour do in to improve its chances in Glenrothes? Unfortunately, they can’t get rid of Gordon Brown, who is probably their main electoral liability there. This was made abundantly clear as early as February 2006, when the Liberal Democrat Willie Rennie snatched the nearby Dunfermline and West Fife at a by-election overturning a similar five figure Labour majority. Even when he was Chancellor, and supposedly at the height of his powers, Gordon Brown was a vote loser. Now, after Glasgow East, where Labour lost the third safest seat in Scotland on a 22% swing to the SNP, he is the electoral equivalent of toxic waste.

But they can’t just dump Gordon , so Labour will have to do the opposite - force him into the front line in the hope that he can reawaken some of the respect he used to command in Fife. He was brought up in the Kingdom, after all, and sits for the neighbouring constituency of Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath. Brown is part of the political landscape of the Kingdom, and if he has to make a last stand in defence of his leadership, then Fife is arguably the best place for it. His late father was a highly respected Church Minister and there must be a lot of residual affection for the prime minister and his family, especially given the health problems of his son. Sarah Brown is a highly respected figure because of her charity work and for her reluctance to hog the limelight in the manner the previous First Lady of Downing St.. Brown had a good relationship with John MacDougall, the late MP for Glenrothes, an ex boilermaker, and goes back a long way with the trades unions there, so he has deep roots to draw on.

But the SNP has roots here too. Glenrothes is a very much easier target for the SNP than Glasgow East. In West Central Scotland, nationalism is an alien creed; in Fife it is an accepted part of the political landscape, and the press is much more favourably disposed to the nationalism than in Glasgow. The SNP hold the equivalent Holyrood seat for Glenrothes, which makes it doubly difficult to see Labour avoiding another defeat. The nationalists also lead the coalition on Fife council and have a strong organisation on the ground.

To demolish that nationalist presence, Brown would have to tour every corner of the constituency, matching Alex Salmond, mile for mile. He would have to convince a sceptical constituency that as Prime Minister he would personally ensure that it doesn’t just become another moribund Labour backwater.
He would also have to defeat Alex Salmond soundly in intellectual debate, something he was certainly capable of in the past.

And like Salmond in Glasgow, Brown would have to elbow aside the Labour candidate. This is likely to be either Alex Rowley, the Labour group leader on Fife Council or Christine May, the former MSP for Fife Central. I cannot, by the way, see Brown honouring the former First Minister, Henry McLeish, as candidate for Glenrothes - there is not a lot of mutual respect there. Anyway it would be madness so soon after another Scottish leader, Wendy Alexander’s, resignation over her campaign finances. McLeish, remember, resigned as First Minister, and local MSP, after a funding scandal in 2001, and while many thought Henry’s subletting of his constituency offices wasn't a resignation matter, the fact remains that he did resign. The SNP would say that he wasn’t fit for Holyrood, but now Labour thinks he is fit for Glenrothes.

, Brown could of course, try to steal the election by political bribery. He has already signalled that there will be some measures - such as the stamp duty holiday, or the scrapping of road tax increases - to sweeten the Chancellor’s pre-Budget report in October. But these are unlikely to do much for him in Glenrothes, and may even create a negative reaction. It didn’t go down too well in Crewe and Nantwich when Brown cobbled together that £2.7 ‘rescue’ for those hit by the abolition of the 10p tax band. With inflation likely to be running at 5% by polling day, and with slide in house prices barely started in Scotland, Brown would have to think very carefully before he tries to introduce a by-election fix.

One other possibility might be to announce changes to the party in Scotland to make it more Scottish. Adopt some of the rhetoric being used by Andy Kerr in the Scottish leadership race and promise that the Scottish leader - whoever wins the current leadership race - is going to have more power to deliver those “Scottish solutions to Scottish problems”. He could talk up the Calman Commission which Wendy Alexander established to explore more powers for the Holyrood Parliament. Do not, however, expect the Prime Minister to call for a referendum on independence. Alex Salmond, will do that, quoting Wendy Alexander.

No it isn’t looking good, for Labour. The SNP will have to mount a dreadful campaign to lose in Glenrothes. I’m afraid this could be Gordon's big red one.


Jeff said...

Hi there Iain,

I strongly suspect you know this already but Lindsay Roy has been selected for Labour, just in case you still thought Christine May and Alex Rowley are in the picture.

Although, rumour has it Ms May wasn't very happy about missing out on the shortlist. Not the most democratic of contests seemingly...



Scottish Unionist said...


It's a Sunday Herald editorial from 17th August.