Tuesday, October 08, 2013

i warn you not to be young.


Neil Kinnock made a speech before the 1983 general election in which he said: "I warn you not to be old. I warn you not to get sick. I warn you not to lose your job..." Today, he might have added a warning not to be young. This week an unprecedented assault was launched by the Conservatives on the living standards and prospects of Britain's under 25 year olds, a million of whom are unemployed.

Who would be young today? £9,000 a year fees (in |England at least) no jobs, zero hours contracts, unaffordable mortgages, ruinous rents and now you lose your benefits if you happen to lose your job. Think about it. If you are someone who left school, got an apprenticeship, worked for five years and then were made redundant, you would lose housing benefits and job seekers allowance for the crime of being under 25.

This is so manifestly unfair, I could hardly believe that David Cameron was serious about it in his conference speech. But this is going to be a major plank of their Tory election platform in 18 months. They are already committed to cutting housing benefits for jobless under 25s, and now they plan to take away jobseekers allowance too, which at £51 is already too little to live on.

I'm not entirely sure this is even legal. If I were a single parent, or a soldier back from Afghanistan, or a hospital worker axed in the cuts,  I would be inclined to raise a court action for discrimination on grounds of age. These are adults were are talking about, not children. I feel genuinely sorry for the under 25s, setting out on lifetime of debt, their aspirations crushed by an generation of politicians who enjoyed advantages they can only dream about. 


When I was that age, starting a career and buying my first flat, I had no debts whatever, because a grant had seen me through university. I even qualified for social security during university vacations. My first house cost £17,000 ,which was cheap even in the 1980s, and we received grants for structural improvements like new windows and roof repairs. I cannot recall experiencing any financial insecurity, when I entered what was even then a very insecure occupation - broadcast journalism - during an economic recession. But then I had the confidence to persevere through short term contracts because I had low overheads.

It might seem hard to justify these privileges today, but they actually added value to the emerging knowledge economy. I didn't have to take up the first job that came along to service student debts or pay for exorbitant rents or lost benefits.  OK, political journalists may not be the most valuable members of society, but at least my years of education studying politics didn't go entirely to waste. If I had ended up selling coffee, working in telesales or doing an internship in some PR company, they would have.

Look at graduates today. Many don't get jobs at all - for years. They find that their years of study and training are dismissed because they didn't go to the right university or college or get the right degree. They are told that in the "global race" as David Cameron calls it, they are still at the bottom. All very well for him as a product of Eton and Bullingdon - like me, he wasn't part of generation debt.

And this doesn't just apply to graduates. The same is true for vocational workers and apprentices. What is the point of spending time and money acquiring skills if you have to take the first job that comes along to avoid destitution?   No wonder British industrial productivity is going into reverse. We are creating a pool of financially desperate young people who will accept low pay and zero hours, allowing firms to resort to sweated labour rather than investment in new techniques.

I think the Conservatives have gone too far here. They think because their benefits cap was popular that people are prepared to victimise the workless, but they have underestimated the British public, who can see for themselves that their own children, 979,000 of them, are bearing the brunt of the economic crisis.    In Scotland the bedroom tax has generated widespread resistance and calls for welfare to be devolved, and these benefit cuts will be resisted too.  It will intensify the demands for welfare to be devolved to Holyrood whatever the result of the referendum.  
   Why do Scots seem to be more sympathetic to the workless?  Well, one reason is that the experience of unemployment is seared into the national  consciousness, especially in the West of Scotland.  Last week, the Chief Medical Officer for Scotland, Harry Burns, confirmed that Scotland's health problems do not stem from bad diet and alcohol abuse, but from the psychological damage caused by unemployment and the destruction of the industrial communities of West Central Scotland during the recessions of the 1970s and1980s.  The idea that former shipyard and engineering workers "chose" the dole is patently ludicrous.  
   In England, especially in the south, these recessions had a very different impact, as skills and capital fled south to the new consumer industries  based in the home counties.   Most middle class Scots are not so detached from the rest of society that they believe the slanders about the unemployed.   Lacking shares and expensive housing assets, most Scots are only a redundancy away from economic hardship themselves.  This is another indication of the social gulf between Scotland and the South East of England, where most of our national wealth is concentrated.

We are told repeatedly that welfare is 'out of control" in Britain and that we simply cannot afford benefits for people under 25. But the vast majority of the £155bn benefits bill goes on old age pensions and disability benefits. Jobseekers allowance accounts for only £5bn in total, and the young unemployed account for less than a billion of this. Jobseekers allowance is already the lowest unemployment benefit in any comparable developed country.

In Germany and Denmark, people can expect to receive three or four times the British rate when they lose their jobs.. They regard young people as a valuable investment and the idea of forcing them into shelf-stacking or nonsense internships is seen as a waste of human capital. In Denmark they call it "flexicurity". 30% of the labour force change jobs every year, and firms can make employees redundant at short notice and without prejudice. Workers accept this because they know they will be supported while they find another, generally better job. Indeed, changing jobs and retraining is a way of life in Denmark, which is why it is often cited by the World Bank as the best country in the world to set up a business.
   Europe is recovering, but Britain is returning to the dark ages, with an essentially punitive approach to social security and a disregard for training. Unemployed people are demeaned as "skivers" who need to be forced to work - given a "dunt" as the education secretary Michael Gove put it so inelegantly last week. David Cameron repeats the slander that people "choose" a life on benefits.  But at £51 a week no one in their right minds would choose to live on benefits. The problem is lack of jobs, not lack of the will to work. Which is confirmed by the millions of working people who are accepting poverty pay.

There is a specific problem with housing benefits. It is a grotesque misuse of public money shelling out £17bn a year, most of which goes straight into the pockets of buy-to-let landlords. But the problem here is not the unemployed, but the dysfunctional housing market, which has allowed house prices and rents to lose touch with reality. Housing benefit is a national scandal, but it is a direct consequence of the policy of council house sales and the failure of successive governments to build social housing - or any housing.

An young family, struggling with rent and fuel bills, can only look in blank amazement at a government which uses public money to underwrite the deposits for people buying £600,000 houses. The Help to Buy scheme helps the few to acquire an immensely valuable asset thanks to up to £90,000 interest free from the state to help pay the deposit and cushion any losses. This is a blatantly political giveaway to the middle classes of the South East of England.  Ask yourself:  how many first time buyers do you know who are in the market for a £600,000 flat?  Forget Scottish independence: it's the Home Counties that are declaring UDI.

64 comments:

Anonymous said...

Well said.

Brilliant piece.

The Tories, and to a certain extent by their open acceptance of many of the benefit changes, have demonised unemployed, underemployed, sick, and to a certain extent pensioners (who have been told that to retire at 65 and not then put something back into the Big Society is a dereliction of duty).

Surely people in government knew that people were getting older. The baby boom has been talked about for a long time. Did they not prepare for this?

In many cases, as you point out, illness has been caused by the appalling poverty lifestyles and insecurity of people living outwith the financial capital of the world. It's been happening since the 80s. Did no one see that?

I can't imagine starting off life with a £40,000 university debt, and little possibility of a mortgage, but having to pay a huge rent for a mediocre property, so small you can't take 4 steps without turning a corner, and a job that may or may not be there next week, and may or may not pay every week, knowing that if I lose the job, I lose my house too.

What a dreadful place to live. I suspect that it may be illegal to discriminate for age, or lack of it. I hope it is. I'd love to wipe that smile of his smarmy coupon.

1971Thistle said...

Excellent piece

I also come from a time when I was given a grant to attend university. Had I not, I would not have been able to go - my parents could not have afforded to fund this.

As you rightly observe, that would not have mattered, since the incentive would have been removed by the burden of debt incurred.

This is an unjust country, and becoming moreso.

Megz said...

More needs to be in the press about this, though when the tories remove our human rights, which they are planning to do there wont be a thing we can do about it, not that ther is much we could do anyway with them scrapping most of legal aid, and moving to use the lobbying bill to curb protesting. we need out, asap!

Stan-ley said...



For information.

In the lead in time to the 1966 westminster general election Labour under the leadership of Harold Wilson outlined its manifesto to the British public. It proposed among other things, a land value tax, price controls,fair rents, half a million new homes, nationalisation of the steel and aviation industries, strengthening the welfare state and the NHS, integrating the public schools into the state system, creating the Open University and expanding arts provision.

The outcome was a Labour majority of 97.

The question is 'Where and when did the character of the nation start to change?'

To start with consensus politics which had underpinned the post war period through to the Wilson period in office disguised a serious democratic deficit at the heart of the Westminster model.

Trade union leaders while bankrolling the Labour movement were not inclined to surrender power to its elected representatives at Westminster.

Following the 'winter of disconent' and the election of a tory administration under M Thatcher the inadequacies of the Westminster 'First past the post' model were exposed. And to this day nothing has been done to put it right.

With consensus politics consigned to the history books, a flawed system, in 2013, has resulted in a Westminster government which has no mandate from the British public.

In Scotland our fledgling democracy whilst arguably not perfect is an improvement on the Westminster model. We should all remember that when it comes to deciding for or against independence on 18th Sept 2014.

Voyance amour said...

Congratulations on your site , I think it helps out a lot of people , me anyway it is very useful to me , continue like this and good luck ! !

voyance par mail gratuite said...

I collected so many interesting things from your site especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your posts, I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here. Keep up the good work.

Julia said...

Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have truly enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again soon!
voyance gratuite amour
voyance gratuite par email

Anonymous said...

The original speech did say I warn you not to be young...

Voyance gratuite par mail said...

Hi there, simply become aware of your blog through Google, and located that it's really informative. I'm going to be careful for brussels. I'll appreciate should you proceed this in future. A lot of people can be benefited out of your writing. Cheers!|
voyance gratuite mail

voyance gratuite en ligne par mail said...

That is quite surprising... I have never heard of that before reading your post!
It makes me quite puzzled and angry too!

voyance gratuite mail said...

This blog has a lot of friendliness and a warm welcome
Thank you a lot

voyance gratuite said...

Nice Stuff..! I also wish him good luck to defend his gold medal. I definitely enjoyed every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.

rosy123 said...

This blog is so nice to me. I will continue to come here again and again. Visit my link as well.
telephone gay

Unknown said...

Hi friends I found an awesome way to get weekly brief traffic report to my website through, http://freeanalyticreports.com

voyance gratuite en ligne said...

Thank you for all work involved and all the pleasure I find

voyance par mail said...

Congratulations to the site it is very nice to be more interactive and more originale.De it has a lot of content and links.

lin said...

Bravo pour ton blog!! Et surtout, merci pour ce contenu qui me fait toujours plaisir!!
consultation voyance gratuite

rosy123 said...

Bravo ! Votre blog est l'un des meilleurs que j'ai vu !
voyance gratuite en ligne

frases de canserbero said...


Su trabajo es impresionante. Se comparte una cosa agradable con nosotros gracias. Vea también algunas frases de whatsapp y estados para whatsapp de amor que se compartirán con usted.estados para whatsapp Gracias por tu información

Unknown said...

Thanks for sharing this informative news.. so we are also share with you james Anderson hairstyle With the new trends and styles…

huile cosmetique Bio said...

Thank you so much for the greatest job that you did.

Unknown said...

This is verey informative site for amour. I always try to found this type of information. I think It's really heplful for who want to know amour.

rosy123 said...

Tres interessant!!! Je l'ai mis dans mon bookmark!
voyance gratuite par téléphone

aliamay said...

ICC Champions trophy 2017 which would take place in England this year. champion trophy 2017 schedule
Cahmpion trophy live streaming champion trophy live score and bally ball commentary.

rosy123 said...

Vos partages me plaient beaucoup! C'est super!!!

voyance gratuite par mail rapide

rosi said...

Bravo ! Votre blog est l'un des meilleurs que j'ai vu !
voyance mail

voyante said...

Merci pour le partage.

rosy123 said...

Vraiment sympa ce site web
voyance gratuite

Ashley Massaro said...

estados positivos para whatsapp
Felicitaciones de Navidad 2017
frases bonitas de amor cortas para whatsapp
frases de canserbero
estados de whatsapp

Cricket said...

Thailand Lottery world famous lottery all countries people following this lottery specially India Bangladesh Saudia Arabia and Kuwait official
source

Unknown said...

iWantv! 'ABS-CBN live spilling' appears with only 1 click! – LopezLink. Jan 28, 2010 - iWantv! gives you a chance to get well known shows in video-on-request and live channel groups. The video-on-request choice makes live gushing of iWant television 2.3.2 for Android – Download Dialect. Creator: ABS-CBN. Security level: 100% safe. Estimate: 3.04MB. Downloads: 12,463. Date: 07.29.16. Bundle Name: com.abscbn.iwantv. IWanTV | LoadCentral Philippines Its administrations incorporate Article source and voice, and portable web alongside the restrictive access to ABS-CBN substance through the IWanTV! application. It was propelled on Article source
ABS-CBN Shows, iWanTV, different substance to be accessible to Shrewd. Sep 27, 2016 - To begin with iWant television, PLDT Home and Savvy endorsers can enlist for a record by means of www.iwantv.com.ph or download the iWant television. iWantv!: Online Free television at your own opportunity | penworks | photoblog Nov 8, 2010 - iWantv is an administration allowed to all SKYBROADBAND and BayanDSL endorsers. Facilitating all the top of the line shows of ABS-CBN, ANC, Studio 23. Get Premium Access on iWantTV with Article source 50! | Starmometer. Nov 13, 2016 - Missing a scene of your most loved primetime teleserye in light of terrible movement is presently a thing previously. With ABS-CBN's iWanTV, I can.
Interpret this page. Liza Soberano and Enrique Gil repeat their very much cherished parts as Agnes and Xander as they top bill "Everlastingly and the sky is the limit from there," the main select substance offering on. the most effective method to download recordings from iwantv » YugaTech | Philippines Tech. BayanDSL and Article source is currently offering live gushing television and video-on-request to all it's DSL endorsers and Sky Broadband clients. Accessible channels incorporate. iWanTV Files – LIONHEARTV. More on the web and cell phone clients keep on watching ABS-CBN programs online by means of the video-on-request and livestreaming administration iWanTV. Article source

voyance sérieuse gratuite par mail said...

Quel plaisir d'atterrir sur un blog inattendu,
voyance sérieuse gratuite par mail

Cricket Games said...

It's not surprising that so many people can't see what all the fuss is about when it comes to cricket. Any sport in which two teams can compete for 5 days and still fail to produce a winner does not look likely to ever have much of a worldwide Download Cricket Games From crickethighlights.

rosy123 said...


Un petit pour vous dire que votre blog est super!

tirage carte gratuit amour

Unknown said...

Un petit pour vous dire que votre blog est super!

voyance gratuitement

pinoy Tambayan said...

you are writing well with your skills I want to read more your posts
Pinoy Tambayan

rosi said...


Mille merci pour tout.
Tu es incroyable, mille bisous pour toi.
voyance gratuitement

rosi said...

Merci pour cet article très complet encore une fois
voyante

sarkari job said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
rosy123 said...

Très bon article, comme toujours. Il a le mérite de susciter le commentaire
voyance gratuitement par mail

Uptravi said...

You lose fat but very little and along with the fat you lose muscle and some amount of water. The higher you reduce your calorie intake, the faster you drop weight and the more muscle mass you lose.
Keto Gedeon

Rozy said...

Semen or sperm pills are not designed to enlarge the penis or target stamina. Common ingredients include zinc which is essential for sperm production and Swedish flower pollen as well as other ingredients that enhance sperm quality and sperm count.
Bionatrol Pro Enhance

Rozy said...

weight can improve your sex life. Always consider your basic health, before assuming that you need to take male sex enhancements. These are best used by males who are in optimum health, so that the enhancements can be fully realized sexually.
Ryzex Male Enhancement

Rozy said...

Being healthy has far greater importance than excess skin. Although, having excess skin can lead to some serious issues there are non-surgical ways of preventing infections such as keeping your excess skin dry. For those who are able and want to remove the excess skin,
Keto Trim 800

Soliqua said...

There are many methods available for trying to lose weight. Restrictive diets are among the best-publicized. These include calorie restriction, in an attempt to take in less energy than you expend, as well as diets that restrict food by type, such as low-fat, low-carbohydrate and low-sugar diets.
Rapid Fast Keto Boost

Watson said...

improve your sex life. Always consider your basic health, before assuming that you need to take male sex enhancements. These are best used by males who are in optimum health, so that the enhancements can be fully realized sexually.
Celaxryn RX

Rozy said...

Each person has different experiences with male sex enhancers. Be sure to read about anything before you take it, so that you can understand it's duration, best usage, proper dosage and any potential side effects. Most products are free from such problems, but if you are on heart medications or other possible treatments, be sure to double check that you can safely use natural male enhancers for sexual activity.
Zydenafil

Rozy said...

Both models are simple to setup. The manual control electric golf caddy sets up in one step with a fold design that has an adjustable height mechanism that locks.The remote control electric golf caddy features an easy two-step, one-click setup design.
Electric Back Massager Reviews

rosy123 said...

j ai passé un bon moments et j en ai eue plein les yeux!!!
voyance gratuitement par mail

Rozy said...

I was always fed well prepared, nutritious meals by my parents. I just ate too much. I didn't even realize I was doing this. During my childhood I became used to eating a certain amount of food. I became an habitual overeater. I kept overeating, automatically, and never thought about changing my behavior. Yet, I never did become morbidly obese. I simply continued to
Meta Keto Boost

Rozy said...

Weight Loss Truth: What would a world without chocolate and without pepperoni pizza be like??? I think it would be a torturous world to live in!! lol, now on a real note I completely disagree with this myth. You are definitely able to eat your favorite foods. Depriving yourself of this kind of pleasure is not fun, and quite frankly you probably WILL eat it anyways. As has
Number One Keto

Rozy said...

Will Brink is an author, columnist and expert in the supplement, fitness, bodybuilding, and weight loss industry and has been extensively published. Will graduated from Harvard University with a concentration in the natural sciences.
Keto Shred Biotic Immunity Booster

Rozy said...

(6) Borg P, et al. Food selection and eating behaviour during weight maintenance intervention and 2-y follow-up in obese men.Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord. 2004 Dec;28(12):1548-54.
Keto Shred Biotic Immunity Booster

Rozy said...

Weight loss is one of the hottest topics ever. Everyone seems to be trying to lose weight nowadays. Most diet programs are about weight loss and body weight is often used as an indicator of fitness progress. But, this is an incorrect approach.
Cylophin RX

Ultiva80 said...

There are many ways to have these pills delivered discreetly at your doorstep. The World Wide Web, too, encourages healthy competition with the many brands available. And you don't have to worry much about the cost; unlike prescription drugs and other penis-enlarging paraphernalia, these male enhancement pills do their work at such relatively affordable prices.Formax Lean Male Enhancement

Rozy said...

Due to the reduction of calorie intake during the early periods of using any weight loss product and in particular those especially designed to "supposedly" facilitate quick fat reduction, the body is forced to release and burn its stored glycogen for energy fuel. Glycogen is essentially made up of 75% water and 25% glucose and therefore when glucose is metabolized, water is largely produced as a by-product.
Reliant Keto

Rozy said...

People should also not be scared off by my "you have to eat this way forever" advice. This does not mean you will be dieting for the rest of your life and have nothing but starvation to look forward to. What it does mean, however, is you will have to learn to eat properly even
Vaso Prime RX

Intuniv said...

Even if you falter and veer off your weight loss track, it's OK. If you are able to quickly get back on track you will overtime, reap the benefits of dramatic weight loss and improved health.
Reliant Keto

Udenyca said...

This actually has a common name. We in the fitness industry call this the F.I.T.T principle. Beyond these basics which are usually associated with the exercise components of your program there will also be nutritional requirements to any quality weight loss program that fit perfectly into the same acronym:
Nature Clarity Keto

Harper said...

Other studies comparing other popular diets have come to essentially the same conclusions. For example, a study that compared the Atkins diet, the Ornish diet, Weight Watchers, and The Zone Diet, found them to be essentially the same in their ability to take weight off after one year. (2)
Viadine Male Enhancement

Femara said...

quick weight loss. Not only must you exercise, but you must do so intelligently. There is no need for you to try to kill yourself in the beginning. Instead, it is better for you to take baby steps and to work yourself up to advanced workout routines. The road to a healthy weight loss and quick weight loss will only be as bumpy as you choose to make it!
Bio Jolt Male Enhancement

William said...

I also recommend that you choose a "weigh day" that doesn't contain a cheat meal, as this can often add a pound or two of water that will come out by the end of the following day (my experience, at least).
Keto Now Real

Rozy said...

The muscle you have is not there forever. If you don't feed it and don't use it - you lose it. A proper plan with right combination of resistance and cardiovascular training with adequate progression and a right nutrition plan to support it can help you achieve this. Exercise only Virtus Strong Testo Boost Pro

Unknown said...

Eager cricket fans can Watch Live Cricket Today including all ongoing national and international leagues for free in HD form.